# Firstenergy Corp: Form 10-Q for the period ended Jun 30, 2016

- Company: [Firstenergy Corp](/companies/fe.md) (CIK 1031296)
- Form: 10-Q
- Filed: 2016-07-28
- Accepted by EDGAR: Jul 28, 2016, 20:58 ET
- Period: 2016-06-30
- Accession: 0001031296-16-000102
- Inline XBRL: yes
- Main document: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1031296/000103129616000102/fe-06302016x10q.htm
- All documents and exhibits: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1031296/000103129616000102/

## Figures reported in this filing

Standardized XBRL line items for the period ended 2016-06-30.

| Line item | Period | Value | XBRL concept |
| --- | --- | ---: | --- |
| Revenue | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | $3.40bn | us-gaap:Revenues |
| Revenue | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $7.27bn | us-gaap:Revenues |
| Operating income | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$975.0m | us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss |
| Operating income | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$199.0m | us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss |
| Interest expense | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | $289.0m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Interest expense | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $577.0m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Income tax | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$130.0m | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Income tax | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $83.0m | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Net income | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$1.09bn | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Net income | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$761.0m | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Diluted EPS | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$2.56 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareDiluted |
| Diluted EPS | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$1.79 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareDiluted |
| Basic EPS | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$2.56 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasic |
| Basic EPS | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | −$1.79 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasic |
| Diluted shares (weighted) | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | 425,000,000 shares | us-gaap:WeightedAverageNumberOfDilutedSharesOutstanding |
| Diluted shares (weighted) | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | 424,000,000 shares | us-gaap:WeightedAverageNumberOfDilutedSharesOutstanding |
| Operating cash flow | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $1.46bn | us-gaap:NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities |
| Capital expenditure | 3 months, 2016-04-01 to 2016-06-30 | $794.0m | us-gaap:PaymentsToAcquireProductiveAssets |
| Capital expenditure | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $1.49bn | us-gaap:PaymentsToAcquireProductiveAssets |
| Dividends paid | 6 months, 2016-01-01 to 2016-06-30 | $305.0m | us-gaap:PaymentsOfDividendsCommonStock |
| Cash and equivalents | at 2016-06-30 | $199.0m | us-gaap:CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue |
| Current assets | at 2016-06-30 | $3.08bn | us-gaap:AssetsCurrent |
| Total assets | at 2016-06-30 | $51.40bn | us-gaap:Assets |
| Current liabilities | at 2016-06-30 | $6.76bn | us-gaap:LiabilitiesCurrent |
| Short-term borrowings | at 2016-06-30 | $2.92bn | us-gaap:ShortTermBorrowings |
| Shareholders' equity | at 2016-06-30 | $11.41bn | us-gaap:StockholdersEquity |
| Shares outstanding | at 2016-06-30 | 425,198,228 shares | dei:EntityCommonStockSharesOutstanding |

## Management's discussion and analysis

As filed, 209,746 characters.

### MANAGEMENT’S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS OF

### FINANCIAL CONDITION AND RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

### FIRSTENERGY’S BUSINESS

FirstEnergy and its subsidiaries are principally involved in the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity. Its reportable segments are as follows: Regulated Distribution, Regulated Transmission, and CES.

The **Regulated Distribution** segment distributes electricity through FirstEnergy’s ten utility operating companies, serving approximately six million customers within 65,000 square miles of Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Maryland, New Jersey and New York, and purchases power for its POLR, SOS, SSO and default service requirements in Ohio, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Maryland. This segment also includes regulated electric generation facilities located primarily in West Virginia, Virginia and New Jersey that MP and JCP&L, respectively, own or contractually control. The segment's results reflect the commodity costs of securing electric generation and the deferral and amortization of certain fuel costs. As of June 30, 2016, this business segment controlled 3,790 MWs of generating capacity.

The **Regulated Transmission** segment transmits electricity through transmission facilities owned and operated by ATSI, TrAIL, and certain of FirstEnergy's utilities (JCP&L, ME, PN, MP, PE and WP). This segment also includes the regulatory asset associated with the abandoned PATH project. The segment's revenues are primarily derived from forward-looking rates at ATSI and TrAIL, as well as fixed rates at certain of FirstEnergy’s utilities. Both the forward-looking and fixed rates recover costs and provide a return on transmission capital investment. Under the forward-looking rates, each of ATSI's and TrAIL’s revenue requirement is updated annually based on a projected rate base and projected costs, subject to annual true-up. Except for the recovery of the PATH abandoned project regulatory asset, the segment's revenues are primarily from transmission services provided to LSEs pursuant to the PJM Tariff. The segment's results also reflect the net transmission expenses related to the delivery of electricity on FirstEnergy's transmission facilities.

The **CES** segment, through FES and AE Supply, primarily supplies electricity to end-use customers through retail and wholesale arrangements, including competitive retail sales to customers primarily in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey and Maryland, and the provision of partial POLR and default service for some utilities in Ohio, Pennsylvania and Maryland, including the Utilities. As of June 30, 2016, this business segment controlled 13,162 MWs of generating capacity. The CES segment’s net income is primarily derived from electric generation sales less the related costs of electricity generation, including fuel, purchased power and net transmission (including congestion) and ancillary costs and capacity costs charged by PJM to deliver energy to the segment’s customers.

Corporate support and other businesses that do not constitute an operating segment, interest expense on stand-alone holding company debt and corporate income taxes are categorized as Corporate/Other for reportable business segment purposes. Additionally, reconciling adjustments for the elimination of inter-segment transactions are included in Corporate/Other. As of June 30, 2016, Corporate/Other had $4.2 billion of stand-alone holding company long-term debt, of which 28% was subject to variable-interest rates, and $2.8 billion was borrowed by FE under its revolving credit facility.

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

While competitive markets continue to be challenged by depressed power and capacity prices, FirstEnergy is focused on capitalizing on investment opportunities available in its Regulated Transmission and Regulated Distribution businesses. FirstEnergy’s regulated investment strategy focuses on delivering enhanced customer service and reliability, strengthening grid and cyber-security and adding resiliency and operating flexibility to its transmission and distribution infrastructure. Over time, FirstEnergy will work to reduce its exposure to competitive markets, and ultimately expects to operate as a fully regulated integrated utility company.

#### Regulated Transmission

The centerpiece of FirstEnergy’s regulated investment strategy is the *Energizing the Future* transmission expansion plan. The initial phase of this plan includes $4.2 billion in investments from 2014 through 2017 to modernize FirstEnergy's transmission system. Through 2015, FirstEnergy’s capital expenditures under this plan were $2.4 billion and in 2016 capital expenditures under this plan are projected to be approximately $1.05 billion.

Additionally, in June 2015, JCP&L, PN, ME, FET, and MAIT made filings with FERC, the NJBPU, and the PPUC requesting authorization for JCP&L, PN and ME to contribute their transmission assets to MAIT, which will operate similar to FET’s two existing stand-alone transmission subsidiaries, ATSI and TrAIL. FERC approved the transaction in February 2016 and the PPUC adopted a Motion on July 21, 2016, approving the transaction, subject to the entry of a final order, which is expected in the near future. In February 2016, the NJBPU issued an Order concluding that MAIT does not satisfy the “electricity distribution” element necessary for “public utility” status and in April 2016, JCP&L and MAIT filed a supplemental petition and testimony seeking to include certain

JCP&L distribution assets in the transfer to satisfy the "electricity distribution" element necessary for "public utility" status in accordance with the NJPBU’s February 2016 order. Upon receipt of all applicable regulatory approvals with respect to the transfer, MAIT expects to file a Section 204 application with FERC, and other necessary filings with the PPUC and the NJBPU, seeking authorization to issue equity to FET, JCP&L, PN and ME for their respective contributions, and to issue debt. MAIT will also make a Section 205 formula rate application with FERC to establish its transmission rate.

#### Regulated Distribution

During the second quarter of 2016, FirstEnergy continued to pursue key regulatory initiatives across its utility footprint, focusing on providing significant benefits to customers while ensuring the timely and appropriate recovery of investments. These initiatives included:

- On February 11, 2016, the PPUC approved the Pennsylvania Companies' LTIIPs for infrastructure improvements over the 2016-2020 period totaling nearly $245 million. On June 9, 2016, the PPUC approved the Pennsylvania Companies’ DSIC riders to be effective July 1, 2016, subject to hearings and refund or reallocation among customers.
- The Ohio Companies’ ESP IV, *Powering Ohio’s Progress*, was approved by the PUCO on March 31, 2016, with certain modifications and included an Economic Stability Program that flows through charges or credits through Rider RRS representing the net result of the price paid to FES through an eight-year FERC-jurisdictional PPA, referred to as the ESP IV PPA, for the output of the ESP IV PPA Facilities against the revenues received from selling such output into the PJM markets. On April 1, 2016, the Ohio Companies and FES entered into the ESP IV PPA. However, on April 27, 2016, FERC issued an order prohibiting any transactions under the ESP IV PPA pending future authorization by FERC and directed FES to submit the ESP IV PPA for FERC review if the companies desired to transact under the agreement. FES did not file the ESP IV PPA for FERC review but rather agreed to suspend the ESP IV PPA prior to transacting thereunder, pending the outcome of the PUCO and FERC proceedings.

On April 29, 2016 and May 2, 2016, applications for rehearing on the Ohio Companies ESP IV were filed with the PUCO by several parties, including the Ohio Companies. As part of the Ohio Companies’ application for rehearing, the Ohio Companies proposed a modified Rider RRS. The PUCO issued an Entry on Rehearing on May 11, 2016 granting the applications for rehearing for the purpose of further consideration of the matters raised therein. On June 29, 2016, PUCO Staff filed testimony recommending that the Ohio Companies’ modified Rider RRS proposal be denied, and instead recommended a new Distribution Modernization Rider providing for the collection of $131 million annually for three years with a possible extension for an additional two years. The hearing began on July 11, 2016 for the modified Rider RRS proposal. On July 25, 2016, the Ohio Companies filed testimony that continues to recommend that the PUCO approve the proposed modified Rider RRS and that the revenues and expenses of the proposed modified Rider RRS be excluded from the significantly excessive earnings test. The Ohio Companies' filing also provided testimony that a properly designed Distribution Modernization Rider would be valued at $558 million annually for 8 years, include an additional amount, as determined by the PUCO, that recognizes the value of the economic impact of FirstEnergy maintaining its headquarters in Ohio, and would also be excluded from the significantly excessive earnings test.

Several parties filed protests and comments at FERC alleging, among other things, that the modified Rider RRS constitutes a "virtual PPA". The filings and responses thereto are pending before FERC.

- On April 28, 2016, JCP&L filed tariffs with the NJBPU proposing a general rate increase associated with its distribution operations that seeks to improve service and benefit customers by supporting equipment maintenance, tree trimming, and inspections of lines, poles and substations, while also compensating for other business and operating expenses. The filing requested approval to increase annual operating revenues by approximately $142.1 million based upon a hybrid test year for the twelve months ending June 30, 2016. JCP&L requested that the proposed new rates take effect in January 2017. On July 13, 2016, this matter was submitted to the Office of Administrative Law for hearing and the issuance of an Initial Decision. A procedural schedule has not yet been issued.
- On April 28, 2016, each of the Pennsylvania Companies filed tariffs with the PPUC proposing general rate increases associated with their distribution operations that will benefit customers by modernizing the grid with smart technologies, increasing vegetation management activities, and continuing other customer service enhancements. The filings request approval to increase annual operating revenues by approximately $140.2 million at ME, $158.8 million at PN, $42.0 million at Penn, and $98.2 million at WP, based upon fully projected future test years for the twelve months ending December 31, 2017 at each of the Pennsylvania Companies. As a result of Act 40 of 2016, the Pennsylvania Companies submitted testimony on July 7, 2016, quantifying the value of the elimination of the CTA and outlined their plan for investing 50% of that amount in rate base eligible equipment as required by the new law. A procedural schedule has been set with hearings commencing on September 6, 2016. The proposed new rates are expected to take effect in January 2017, pending regulatory approval.

#### Competitive Energy Services

With the present forward market indicators, it is anticipated that CES will produce approximately 70 to 75 million MWHs of electricity annually, with up to an additional five million MWHs available from purchased power agreements for wind, solar and CES' entitlement in OVEC. In 2017 and going forward, CES expects to hedge 75% - 85% of its generation output by targeting approximately 50 to 65 million MWHs in annual contract sales and maintaining up to 25 million MWHs as reserve margin. For the period July 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016, CES’ generation supply, including committed purchases, is 100% hedged against committed sales assuming normal weather conditions. Contractual sales obligations for the periods July 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016 and 2017 are approximately 31 million MWHs and 51 million MWHs, respectively.

CES considers a variety of factors, including wholesale power prices, in its decision to operate, or not operate, a generating plant. If wholesale power prices represent a lower cost option, CES may fulfill its load obligation through purchasing electricity in the wholesale market as opposed to operating a generating plant. The effect of this economic decision would be to displace higher per unit fuel expense with lower per unit purchased power.

During the second quarter of 2016 PJM conducted the BRA for the 2019/2020 delivery year. FirstEnergy’s net competitive capacity position as a result of PJM’s BRAs and Capacity Performance transition auctions is as follows:

|  | 2016 - 2017\* Legacy Obligation (MW) | ($/MWD) | Capacity Performance (MW) | ($/MWD) | 2017 - 2018\* Legacy Obligation (MW) | ($/MWD) | Capacity Performance (MW) | ($/MWD) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| **ATSI** | 2,765 | $114.23 | 4,210 | $134.00 | 375 | $120.00 | 6,245 | $151.50 |
| **RTO** | 875 | $59.37 | 3,675 | $134.00 | 985 | $120.00 | 3,565 | $151.50 |
| **All Other Zones** | 135 | $119.13 | — | $134.00 | 150 | $120.00 | — | $151.50 |
|  | 3,775 |  | 7,885 |  | 1,510 |  | 9,810 |  |

|  | 2018 - 2019\* Base Generation (MW) | ($/MWD) | Capacity Performance (MW) | ($/MWD) | 2019 - 2020\* Base Generation (MW) | ($/MWD) | Capacity Performance (MW) | ($/MWD) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| **ATSI** | — | $149.98 | 6,245 | $164.77 | — | $80.00 | 5,680 | $100.00 |
| **RTO** | 240 | $149.98 | 3,930 | $164.77 | 245 | $80.00 | 3,691 | $100.00 |
| **All Other Zones** | 35 | \*\* | 20 | \*\* | 37 | \*\*\* | 18 | \*\*\* |
|  | 275 |  | 10,195 |  | 282 |  | 9,389 |  |

\*Approximately 790 MWs, 130 MWs, 885 MWs and 667 MWs remain uncommitted for the delivery years 2016/2017, 2017/2018, 2018/2019 and 2019/2020, respectively.

\*\*Base Generation: 10 MWs cleared at $200.21/MWD and 25 MWs cleared at $149.98/MWD. Capacity Performance: 5 MWs cleared at $215.00/MWD and 15 MWs cleared at $164.77/MWD.

\*\*\*Base Generation: 13 MWs cleared at $182.77/MWD and 24 MWs cleared at $80.00/MWD. Capacity Performance: 5 MWs cleared at $100.00/MWD and 13 MWs cleared at $202.77/MWD.

*Projected Capacity Revenue\* (In millions)*

|  | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 (through 5/31) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| **CES** | $815 | $590 | $620 | $465 | $147 |
| **FES** | $695 | $470 | $475 | $355 | $115 |

\*Includes revenues from the results of incremental/transitional capacity auctions, bilateral transactions and capacity transfer rights.

Current market dynamics continue to challenge FirstEnergy’s competitive generation fleet, including FES, and CES continues to evaluate its overall generation business, including plant operations, capital investments, and operation and maintenance expenses, in light of the continued pressure on energy and capacity prices.

On July 22, 2016, FirstEnergy announced its intent to exit the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station (136 MW) by October 1, 2020 either through sale or deactivation, and to deactivate Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station (720 MW) by May 31, 2020. These decisions resulted in impairment charges to write-off assets of $150 million and $497 million, respectively, in the second quarter of 2016. While FirstEnergy and FES made the decision to sell or deactivate the unit at Bay Shore and deactivate Sammis Units 1-4, deactivation is subject to review by PJM.

Additionally, as a result of low capacity prices associated with the 2019/2020 PJM Base Residual Auction as well as an update to CES’ fundamental long-term capacity and energy price forecast, FE recognized a goodwill impairment charge of $800 million, representing the total amount of goodwill at CES as well as valuation allowances against state and local NOL carryforwards of $159 million that management believes, more likely than not, will not be realized based primarily on projected taxable income reflecting CES’ updated fundamental long-term pricing model and certain statutory limitations on the utilization of state and local NOL carryforwards.

FirstEnergy believes that a combination of distribution, transmission and generation assets in a regulated model is the best way to serve customers, and continues to evaluate alternative options that would de-risk the competitive generation fleet and convert MWs from competitive markets to a regulated or regulated-like construct. In particular, FirstEnergy will monitor legislative efforts aimed at maintaining important baseload generation in various states, including Ohio and New York. FirstEnergy also plans to work with the WVPSC as they address the generation shortfall included in Mon Power’s IRP.

At the same time, FirstEnergy will continue to advocate for reforms that ensure competitive wholesale markets adequately value baseload generation, which is essential to maintaining grid reliability. If these options are not possible, are only possible for a portion of the CES fleet or market conditions continue to be depressed, FirstEnergy may consider other options, including the sale or deactivation of generating plants. No assurance can be given, however, that any such options will be realized.

CES, including FES, will continue to review the economics of all generating units on an ongoing basis, and is expected to be cash flow positive 2016 through 2018 each year, with the ability to reinvest in its own business and cover currently anticipated capital expenditures during that time. FirstEnergy does not intend to infuse additional equity into CES, including FES, in order to support that segment’s credit ratings. CES identified additional fuel savings for 2017 and 2018 of $80 million each year, beyond those announced as part of the CFIP initiative. Furthermore, CES, including FES, delayed its Beaver Valley Unit 2 steam generator replacement project from 2020 to 2023. CES, including FES, will continue to invest in its nuclear units in order to maintain safe and reliable operations in accordance with nuclear industry standards. Market conditions will continue to impact capital investments in the fossil fleet, with current conditions favoring limited investments.

Competitive markets continue to challenge coal and nuclear baseload generation within FirstEnergy’s footprint. Because CES, including FES, is subject to wholesale market prices and capacity auction prices, which continue to be depressed, FirstEnergy and CES', including FES', future results of operations and financial condition could be negatively and materially impacted.

### FINANCIAL OVERVIEW

*(In millions, except per share amounts)*

|  | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Change |  | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Change |  |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| **REVENUES:** | $3,401 | $3,465 | $(64) | (2)% | $7,270 | $7,362 | $(92) | (1)% |
| **OPERATING EXPENSES:** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 438 | 383 | 55 | 14% | 819 | 896 | (77) | (9)% |
| Purchased power | 889 | 989 | (100) | (10)% | 2,013 | 2,102 | (89) | (4)% |
| Other operating expenses | 964 | 900 | 64 | 7% | 1,882 | 1,957 | (75) | (4)% |
| Provision for depreciation | 334 | 322 | 12 | 4% | 663 | 641 | 22 | 3% |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 63 | 59 | 4 | 7% | 124 | 91 | 33 | 36% |
| General taxes | 241 | 242 | (1) | —% | 521 | 511 | 10 | 2% |
| Impairment of assets | 1,447 | 16 | 1,431 | NM | 1,447 | 16 | 1,431 | NM |
| Total operating expenses | 4,376 | 2,911 | 1,465 | 50% | 7,469 | 6,214 | 1,255 | 20% |
| **OPERATING INCOME (LOSS)** | (975) | 554 | (1,529) | NM | (199) | 1,148 | (1,347) | NM |
| **OTHER INCOME (EXPENSE):** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income (loss) | 19 | (3) | 22 | NM | 47 | 14 | 33 | NM |
| Interest expense | (289) | (282) | (7) | 2% | (577) | (561) | (16) | 3% |
| Capitalized financing costs | 26 | 33 | (7) | (21)% | 51 | 67 | (16) | (24)% |
| Total other expense | (244) | (252) | 8 | (3)% | (479) | (480) | 1 | —% |
| **INCOME (LOSS) BEFORE INCOME TAXES (BENEFITS)** | (1,219) | 302 | (1,521) | NM | (678) | 668 | (1,346) | NM |
| **INCOME TAXES (BENEFITS)** | (130) | 115 | (245) | NM | 83 | 259 | (176) | (68)% |
| **NET INCOME (LOSS)** | $(1,089) | $187 | $(1,276) | NM | $(761) | $409 | $(1,170) | NM |
| **EARNINGS (LOSSES) PER SHARE OF COMMON STOCK:** |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| Basic | $(2.56) | $0.44 | $(3.00) | NM | $(1.79) | $0.97 | $(2.76) | NM |
| Diluted | $(2.56) | $0.44 | $(3.00) | NM | $(1.79) | $0.97 | $(2.76) | NM |

#### NM - Not Meaningful

### For the Three Months Ended June 30, 2016

FirstEnergy’s net loss in the second quarter of 2016 was $(1,089) million, or a basic and diluted loss of $(2.56) per share of common stock, compared with net income of $187 million, or basic and diluted earnings of $0.44 per share of common stock in the second quarter of 2015.

As further discussed below, FirstEnergy’s second quarter 2016 operating results decreased $1,276 million as compared to the second quarter of 2015, primarily resulting from asset impairment and plant exit costs consisting of:

- Non-cash impairment charges of $800 million associated with goodwill at CES,
- Non-cash impairment charges of $647 million associated with the announced plan to exit operations by 2020 of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station (720 MW) and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station (136 MW),
- Coal contract settlement and termination costs of $58 million, and
- Valuation allowances against state and local NOL carryforwards of $159 million.

During the second quarter of 2016, FirstEnergy’s revenues decreased $64 million as compared to the same period in 2015, resulting from an $80 million decrease at CES, a $39 million decrease at Regulated Distribution, and a $5 million decrease at Regulated Transmission.

- The decrease in revenue at CES resulted from a 4 million MWHs decline in contract sales as the segment continues to align its sales to its generation. The decline in contract sales volume was partially offset by higher wholesale sales and increased capacity revenue associated with higher capacity auction prices.
- The decrease in revenue at Regulated Distribution resulted from lower regulated generation sales volumes due to increased customer shopping as well as lower industrial usage in West Virginia. The declines in regulated generation sales volumes were partially offset by the impact of rate increases at the Pennsylvania companies implemented in May of 2015 as a result of approved rate cases.
- The decrease in revenue at Regulated Transmission primarily reflected adjustments associated with ATSI's and TrAIL's annual rate filing for costs previously recovered as well as a lower ROE at ATSI under its FERC-approved comprehensive settlement related to the implementation of a forward-looking rate, partially offset by higher recovery of incremental operating expenses and a higher asset base at ATSI and TrAIL.

Operating expenses increased $1,465 million in the second quarter of 2016 as compared to the second quarter of 2015, reflecting an increase at CES of $1,414 million and Regulated Transmission of $17 million, partially offset by a decrease at Regulated Distribution of $22 million. Changes in certain operating expenses include the following:

- Fuel expense increased $55 million primarily resulting from settlement and termination costs on coal contracts recognized in the second quarter of 2016 at CES as well as higher generation at CES' and Regulated Distribution.
- Purchased power decreased $100 million due to lower required volumes at Regulated Distribution as a result of higher customer shopping as well as lower volumes at CES associated with lower contract sales.
- Other operating expenses increased $64 million, primarily reflecting an increase of $42 million at Regulated Distribution associated with higher transmission expenses and retirement benefit costs and an increase at CES due to mark-to-market losses on commodity contract positions.
- Impairment of assets increased $1,431 million due to impairment charges at CES associated with goodwill ($800 million) and the announcement to exit operations of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station ($497 million) and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station ($150 million).

FirstEnergy’s effective tax rate was 10.7% for the three months ended June 30, 2016 compared to 38.1% for the same period in 2015. The change in the effective tax rate resulted from an $800 million goodwill impairment, of which $433 million is non-deductible for tax purposes, as well as valuation allowances recorded in the second quarter of 2016 relating to state and local NOL carryforwards that management believes, more likely than not, will not be realized based primarily on projected taxable income reflecting updates to FirstEnergy's fundamental long-term pricing model for energy and capacity in the second quarter of 2016 as well as certain statutory limitations on the utilization of state and local NOL carryforwards.

### For the Six Months Ended June 30, 2016

For the six months ended June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy's net loss was $(761) million, or a basic and diluted loss of $(1.79) per share of common stock, compared to net income of $409 million, or basic and diluted earnings of $0.97 per share of common stock for the six months ended June 30, 2015.

FirstEnergy's 2016 year-to-date earnings decreased $1,170 million as compared to the same period of 2015 primarily reflecting asset impairment and plant exit costs discussed above.

During the first six months of 2016, FirstEnergy’s revenues decreased $92 million as compared to the same period in 2015, resulting from a $211 million decrease at CES and a $80 million decrease at Regulated Distribution, partially offset by an increase of $32 million at Regulated Transmission.

- The decrease in revenue at CES resulted from an 11 million MWHs decline in contract sales as the segment continues to align its sales to its generation. The decline in contract sales volume was partially offset by higher wholesale sales and increased capacity revenue associated with higher capacity auction prices.
- The decrease in revenue at Regulated Distribution resulted from lower distribution deliveries to residential and commercial customers resulting from decreased weather-related usage and lower average customer usage associated with more energy efficient products and services as well as lower deliveries to industrial customers. Regulated generation sales volumes were also lower year-over-year due to increased customer shopping and lower industrial usage in West Virginia. These declines were partially offset by the impact of net rate increases implemented in the first six months of 2015 as a result of approved rate cases at certain operating companies.
- The increase in revenue at Regulated Transmission primarily reflected higher recovery of incremental operating expenses and higher rate base at ATSI and TrAIL, partially offset by adjustments associated with ATSI and TrAIL's annual rate filing for costs previously recovered as well as a lower ROE at ATSI under its FERC-approved comprehensive settlement related to the implementation of a forward-looking rate.

Operating expenses increased $1,255 million during the first six months of 2016 as compared to 2015, reflecting an increase at CES of $1,047 million and Regulated Transmission of $40 million. Changes in certain operating expenses include the following:

- Fuel expense decreased $77 million resulting from lower generation at CES associated with outages and economic dispatch of fossil units.
- Purchased power decreased $89 million due to lower volumes.
- Other operating expenses decreased $75 million, reflecting a decrease of $177 million at CES resulting from lower transmission expenses and higher mark-to-market gains on commodity contract positions, partially offset by an increase of $93 million at Regulated Distribution resulting from the recognition of economic development and energy efficiency obligations in accordance with the PUCO’s March 31 Opinion and Order adopting and approving, with modifications, the Ohio Company’s ESP IV as well as higher retirement costs.
- Impairment of assets increased $1,431 million as further described above.

FirstEnergy’s effective tax rate was (12.2)% for the six months ended June 30, 2016 compared to 38.8% for the same period in 2015. The decline in the effective tax rate resulted from the $800 million goodwill impairment, of which $433 million is non-deductible for tax purposes, as well as valuation allowances against state and local NOL carryforwards recorded in the second quarter of 2016 as further described above.

### 2016 Full Year Outlook

For 2016, FirstEnergy’s financial results will be significantly impacted by asset impairment and plant exit costs at its competitive business primarily associated with the impairment of goodwill, the impairment of Bay Shore Unit 1 and W. H. Sammis Units 1-4, and other costs associated with the deactivation of certain power plants as well as valuation allowances against state and local NOL carryforwards, all of which were recognized in the second quarter of 2016 and are discussed above. The below represents a summary of the key assumptions and drivers that management expects will impact full year 2016 results of operations, by segment. However, no assurances can be made that such assumptions and drivers will materialize and actual results may vary. See the “Forward-Looking Statements” section above.

#### Regulated Transmission

- Increased transmission revenue associated with increased investments at ATSI and TrAIL, partially offset by a lower ROE at ATSI. The lower ROE at ATSI is the result of its FERC-approved comprehensive settlement related to the implementation of its forward-looking rate. The ROE at ATSI for 2016 is 10.38% and compares to 12.38% for the period January 1, 2015 to June 30, 2015 and 11.06% from July 1, 2015 to December 31, 2015.
- As part of FirstEnergy’s *Energizing the Future* transmission expansion plan, 2016 forecasted capital expenditures are $1.05 billion of which approximately $715 million will be within ATSI and TrAIL and subject to their forward-looking rates with the remaining capital expenditures of $335 million to be within the Utilities' transmission system.

#### Regulated Distribution

- Distribution deliveries of 146.4 million MWH in 2016 (assumes normal weather) versus 148.4 million MWH in 2015, resulting from lower weather-related usage and declining average customer usage associated with more energy efficient products and services.
- Increased revenues from the full year impact of approved distribution rate increases for the Pennsylvania Companies (effective May 3, 2015) and higher DCR revenues at the Ohio Companies in connection with their ESP IV, partially offset by the full year impact of an approved distribution rate decrease at JCP&L (effective April 1, 2015).
- Lower operation and maintenance expenses as the business continues its focus on cost management.
- Increased depreciation and property taxes as a result of a higher asset base.
- Increased Pension/OPEB expense primarily due to lower amortization of prior service credits and higher pension financing costs.
- Increased regulatory charges primarily reflecting the Ohio Companies’ recognition of economic development and energy efficiency obligations in accordance with the PUCO's March 31 Opinion and Order adopting and approving, with modifications, their ESP IV.
- Capital expenditures for 2016 are forecasted to be approximately $1.3 billion primarily associated with reliability improvements.

#### Competitive Energy Services

- Lower CES capacity revenue resulting from lower capacity rates as discussed above.
- Decreased operation and maintenance expenses primarily resulting from two nuclear refueling outages in 2016 versus three in 2015 and lower retail related costs.
- Increased Pension/OPEB expense primarily due to lower amortization of prior service credits and higher pension financing costs.
- Asset impairment and plant exit costs as a result of an impairment of goodwill ($800 million pre-tax), the impairment of Bay Shore Unit 1 and W. H. Sammis Units 1-4 generating stations ($647 million pre-tax), and other costs associated with the deactivation of certain power plants.
- Lower tax benefits on forecasted pre-tax losses associated with valuation allowances against state and local NOL carryforwards of $159 million and the impact of the impairment of goodwill of which $433 million was non-deductible for tax purposes.
- Capital expenditures for 2016 are forecasted to be $545 million.

#### Corporate / Other

- Higher net financing costs primarily due to higher interest expense.
- Reduced tax benefits on uncertain tax positions.
- Capital expenditures for 2016 are forecasted to be $85 million.

Additionally, in 2015, the Regulated Distribution and CES segments recognized pre-tax pension and OPEB mark-to-market charges associated with changes in the fair value of plan assets and net actuarial gains and losses of $179 million and $60 million, respectively. At this time, FirstEnergy is unable to determine or project the mark-to-market adjustment that may be recorded as of December 31, 2016.

### RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

The financial results discussed below include revenues and expenses from transactions among FirstEnergy’s segments. A reconciliation of segment financial results is provided in Note 14, Segment Information, of the Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements. Certain prior year amounts have been reclassified to conform to the current year presentation.

### Summary of Results of Operations — Second Quarter 2016 Compared with Second Quarter 2015

Financial results for FirstEnergy’s business segments in the second quarter of 2016 and 2015 were as follows:

*(In millions)*

| Second Quarter 2016 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $2,147 | $264 | $963 | $(43) | $3,331 |
| Other | 53 | — | 45 | (28) | 70 |
| Internal | — | — | 108 | (108) | — |
| Total Revenues | 2,200 | 264 | 1,116 | (179) | 3,401 |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 141 | — | 297 | — | 438 |
| Purchased power | 721 | — | 276 | (108) | 889 |
| Other operating expenses | 580 | 36 | 432 | (84) | 964 |
| Provision for depreciation | 170 | 44 | 103 | 17 | 334 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 61 | 2 | — | — | 63 |
| General taxes | 170 | 36 | 29 | 6 | 241 |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 1,447 | — | 1,447 |
| Total Operating Expenses | 1,843 | 118 | 2,584 | (169) | 4,376 |
| Operating Income (Loss) | 357 | 146 | (1,468) | (10) | (975) |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | 13 | — | 18 | (12) | 19 |
| Interest expense | (145) | (42) | (48) | (54) | (289) |
| Capitalized financing costs | 5 | 9 | 9 | 3 | 26 |
| Total Other Expense | (127) | (33) | (21) | (63) | (244) |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | 230 | 113 | (1,489) | (73) | (1,219) |
| Income taxes (benefits) | 84 | 42 | (230) | (26) | (130) |
| Net Income (Loss) | $146 | $71 | $(1,259) | $(47) | $(1,089) |

61

*(In millions)*

| Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $2,189 | $269 | $980 | $(43) | $3,395 |
| Other | 50 | — | 54 | (34) | 70 |
| Internal | — | — | 162 | (162) | — |
| Total Revenues | 2,239 | 269 | 1,196 | (239) | 3,465 |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 120 | — | 263 | — | 383 |
| Purchased power | 806 | — | 345 | (162) | 989 |
| Other operating expenses | 538 | 35 | 411 | (84) | 900 |
| Provision for depreciation | 170 | 38 | 99 | 15 | 322 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 57 | 2 | — | — | 59 |
| General taxes | 174 | 26 | 36 | 6 | 242 |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 16 | — | 16 |
| Total Operating Expenses | 1,865 | 101 | 1,170 | (225) | 2,911 |
| Operating Income | 374 | 168 | 26 | (14) | 554 |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | 12 | — | — | (15) | (3) |
| Interest expense | (146) | (40) | (48) | (48) | (282) |
| Capitalized financing costs | 7 | 13 | 10 | 3 | 33 |
| Total Other Expense | (127) | (27) | (38) | (60) | (252) |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | 247 | 141 | (12) | (74) | 302 |
| Income taxes (benefits) | 91 | 52 | (4) | (24) | 115 |
| Net Income (Loss) | $156 | $89 | $(8) | $(50) | $187 |

62

*(In millions)*

| Changes Between Second Quarter 2016 and Second Quarter 2015 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $(42) | $(5) | $(17) | $— | $(64) |
| Other | 3 | — | (9) | 6 | — |
| Internal | — | — | (54) | 54 | — |
| Total Revenues | (39) | (5) | (80) | 60 | (64) |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 21 | — | 34 | — | 55 |
| Purchased power | (85) | — | (69) | 54 | (100) |
| Other operating expenses | 42 | 1 | 21 | — | 64 |
| Provision for depreciation | — | 6 | 4 | 2 | 12 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 4 | — | — | — | 4 |
| General taxes | (4) | 10 | (7) | — | (1) |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 1,431 | — | 1,431 |
| Total Operating Expenses | (22) | 17 | 1,414 | 56 | 1,465 |
| Operating Income (Loss) | (17) | (22) | (1,494) | 4 | (1,529) |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | 1 | — | 18 | 3 | 22 |
| Interest expense | 1 | (2) | — | (6) | (7) |
| Capitalized financing costs | (2) | (4) | (1) | — | (7) |
| Total Other Expense | — | (6) | 17 | (3) | 8 |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | (17) | (28) | (1,477) | 1 | (1,521) |
| Income taxes (benefits) | (7) | (10) | (226) | (2) | (245) |
| Net Income (Loss) | $(10) | $(18) | $(1,251) | $3 | $(1,276) |

63

### Regulated Distribution — Second Quarter 2016 Compared with Second Quarter 2015

Regulated Distribution's net income decreased $10 million in the second quarter of 2016 as compared to the same period of 2015, reflecting increasing retirement benefit costs and lower distribution deliveries associated with a decline in average customer usage. Partially offsetting the decrease were rate increases implemented in May of 2015 as a result of approved rate cases at the Pennsylvania operating companies.

#### Revenues —

The $39 million decrease in total revenues resulted from the following sources:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Type of Service | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Distribution services | $1,105 | $1,089 | $16 |
| Generation sales: |  |  |  |
| Retail | 922 | 970 | (48) |
| Wholesale | 120 | 130 | (10) |
| Total generation sales | 1,042 | 1,100 | (58) |
| Other | 53 | 50 | 3 |
| Total Revenues | $2,200 | $2,239 | $(39) |

Distribution services revenues increased $16 million primarily resulting from an increase associated with approved base distribution rate increases in Pennsylvania, effective May 2015, partially offset by a decline in MWH deliveries, described below. Additionally, distribution revenues were impacted by higher rates associated with the recovery of deferred costs. Distribution deliveries by customer class are summarized in the following table:

*(In thousands)*

| Electric Distribution MWH Deliveries | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Residential | 11,656 | 11,839 | (1.5)% |
| Commercial | 10,349 | 10,411 | (0.6)% |
| Industrial | 12,346 | 12,688 | (2.7)% |
| Other | 145 | 145 | —% |
| Total Electric Distribution MWH Deliveries | 34,496 | 35,083 | (1.7)% |

Lower distribution deliveries to residential and commercial customers primarily reflect declining average customer usage associated with more energy efficient products and services. Weather-related usage was flat as decreased usage resulting from cooling degree days that were 13% below 2015, and 11% above normal, was offset by heating degree days that were 32% above 2015, and 8% above normal. Deliveries to industrial customers continue to decline as the increase from shale customer usage was more than offset by a decrease from steel customer usage.

The following table summarizes the price and volume factors contributing to the $58 million decrease in generation revenues for the second quarter of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015:

*(In millions)*

| Source of Change in Generation Revenues Retail: | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: |
| Effect of decrease in sales volumes | $(61) |
| Change in prices | 13 |
|  | (48) |
| Wholesale: |  |
| Effect of increase in sales volumes | 17 |
| Change in prices | (27) |
|  | (10) |
| Decrease in Generation Revenues | $(58) |

The decrease in retail generation sales volumes was primarily due to increased customer shopping in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey as well as lower industrial usage in West Virginia, as described above. Total generation provided by alternative suppliers as a percentage of total MWH deliveries increased to 82% from 80% for the Ohio Companies, to 69% from 67% for the Pennsylvania Companies, and to 54% from 52% for JCP&L. The increase in retail generation prices primarily resulted from an ENEC rate increase in West Virginia, effective January 1, 2016.

The decrease in wholesale generation revenues of $10 million in the second quarter of 2016, as compared to the same period in 2015, reflects lower spot market energy prices, partially offset by higher wholesale sales. The difference between current wholesale generation revenues and certain energy costs incurred are deferred for future recovery or refund, with no material impact to earnings.

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses decreased $22 million primarily due to the following:

- Fuel expense increased $21 million in the second quarter of 2016, as compared to the same period in 2015, primarily related to higher generation.
- Purchased power costs were $85 million lower in the second quarter of 2016, as compared to the same period in 2015, primarily due to decreased volumes reflecting increased customer shopping, as described above.

*(In millions)*

| Source of Change in Purchased Power Purchases from non-affiliates: | Increase(Decrease) |
| --- | ---: |
| Change due to increased unit costs | $11 |
| Change due to decreased volumes | (29) |
|  | (18) |
| Purchases from affiliates: |  |
| Change due to increased unit costs | 4 |
| Change due to decreased volumes | (59) |
|  | (55) |
| Capacity Expense | (3) |
| Amortization of deferred costs | (9) |
| Decrease in Purchased Power Costs | $(85) |

- Other operating expenses increased $42 million primarily due to:
- Higher transmission expenses of $22 million primarily due to an increase in network transmission expenses at the Ohio Companies. The difference between current revenues and transmission costs incurred are deferred for future recovery or refund, resulting in no material impact on current period earnings.
- Higher retirement benefit costs of $12 million.
- Net amortization of regulatory assets increased $4 million primarily due to recovery of storm costs in Pennsylvania and vegetation management program costs in West Virginia, partially offset by higher deferral of Ohio network transmission expenses.

#### Income Taxes —

Regulated Distribution’s effective tax rate was 36.5% and 36.8% for the quarter ended June 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively.

### Regulated Transmission — Second Quarter 2016 Compared with Second Quarter 2015

Net income decreased $18 million in the second quarter of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015 reflecting lower transmission revenues, as described below, and increased net financing costs.

#### Revenues —

Total revenues decreased $5 million principally due to adjustments associated with ATSI's and TrAIL's annual rate filing for costs previously recovered as well as a lower ROE at ATSI under its FERC-approved comprehensive settlement related to the implementation of a forward-looking rate, partially offset by higher recovery of incremental operating expenses and a higher rate base at ATSI and TrAIL.

Revenues by transmission asset owner are shown in the following table:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Transmission Asset Owner | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| ATSI | $128 | $127 | $1 |
| TrAIL | 59 | 65 | (6) |
| PATH | 3 | 3 | — |
| Utilities | 74 | 74 | — |
| Total Revenues | $264 | $269 | $(5) |

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses increased $17 million principally due to higher property taxes and depreciation expense at ATSI, which are recovered through ATSI's formula rate.

#### Other Expense —

Total other expense increased $6 million in the second quarter of 2016 as compared to the same period of 2015 primarily due to lower capitalized financing costs of $4 million resulting from lower construction work in progress balances at ATSI as well as increased interest expense resulting from debt issuances of $150 million at ATSI in the fourth quarter of 2015, the proceeds of which, in part, paid off short-term borrowings.

#### Income Taxes —

Regulated Transmission’s effective tax rate was 37.2% and 36.9% for the quarter ended June 30, 2016 and 2015, respectively.

### CES — Second Quarter 2016 Compared with Second Quarter 2015

Operating results decreased $1,251 million in the second quarter of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily resulting from charges associated with the impairments of goodwill, Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station as discussed above, higher net mark-to-market losses on commodity contract positions and termination and settlement costs on coal contracts, as discussed below. Operating results were also impacted by higher capacity revenues from higher capacity auction prices, lower unit prices for fuel and lower purchased power, partially offset by lower sales volumes.

#### Revenues —

Total revenues decreased $80 million in the second quarter of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower sales volumes resulting from the continuation of CES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. Revenues were also impacted by higher capacity revenues and higher net gains on financially settled contracts, as further described below.

The change in total revenues resulted from the following sources:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Type of Service Contract Sales: | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $196 | $324 | $(128) |
| Governmental Aggregation | 191 | 218 | (27) |
| Mass Market | 37 | 61 | (24) |
| POLR | 125 | 169 | (44) |
| Structured Sales | 115 | 126 | (11) |
| Total Contract Sales | 664 | 898 | (234) |
| Wholesale | 389 | 216 | 173 |
| Transmission | 18 | 28 | (10) |
| Other | 45 | 54 | (9) |
| **Total Revenues** | $1,116 | $1,196 | $(80) |

*(In thousands)*

| MWH Sales by Channel Contract Sales: | For the Three Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | 3,684 | 6,070 | (39.3)% |
| Governmental Aggregation | 2,991 | 3,453 | (13.4)% |
| Mass Market | 536 | 905 | (40.8)% |
| POLR | 2,081 | 2,920 | (28.7)% |
| Structured Sales | 2,842 | 2,808 | 1.2% |
| Total Contract Sales | 12,134 | 16,156 | (24.9)% |
| Wholesale | 3,577 | 804 | NM |
| **Total MWH Sales** | 15,711 | 16,960 | (7.4)% |

#### NM - Not Meaningful

The following table summarizes the price and volume factors contributing to changes in revenues:

*(In millions)*

| MWH Sales Channel: | Source of Change in Revenues Increase (Decrease) Sales Volumes | Prices | Gain on Settled Contracts | Capacity Revenue | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $(127) | $(1) | $— | $— | $(128) |
| Governmental Aggregation | (29) | 2 | — | — | (27) |
| Mass Market | (25) | 1 | — | — | (24) |
| POLR | (48) | 4 | — | — | (44) |
| Structured Sales | 2 | (13) | — | — | (11) |
| Wholesale | 88 | (24) | 51 | 58 | 173 |

Lower sales volumes in Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market channels primarily reflects the continuation of CES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. The Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market customer base was 1.5 million as of June 30, 2016, compared to 1.9 million as of June 30, 2015.

The decrease in POLR sales of $44 million was due to lower volumes, partially offset by higher rates associated with recent POLR auctions. Structured Sales decreased $11 million primarily due to the impact of lower market prices, partially offset by higher structured transaction volumes.

Wholesale revenues increased $173 million, primarily due to an increase in capacity revenue from higher capacity auction prices, gains on financially settled contracts and an increase in short-term (net hourly position) transactions, partially offset by lower spot market energy prices. Although wholesale short-term transactions increased year-over-year, low average spot market energy prices reduced the economic dispatch of fossil generating units, limiting additional wholesale sales.

Transmission revenue decreased $10 million primarily due to lower congestion.

Other revenue decreased $9 million, primarily due to the absence of a pre-tax gain on the sale of property to a regulated affiliate in the second quarter of 2015 and lower lease revenues from the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement.

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses increased $1,414 million in the second quarter of 2016 due to the following:

- Fuel costs increased $34 million, primarily due to a pre-tax charge of $58 million from settlement and termination costs on coal contracts recognized in the second quarter of 2016 and higher nuclear generation, partially offset by lower generation associated with outages and economic dispatch of fossil units resulting from low wholesale spot market energy prices, as described above, as well as lower unit prices on fossil fuel contracts.
- Purchased power costs decreased $69 million due to lower volumes ($76 million) and lower capacity expense ($19 million), partially offset by higher losses on financially settled contracts ($13 million) and higher unit prices ($13 million). Lower volumes and capacity expense primarily resulted from lower contract sales as discussed above, partially offset by economic purchases, resulting from the low wholesale spot market price environment. Higher losses on financially settled contracts were due to lower wholesale spot market prices in the second quarter of 2016 compared to the second quarter of 2015. Higher unit prices were primarily due to a higher proportion of purchases coming from purchased power agreements for wind, solar and CES' entitlement in OVEC, partially offset by the lower wholesale spot prices.
- Fossil operating costs increased $13 million, primarily due to increased outage costs.
- Nuclear operating costs decreased $22 million, primarily due to lower refueling outage costs. There was one refueling outage during the second quarter of 2016, as compared to two refueling outages during the same period of 2015.
- Retirement benefit costs increased $8 million.
- Transmission expenses decreased $32 million, due to lower congestion and market-based ancillary costs, primarily resulting from lower sales.
- Other operating expenses increased $54 million, primarily due to a $79 million increase in mark-to-market losses on commodity contract positions, partially offset by lower lease expense as a result of the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement and lower retail-related costs.
- General taxes decreased $7 million, primarily due to lower gross receipts taxes associated with lower retail sales volumes.
- Impairment of assets increased $1,431 million primarily due to an $800 million impairment of goodwill and a decision to exit operations of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station by May 31, 2020 and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station by October 1, 2020, resulting in an impairment of $647 million.

#### Other Expense —

Total other expense decreased $17 million in the second quarter of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower OTTI on NDT investments.

#### Income Taxes —

CES' effective tax rate was 15.4% and 33.3% for the second quarter of 2016 and 2015, respectively. The decrease in the effective tax rate is primarily due to valuation allowances of $159 million recorded against state and local NOL carryforwards that management believes, more likely than not, will not be realized as further described above as well as the impairment of goodwill, of which, $433 million is non-deductible for tax purposes.

### Corporate / Other — Second Quarter 2016 Compared with Second Quarter 2015

Financial results from the Corporate/Other operating segment and reconciling items, including interest expense on holding company debt, corporate support services revenues and expenses and income taxes, resulted in a nominal $3 million increase in earnings in the second quarter of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015.

### Summary of Results of Operations — First Six Months of 2016 Compared with First Six Months of 2015

Financial results for FirstEnergy’s business segments in the first six months of 2016 and 2015 were as follows:

*(In millions)*

| First Six Months 2016 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $4,589 | $539 | $2,064 | $(89) | $7,103 |
| Other | 132 | — | 96 | (61) | 167 |
| Internal | — | — | 260 | (260) | — |
| Total Revenues | 4,721 | 539 | 2,420 | (410) | 7,270 |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 280 | — | 539 | — | 819 |
| Purchased power | 1,647 | — | 626 | (260) | 2,013 |
| Other operating expenses | 1,228 | 72 | 753 | (171) | 1,882 |
| Provision for depreciation | 339 | 87 | 205 | 32 | 663 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 120 | 4 | — | — | 124 |
| General taxes | 355 | 77 | 68 | 21 | 521 |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 1,447 | — | 1,447 |
| Total Operating Expenses | 3,969 | 240 | 3,638 | (378) | 7,469 |
| Operating Income (Loss) | 752 | 299 | (1,218) | (32) | (199) |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | 24 | — | 33 | (10) | 47 |
| Interest expense | (292) | (85) | (95) | (105) | (577) |
| Capitalized financing costs | 9 | 16 | 20 | 6 | 51 |
| Total Other Expense | (259) | (69) | (42) | (109) | (479) |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | 493 | 230 | (1,260) | (141) | (678) |
| Income taxes (benefits) | 182 | 85 | (145) | (39) | 83 |
| Net Income (Loss) | $311 | $145 | $(1,115) | $(102) | $(761) |

70

*(In millions)*

| First Six Months 2015 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $4,706 | $507 | $2,105 | $(88) | $7,230 |
| Other | 95 | — | 104 | (67) | 132 |
| Internal | — | — | 422 | (422) | — |
| Total Revenues | 4,801 | 507 | 2,631 | (577) | 7,362 |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 266 | — | 630 | — | 896 |
| Purchased power | 1,781 | — | 743 | (422) | 2,102 |
| Other operating expenses | 1,135 | 70 | 930 | (178) | 1,957 |
| Provision for depreciation | 342 | 75 | 195 | 29 | 641 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 86 | 5 | — | — | 91 |
| General taxes | 364 | 50 | 77 | 20 | 511 |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 16 | — | 16 |
| Total Operating Expenses | 3,974 | 200 | 2,591 | (551) | 6,214 |
| Operating Income | 827 | 307 | 40 | (26) | 1,148 |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | 25 | — | 12 | (23) | 14 |
| Interest expense | (290) | (79) | (96) | (96) | (561) |
| Capitalized financing costs | 15 | 27 | 20 | 5 | 67 |
| Total Other Expense | (250) | (52) | (64) | (114) | (480) |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | 577 | 255 | (24) | (140) | 668 |
| Income taxes (benefits) | 213 | 94 | (8) | (40) | 259 |
| Net Income (Loss) | $364 | $161 | $(16) | $(100) | $409 |

71

*(In millions)*

| Changes Between First Six Months 2016 and First Six Months 2015 Financial Results Revenues: External | Regulated Distribution | Regulated Transmission | Competitive Energy Services | Corporate/Other and Reconciling Adjustments | FirstEnergy Consolidated |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Electric | $(117) | $32 | $(41) | $(1) | $(127) |
| Other | 37 | — | (8) | 6 | 35 |
| Internal | — | — | (162) | 162 | — |
| Total Revenues | (80) | 32 | (211) | 167 | (92) |
| Operating Expenses: |  |  |  |  |  |
| Fuel | 14 | — | (91) | — | (77) |
| Purchased power | (134) | — | (117) | 162 | (89) |
| Other operating expenses | 93 | 2 | (177) | 7 | (75) |
| Provision for depreciation | (3) | 12 | 10 | 3 | 22 |
| Amortization of regulatory assets, net | 34 | (1) | — | — | 33 |
| General taxes | (9) | 27 | (9) | 1 | 10 |
| Impairment of assets | — | — | 1,431 | — | 1,431 |
| Total Operating Expenses | (5) | 40 | 1,047 | 173 | 1,255 |
| Operating Income (Loss) | (75) | (8) | (1,258) | (6) | (1,347) |
| Other Income (Expense): |  |  |  |  |  |
| Investment income | (1) | — | 21 | 13 | 33 |
| Interest expense | (2) | (6) | 1 | (9) | (16) |
| Capitalized financing costs | (6) | (11) | — | 1 | (16) |
| Total Other Expense | (9) | (17) | 22 | 5 | 1 |
| Income (Loss) Before Income Taxes (Benefits) | (84) | (25) | (1,236) | (1) | (1,346) |
| Income taxes (benefits) | (31) | (9) | (137) | 1 | (176) |
| Net Income (Loss) | $(53) | $(16) | $(1,099) | $(2) | $(1,170) |

72

### Regulated Distribution — First Six Months of 2016 Compared with First Six Months of 2015

Regulated Distribution's net income decreased $53 million in the first six months of 2016 as compared to the same period of 2015, reflecting increasing retirement benefit costs and lower distribution deliveries, primarily resulting from lower distribution deliveries, partially offset by the impact of net rate increases implemented in 2015 as a result of approved rate cases at certain operating companies. Additionally, the Ohio Companies recognized $51 million in regulatory charges resulting from the PUCO's March 31 Opinion and Order adopting and approving, with modifications, the Ohio Companies' ESP IV.

#### Revenues —

The $80 million decrease in total revenues resulted from the following sources:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Type of Service | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Distribution services | $2,290 | $2,256 | $34 |
| Generation sales: |  |  |  |
| Retail | 2,057 | 2,150 | (93) |
| Wholesale | 242 | 300 | (58) |
| Total generation sales | 2,299 | 2,450 | (151) |
| Other | 132 | 95 | 37 |
| Total Revenues | $4,721 | $4,801 | $(80) |

Distribution services revenues increased $34 million primarily resulting from approved base distribution rate increases in Pennsylvania, effective May 3, 2015, and MP and PE in West Virginia, effective February 25, 2015, partially offset by a distribution rate decrease at JCP&L, including the recovery of 2011 and 2012 storm costs, effective April 1, 2015. Partially offsetting this net rate increase was a decline in MWH deliveries, primarily resulting from lower weather-related usage as well as lower average customer usage, as described below. Additionally, distribution revenues were impacted by higher rates associated with the recovery of deferred costs. Distribution deliveries by customer class are summarized in the following table:

*(In thousands)*

| Electric Distribution MWH Deliveries | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Residential | 25,992 | 28,401 | (8.5)% |
| Commercial | 20,908 | 21,543 | (2.9)% |
| Industrial | 24,724 | 25,428 | (2.8)% |
| Other | 292 | 292 | —% |
| Total Electric Distribution MWH Deliveries | 71,916 | 75,664 | (5.0)% |

Lower distribution deliveries to residential and commercial customers primarily reflect decreased weather-related usage resulting from heating degree days that were 17% below 2015, and 8% below normal and cooling degree days that were 12% below 2015, and 11% above normal. Additionally, distribution deliveries to residential and commercial customers reflect declining average customer usage associated with more energy efficient products and services. Deliveries to industrial customers continue to decline as the increase from shale customer usage was more than offset by a decrease from steel and mining customer usage.

The following table summarizes the price and volume factors contributing to the $151 million decrease in generation revenues for the first six months of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015:

*(In millions)*

| Source of Change in Generation Revenues Retail: | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: |
| Effect of decrease in sales volumes | $(200) |
| Change in prices | 107 |
|  | (93) |
| Wholesale: |  |
| Effect of increase in sales volumes | 31 |
| Change in prices | (98) |
| Capacity Revenue | 9 |
|  | (58) |
| Decrease in Generation Revenues | $(151) |

The decrease in retail generation sales volumes was primarily due to increased customer shopping in Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey as well as lower weather-related usage and industrial usage in West Virginia, as described above. Total generation provided by alternative suppliers as a percentage of total MWH deliveries increased to 81% from 79% for the Ohio Companies, to 67% from 64% for the Pennsylvania Companies and to 52% from 51% for JCP&L. The increase in retail generation prices primarily resulted from higher default service auction prices for the Pennsylvania Companies and an ENEC rate increase in West Virginia, effective January 1, 2016.

Wholesale generation revenues decreased $58 million in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower spot market energy prices, partially offset by higher wholesale sales and higher capacity revenues. The difference between current wholesale generation revenues and certain energy costs incurred are deferred for future recovery or refund, with no material impact to earnings.

Other revenues increased $37 million primarily related to a $29 million gain on the sale of oil and gas rights at WP.

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses decreased $5 million primarily due to the following:

- Fuel expense increased $14 million in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015, primarily related to higher generation.
- Purchased power costs decreased $134 million during the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015 primarily due to decreased volumes reflecting lower weather-related usage and increased customer shopping, as described above.

*(In millions)*

| Source of Change in Purchased Power Purchases from non-affiliates: | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: |
| Change due to decreased unit costs | $(1) |
| Change due to volumes | 8 |
|  | 7 |
| Purchases from affiliates: |  |
| Change due to increased unit costs | 16 |
| Change due to volumes | (179) |
|  | (163) |
| Capacity Expense | 10 |
| Amortization of deferred costs | 12 |
| Decrease in Purchased Power Costs | $(134) |

74

- Other operating expenses increased $93 million primarily due to:
- An increase of $51 million resulting from the recognition of economic development and energy efficiency obligations in accordance with the PUCO's March 31 Opinion and Order adopting and approving, with modifications, the Ohio Companies' ESP IV.
- Higher retirement benefit costs of $25 million.
- Higher transmission expenses of $11 million primarily related to an increase in network transmission expenses at the Ohio Companies, partially offset by lower congestion expenses at MP. The difference between current revenues and costs incurred are deferred for future recovery or refund, resulting in no material impact on current period earnings.
- Net amortization of regulatory assets increased $34 million primarily due to:
- Recovery of storm costs in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia effective with the implementation of new rates as discussed above ($35 million),
- Recovery of West Virginia vegetation management program costs ($27 million), partially offset by
- Higher deferral of Ohio network transmission expenses ($26 million).
- General taxes decreased $9 million primarily due to lower property taxes in Ohio, partially offset by higher revenue-related taxes in Pennsylvania.

#### Other Expense —

Other expense increased $9 million in the first six months of 2016 primarily due to lower capitalized financing costs as well as higher interest expense related to long-term debt issuances in 2015 at JCPL and WPP, the proceeds of which, in part, paid off short-term borrowings.

#### Income Taxes —

Regulated Distribution’s effective tax rate was 36.9% for the first six months of 2016 and 2015.

### Regulated Transmission — First Six Months of 2016 Compared with First Six Months of 2015

Net income decreased $16 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily resulting from adjustments associated with ATSI and TrAIL's annual rate filing for costs previously recovered, a lower return on equity at ATSI, and lower capitalized financing costs.

#### Revenues —

Total revenues increased $32 million principally due to higher recovery of incremental operating expenses and a higher rate base at ATSI and TrAIL, partially offset by adjustments associated with ATSI's and TrAIL's annual rate filing for costs previously recovered as well as a lower ROE at ATSI under its FERC-approved comprehensive settlement related to the implementation of a forward-looking rate.

Revenues by transmission asset owner are shown in the following table:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Transmission Asset Owner | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| ATSI | $262 | $223 | $39 |
| TrAIL | 120 | 126 | (6) |
| PATH | 6 | 7 | (1) |
| Utilities | 151 | 151 | — |
| Total Revenues | $539 | $507 | $32 |

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses increased $40 million principally due to higher property taxes and depreciation expense at ATSI, which are recovered through ATSI's formula rate.

#### Other Expense —

Other expense increased $17 million in the first six months of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015 primarily due to lower capitalized financing costs resulting from lower construction work in progress balances at ATSI as well as increased interest expense resulting from debt issuances of $150 million at ATSI in the fourth quarter of 2015, the proceeds of which, in part, paid off short-term borrowings.

#### Income Taxes —

Regulated Transmission’s effective tax rate was 37.0% and 36.9% for the first six months of 2016 and 2015, respectively.

### CES — First Six Months of 2016 Compared with First Six Months of 2015

Operating results decreased $1,099 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily resulting from charges associated with the impairments of goodwill, Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station as discussed above, termination and settlement costs on coal contracts, partially offset by net mark-to-market gains on commodity contract positions. Excluding these items, operating results were impacted by higher capacity revenues from higher capacity auction prices, lower fuel costs and lower purchased power, partially offset by lower sales volumes.

#### Revenues —

Total revenues decreased $211 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower sales volumes resulting from the continuation of CES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. Revenues were also impacted by higher capacity revenues and higher net gains on financially settled contracts, as further described below.

The decrease in total revenues resulted from the following sources:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Type of Service Contract Sales: | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $403 | $717 | $(314) |
| Governmental Aggregation | 432 | 506 | (74) |
| Mass Market | 85 | 160 | (75) |
| POLR | 282 | 445 | (163) |
| Structured Sales | 277 | 259 | 18 |
| Total Contract Sales | 1,479 | 2,087 | (608) |
| Wholesale | 806 | 347 | 459 |
| Transmission | 39 | 93 | (54) |
| Other | 96 | 104 | (8) |
| **Total Revenues** | $2,420 | $2,631 | $(211) |

76

*(In thousands)*

| MWH Sales by Channel Contract Sales: | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | 7,478 | 13,319 | (43.9)% |
| Governmental Aggregation | 6,560 | 8,052 | (18.5)% |
| Mass Market | 1,239 | 2,340 | (47.1)% |
| POLR | 4,633 | 7,742 | (40.2)% |
| Structured Sales | 6,738 | 5,897 | 14.3% |
| Total Contract Sales | 26,648 | 37,350 | (28.7)% |
| Wholesale | 5,490 | 867 | NM |
| **Total MWH Sales** | 32,138 | 38,217 | (15.9)% |

#### NM - Not Meaningful

The following table summarizes the price and volume factors contributing to changes in revenues:

*(In millions)*

| MWH Sales Channel: | Source of Change in Revenues Increase (Decrease) Sales Volumes | Prices | Gain on Settled Contracts | Capacity Revenue | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $(314) | $— | $— | $— | $(314) |
| Governmental Aggregation | (94) | 20 | — | — | (74) |
| Mass Market | (76) | 1 | — | — | (75) |
| POLR | (179) | 16 | — | — | (163) |
| Structured Sales | 37 | (19) | — | — | 18 |
| Wholesale | 149 | (30) | 121 | 219 | 459 |

Lower sales volumes in Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market channels primarily reflects the continuation of CES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. The Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market customer base was 1.5 million as of June 30, 2016, compared to 1.9 million as of June 30, 2015. Although unit pricing was higher year-over-year in the Government Aggregation and Mass Market channels, the increase was primarily attributable to higher capacity expense as discussed below, which is a component of the retail price.

The decrease in POLR sales of $163 million was due to lower volumes, partially offset by higher rates associated with recent POLR auctions. Structured Sales increased $18 million, primarily due to higher volumes, partially offset by the impact of lower market prices.

Wholesale revenues increased $459 million, primarily due to an increase in capacity revenue from higher capacity auction prices, an increase in short-term (net hourly position) transactions and gains on financially settled contracts, partially offset by lower spot market energy prices. Although wholesale short-term transactions increased year-over-year, low average spot market energy prices reduced the economic dispatch of fossil generating units, limiting additional wholesale sales.

Transmission revenue decreased $54 million in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower congestion revenue associated with less volatile market conditions.

Other revenue decreased $8 million, primarily due to the absence of a pre-tax gain on the sale of property to a regulated affiliate in the second quarter of 2015 and lower lease revenues from the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement.

#### Operating Expenses —

Total operating expenses increased $1,047 million in the first six months of 2016 due to the following:

- Fuel costs decreased $91 million, primarily due to lower generation associated with outages and economic dispatch of fossil units resulting from low wholesale spot market energy prices, as described above, as well as lower unit prices on fossil fuel contracts. Additionally, fuel costs were impacted by a pre-tax charge of $58 million from settlement and termination costs on coal contracts in the second quarter of 2016.
- Purchased power costs decreased $117 million due to lower volumes ($193 million) and lower unit prices ($3 million), partially offset by higher losses on financial settled contracts ($54 million) and higher capacity expenses ($25 million). Lower volumes primarily resulted from lower contract sales as discussed above, partially offset by economic purchases, resulting from the low wholesale spot market price environment. Lower unit prices and higher losses on financially settled contracts were both due to lower wholesale spot market prices in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015. The increase in capacity expense, which is a component of CES' retail price, was primarily the result of higher capacity rates associated with CES' retail sales obligations.
- Fossil operating costs increased $21 million, primarily due to increased outage costs.
- Nuclear operating costs decreased $33 million as a result of lower refueling outage costs. There was one refueling outage during the first six months of 2016 as compared to two refueling outages during the same period of 2015.
- Retirement benefit costs increased $16 million.
- Transmission expenses decreased $151 million, primarily due to lower congestion and market-based ancillary costs associated with less volatile market conditions as compared to the first six months of 2015, as well as lower load requirements.
- Other operating expenses decreased $30 million, primarily due to a $14 million increase in mark-to-market gains on commodity contract positions, lower lease expense as a result of the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement and lower retail-related costs.
- Depreciation expense increased $10 million as a result of a higher asset base.
- General taxes decreased $9 million due to lower gross receipts taxes associated with lower retail sales volumes.
- Impairment of assets increased $1,431 million primarily due to an $800 million impairment of goodwill and a decision to exit operations of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station by May 31, 2020 and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station by October 1, 2020, resulting in an impairment of $647 million.

#### Other Expense —

Total other expense decreased $22 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower OTTI on NDT investments.

#### Income Taxes (Benefits) —

CES' effective tax rate was 11.5% and 33.3% for the first six months of 2016 and 2015, respectively. The decrease in the effective tax rate is primarily due to valuation allowances of $159 million recorded against state and local NOL carryforwards that management believes, more likely than not, will not be realized as discussed above as well as the impairment of goodwill, of which, $433 million is non-deductible for tax purposes.

### Corporate / Other — First Six Months of 2016 Compared with First Six Months of 2015

Financial results from the Corporate/Other operating segment and reconciling items resulted in a nominal $2 million decrease in net income in the first six months of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015.

### Regulatory Assets

Regulatory assets represent incurred costs that have been deferred because of their probable future recovery from customers through regulated rates. Regulatory liabilities represent amounts that are expected to be credited to customers through future regulated rates or amounts collected from customers for costs not yet incurred. FirstEnergy and the Utilities net their regulatory assets and liabilities based on federal and state jurisdictions. The following table provides information about the composition of net regulatory assets as of June 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, and the changes during the six months ended June 30, 2016:

*(In millions)*

| Regulatory Assets (Liabilities) by Source | June 30, 2016 | December 31, 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Regulatory transition costs | $143 | $185 | $(42) |
| Customer receivables for future income taxes | 424 | 355 | 69 |
| Nuclear decommissioning and spent fuel disposal costs | (306) | (272) | (34) |
| Asset removal costs | (462) | (372) | (90) |
| Deferred transmission costs | 136 | 115 | 21 |
| Deferred generation costs | 243 | 243 | — |
| Deferred distribution costs | 315 | 335 | (20) |
| Contract valuations | 179 | 186 | (7) |
| Storm-related costs | 375 | 403 | (28) |
| Other | 140 | 170 | (30) |
| Net Regulatory Assets included on the Consolidated Balance Sheets | $1,187 | $1,348 | $(161) |

Regulatory assets that do not earn a current return totaled approximately $140 million and $148 million as of June 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, respectively, primarily related to storm damage costs.

As of June 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, FirstEnergy had approximately $114 million and $116 million, respectively, of net regulatory liabilities that are primarily related to asset removal costs. Net regulatory liabilities are classified within Other noncurrent liabilities on the Consolidated Balance Sheets.

### CAPITAL RESOURCES AND LIQUIDITY

FirstEnergy expects its existing sources of liquidity to remain sufficient to meet its anticipated obligations and those of its subsidiaries. FirstEnergy’s business is capital intensive, requiring significant resources to fund operating expenses, construction expenditures, scheduled debt maturities and interest payments, dividend payments, and contributions to its pension plan. In addition to internal sources to fund liquidity and capital requirements for 2016 and beyond, FirstEnergy expects to rely on external sources of funds. Short-term cash requirements not met by cash provided from operations are generally satisfied through short-term borrowings. Long-term cash needs may be met through the issuance of long-term debt and/or equity. FirstEnergy expects that borrowing capacity under credit facilities will continue to be available to manage working capital requirements along with continued access to long-term capital markets. FirstEnergy also expects to both issue long-term debt at certain Utilities and certain other subsidiaries to, among other things, refinance short-term and maturing debt in the ordinary course, and remarket PCRB's currently held by FG and NG, in each case, subject to market and other conditions.

Additionally, in 2016, FirstEnergy has minimum required funding obligations of $381 million to its qualified pension plan, of which$245 million has been contributed through July 2016, including $85 million at FES in July of 2016. FirstEnergy expects to make future contributions to the qualified pension plan in 2016 to satisfy its remaining 2016 funding obligations, as well as address certain of its future funding obligations, with cash, up to $500 million of equity or a combination thereof, depending on, among other things, market conditions.

Capital expenditures through June 30, 2016 as well as planned capital expenditures for 2016 by reportable segment are included below:

*(In millions)*

| Reportable Segment | Capital Expenditures Accrued - First six months of 2016 | Capital Expenditures Forecast 2016 |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Regulated Distribution | $619 | $1,270 |
| Regulated Transmission | 514 | 1,050 |
| Competitive Energy Services | 314 | 545 |
| Corporate/Other | 42 | 85 |
| Total | $1,489 | $2,950 |

FirstEnergy's strategy is to focus on investments in its regulated operations. The centerpiece of this strategy is a $4.2 billion *Energizing the Future* investment plan that began in 2014 and will continue through 2017 to upgrade and expand FirstEnergy's transmission system. This program is focused on projects that enhance system performance, physical security and add operating flexibility and capacity starting with the ATSI system and moving east across FirstEnergy's service territory over time. Through 2015, FirstEnergy's capital expenditures under this plan were $2.4 billion and in 2016 capital expenditures under this plan are currently projected to be approximately $1.05 billion. In total, FirstEnergy has identified at least $15 billion in transmission investment opportunities across the 24,000 mile transmission system, making this a continuing platform for investment in the years beyond 2017.

In alignment with FirstEnergy’s strategy to invest in its Regulated Transmission and Regulated Distribution segments and the repositioning of the CES segment, FirstEnergy is also focused on improving the balance sheet over time consistent with its business profile, maintaining investment grade metrics at its regulated businesses and FirstEnergy Corp. and maintaining strong liquidity for an overall stable financial position. Specifically, at the regulated businesses, authority has been obtained for various regulated distribution and transmission subsidiaries to issue and/or refinance debt.

Any financing plans by FirstEnergy, including the issuance of equity, refinancing of maturing debt and reductions in short-term borrowings, are subject to market conditions and other factors, such as the impact of the current energy and capacity markets and potential credit rating changes. No assurance can be given that any such issuances, financings, refinancings, or reductions in short-term debt, as the case may be, will be completed as anticipated. Any delay in the completion of financing plans could require FE or FES or any of their subsidiaries to utilize short-term borrowing capacity, which would impact available liquidity. In addition, FirstEnergy expects to continually evaluate any planned financings, which may result in changes from time to time.

As of June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy’s net deficit in working capital (current assets less current liabilities) was due in large part to currently payable long-term debt and short-term borrowings. Currently payable long-term debt as of June 30, 2016, included the following:

*(In millions)*

| Currently Payable Long-Term Debt |  |
| --- | ---: |
| PCRBs supported by bank LOCs(1) | $92 |
| Unsecured notes | 380 |
| FMBs | 395 |
| Unsecured PCRBs(1) | 325 |
| Collateralized lease obligation bonds | 8 |
| Sinking fund requirements | 89 |
| Other notes | 38 |
|  | $1,327 |

(1) These PCRBs are classified as currently payable long-term debt because the applicable interest rate mode permits individual debt holders to put the respective debt back to the issuer prior to maturity.

### Short-Term Borrowings

FirstEnergy had $2,925 million and $1,708 million of short-term borrowings as of June 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, respectively. FirstEnergy’s and FES' available liquidity as of June 30, 2016, was as follows:

*(In millions)*

| Borrower(s) | Type | Maturity | Commitment | Available Liquidity |
| --- | --- | --- | ---: | ---: |
| FirstEnergy(1) | Revolving | March 2019 | $3,500 | $719 |
| FES / AE Supply | Revolving | March 2019 | 1,500 | 1,499 |
| FET(2) | Revolving | March 2019 | 1,000 | 850 |
|  |  | Subtotal | $6,000 | $3,068 |
|  |  | Cash | — | 199 |
|  |  | Total | $6,000 | $3,267 |

(1) FE and the Utilities.

(2) Includes FET, ATSI and TrAIL.

### Revolving Credit Facilities

#### FirstEnergy, FES/AE Supply and FET Facilities

FE and certain of its subsidiaries participate in three five-year syndicated revolving credit facilities with aggregate commitments of $6.0 billion (Facilities) expiring on March 31, 2019.

Generally, borrowings under each of the Facilities are available to each borrower separately and mature on the earlier of 364 days from the date of borrowing or the commitment termination date, as the same may be extended. Each of the Facilities contains financial covenants requiring each borrower to maintain a consolidated debt to total capitalization ratio (as defined under each of the Facilities, as amended) of no more than 65%, and 75% for FET, measured at the end of each fiscal quarter.

The following table summarizes the borrowing sublimits for each borrower under the Facilities, the limitations on short-term indebtedness applicable to each borrower under current regulatory approvals and applicable statutory and/or charter limitations, as of June 30, 2016:

*(In millions)*

| Borrower | FE Revolving Credit Facility Sublimit | FES/AE Supply Revolving Credit Facility Sublimit | FET Revolving Credit Facility Sublimit | Regulatory and Other Short-Term Debt Limitations |  |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| FE | $3,500 | $— | $— | $— | (1) |
| FES | — | 1,500 | — | — | (2) |
| AE Supply | — | 1,000 | — | — | (2) |
| FET | — | — | 1,000 | — | (1) |
| OE | 500 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| CEI | 500 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| TE | 500 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| JCP&L | 600 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| ME | 300 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| PN | 300 | — | — | 300 | (3) |
| WP | 200 | — | — | 200 | (3) |
| MP | 500 | — | — | 500 | (3) |
| PE | 150 | — | — | 150 | (3) |
| ATSI | — | — | 500 | 500 | (3) |
| Penn | 50 | — | — | 100 | (3) |
| TrAIL | — | — | 400 | 400 | (3) |

(1) No limitations.

(2) No limitation based upon blanket financing authorization from the FERC under existing open market tariffs.

(3) Includes amounts which may be borrowed under the regulated companies' money pool.

The entire amount of the FES/AE Supply Facility, $600 million of the FE Facility and $225 million of the FET Facility, subject to each borrower’s sublimit, is available for the issuance of LOCs (subject to borrowings drawn under the Facilities) expiring up to one year from the date of issuance. The stated amount of outstanding LOCs will count against total commitments available under each of the Facilities and against the applicable borrower’s borrowing sublimit.

The Facilities do not contain provisions that restrict the ability to borrow or accelerate payment of outstanding advances in the event of any change in credit ratings of the borrowers. Pricing is defined in “pricing grids,” whereby the cost of funds borrowed under the Facilities is related to the credit ratings of the company borrowing the funds, other than the FET Facility, which is based on its subsidiaries' credit ratings. Additionally, borrowings under each of the Facilities are subject to the usual and customary provisions for acceleration upon the occurrence of events of default, including a cross-default for other indebtedness in excess of $100 million.

As of June 30, 2016, the borrowers were in compliance with the applicable debt to total capitalization ratios under the respective Facilities.

### Term Loans

FE has a $1 billion variable rate term loan credit agreement with a maturity date of March 31, 2019. The initial borrowing under the term loan, which took the form of a Eurodollar rate advance, may be converted from time to time, in whole or in part, to alternate base rate advances or other Eurodollar rate advances. Additionally, FE has a $200 million variable rate term loan, due May 29, 2020. Each of the term loans contains covenants and other terms and conditions substantially similar to those of the FE Facility described above, including the same consolidated debt to total capitalization ratio requirement.

As of June 30, 2016, FE was in compliance with the applicable debt to total capitalization ratios under each of these term loans.

### FirstEnergy Money Pools

FirstEnergy’s utility operating subsidiary companies also have the ability to borrow from each other and the holding company to meet their short-term working capital requirements. A similar but separate arrangement exists among FirstEnergy’s unregulated companies. FESC administers these two money pools and tracks surplus funds of FirstEnergy and the respective regulated and unregulated subsidiaries, as well as proceeds available from bank borrowings. Companies receiving a loan under the money pool agreements must repay the principal amount of the loan, together with accrued interest, within 364 days of borrowing the funds. The rate of interest is the same for each company receiving a loan from their respective pool and is based on the average cost of funds available through the pool. The average interest rates for borrowings in the first six months of 2016 were 0.73% per annum for the regulated companies’ money pool and 1.83% per annum for the unregulated companies’ money pool.

### Pollution Control Revenue Bonds

As of June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy’s currently payable long-term debt included approximately $92 million (all applicable to FES) of variable interest rate PCRBs, the bondholders of which are entitled to the benefit of irrevocable direct pay bank LOCs. The interest rates on the PCRBs are reset daily or weekly. Bondholders can tender their PCRBs for mandatory purchase prior to maturity with the purchase price payable from remarketing proceeds or, if the PCRBs are not successfully remarketed, by drawings on the irrevocable direct pay LOCs. The subsidiary obligor is required to reimburse the applicable LOC bank for any such drawings or, if the LOC bank fails to honor its LOC for any reason, must itself pay the purchase price. The LOCs for FirstEnergy's variable interest rate PCRBs outstanding as of June 30, 2016 were issued by the following bank:

*(In millions)*

| Bank | Aggregate Amount(1) | Termination Date | Reimbursements of Draws Due |
| --- | ---: | --- | --- |
| The Bank of Nova Scotia | $92 | March 2017 | March 2017 |

(1) Excludes approximately $1 million of applicable interest coverage.

### Long-Term Debt Capacity

FE's and its subsidiaries' access to capital markets and costs of financing are influenced by the credit ratings of their securities. FirstEnergy is focused on improving its balance sheet and maintaining investment grade credit metrics at its regulated businesses and at FirstEnergy Corp. The following table displays FE’s and its subsidiaries’ credit ratings as of June 30, 2016:

| Issuer | Senior Secured S&P | Moody’s | Senior Unsecured S&P | Moody’s | Fitch |
| --- | ---: | ---: | --- | --- | ---: |
| FE | — | — | BB+ | Baa3 | BB+ |
| FES | BBB- | — | BBB- | Baa3 | — |
| AE Supply | BBB- | — | BBB- | Baa3 | — |
| AGC | — | — | BBB- | Baa3 | — |
| ATSI | — | — | BBB- | Baa2 | — |
| CEI | BBB+ | Baa1 | BBB- | Baa3 | — |
| FET | — | — | BB+ | Baa3 | — |
| JCP&L | — | — | BBB- | Baa2 | — |
| ME | — | — | BBB- | Baa1 | — |
| MP | BBB+ | A3 | — | — | — |
| OE | BBB+ | A2 | BBB- | Baa1 | — |
| PN | — | — | BBB- | Baa2 | — |
| Penn | — | A2 | — | — | — |
| PE | BBB+ | A3 | — | — | — |
| TE | BBB+ | Baa1 | — | — | — |
| TrAIL | — | — | BBB- | A3 | — |
| WP | BBB+ | A2 | — | — | — |

On July 22, 2016, S&P placed FES, AE Supply, and AGC on CreditWatch with negative implications, which could result in a downgrade to non-investment grade in the near-term.

Debt capacity is subject to the consolidated debt to total capitalization limits in the Facilities previously discussed. As of June 30, 2016, FE and its subsidiaries could issue additional debt of approximately $3.9 billion and remain within the limitations of the financial covenants required by the Facilities. As of June 30, 2016, FES' incremental debt capacity under its consolidated debt to total capitalization financial covenant is also $3.9 billion given FE's consolidated debt to total capitalization ratio under its Facility.

### Changes in Cash Position

As of June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy had $199 million of cash and cash equivalents compared to $131 million of cash and cash equivalents as of December 31, 2015. As of June 30, 2016 and December 31, 2015, FirstEnergy had approximately $65 million and $82 million, respectively, of restricted cash included in Other Current Assets on the Consolidated Balance Sheets.

### Cash Flows From Operating Activities

FirstEnergy's most significant sources of cash are derived from electric service provided by its utility operating subsidiaries and the sales of energy and related products and services by its unregulated competitive subsidiaries. The most significant use of cash from operating activities is to buy electricity in the wholesale market and pay fuel suppliers, employees, tax authorities, lenders, and others for a wide range of material and services.

Net cash provided from operating activities was $1,460 million during the first six months of 2016 compared with $990 million provided from operating activities during the first six months of 2015. Cash flows from operations increased $470 million in the first six months of 2016, compared with the same period of 2015, primarily due to the following:

- Distribution rate increases associated with the implementation of new rates, partially offset by a year-over-year decline in distribution deliveries primarily associated with lower weather-related usage;
- Higher transmission revenue, reflecting recovery of incremental operating expenses and a higher rate base;
- Higher capacity revenues at CES, partially offset by a decline in sales volume; and
- Lower disbursements for fuel and purchased power resulting from the lower sales volumes.

### Cash Flows From Financing Activities

In the first six months of 2016, cash provided from financing activities was $375 million compared to $712 million of cash provided from financing activities during the first six months of 2015. The following table summarizes redemptions, repayments, short-term borrowings and dividends:

*(In millions)*

| Securities Issued or Redeemed / Repaid New Issues | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Term Loan | $— | $200 |
|  | $— | $200 |
| Redemptions / Repayments |  |  |
| Term Loan | $— | $(200) |
| Unsecured notes | (356) | — |
| Senior secured notes | (225) | (92) |
|  | $(581) | $(292) |
| Short-term borrowings, net | $1,225 | $1,109 |
| Common stock dividend payments | $(305) | $(303) |

On May 1, 2016, JCP&L repaid $300 million of 5.625% senior unsecured notes at maturity.

On June 1 and July 1 of 2016, NG repurchased approximately $225 million and $60 million, respectively of PCRBs, which were subject to a mandatory put on such date. NG is currently holding these PCRBs for future remarketing in 2016 subject to market and other conditions as further described above.

On July 11, 2016, Penn issued $50 million of its 4.24% FMBs due July 11, 2056. Proceeds received from the issuance of the FMBs were used: (i) to fund capital expenditures; (ii) for working capital needs and other general business purposes; and (iii) to repay borrowings under the FirstEnergy regulated companies' money pool.

### Cash Flows From Investing Activities

Cash used for investing activities in the first six months of 2016 principally represented cash used for property additions. The following table summarizes investing activities for the first six months of 2016 and the comparable period of 2015:

*(In millions)*

| Cash Used for Investing Activities Property Additions: | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Regulated Distribution | $575 | $592 | $(17) |
| Regulated Transmission | 509 | 551 | (42) |
| Competitive Energy Services | 382 | 317 | 65 |
| Corporate / Other | 26 | 26 | — |
| Nuclear fuel | 188 | 97 | 91 |
| Investments | 49 | 62 | (13) |
| Asset removal costs | 63 | 67 | (4) |
| Other | (25) | (19) | (6) |
|  | $1,767 | $1,693 | $74 |

Cash used for investing activities for the first six months of 2016 increased $74 million, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to increases in nuclear fuel and property additions. The increase in nuclear fuel was due to the scheduled Davis-Besse refueling and maintenance outage.

### GUARANTEES AND OTHER ASSURANCES

FirstEnergy has various financial and performance guarantees and indemnifications which are issued in the normal course of business. These contracts include performance guarantees, stand-by letters of credit, debt guarantees, surety bonds and indemnifications. FirstEnergy enters into these arrangements to facilitate commercial transactions with third parties by enhancing the value of the transaction to the third party. The maximum potential amount of future payments FirstEnergy and its subsidiaries could be required to make under these guarantees as of June 30, 2016, was approximately $3.5 billion, as summarized below:

*(In millions)*

| Guarantees and Other Assurances FE's Guarantees on Behalf of its Subsidiaries | Maximum Exposure |
| --- | ---: |
| Energy and Energy-Related Contracts(1) | $33 |
| Deferred compensation arrangements | 544 |
| Other(2) | 13 |
|  | 590 |
| **Subsidiaries’ Guarantees** |  |
| Energy and Energy-Related Contracts(3) | 248 |
| FES’ guarantee of NG’s nuclear property insurance | 96 |
| FES' guarantee of nuclear decommissioning costs | 21 |
| FES’ guarantee of FG’s sale and leaseback obligations | 1,674 |
|  | 2,039 |
| **FE's Guarantees on Behalf of Business Ventures** |  |
| Global Holding facility | 300 |
| **Other Assurances** |  |
| Surety Bonds - Wholly Owned Subsidiaries | 383 |
| Surety Bonds | 22 |
| FES' LOC (long-term tax-exempt debt)(4) | 93 |
| LOCs(5) | 99 |
|  | 597 |
| **Total Guarantees and Other Assurances** | $3,526 |

(1) Issued for open-ended terms, with a 10-day termination right by FirstEnergy.

(2) Includes guarantees of $4 million for nuclear decommissioning funding assurances, $5 million for railcar leases and $4 million for various leases.

(3) Includes energy and energy-related contracts associated with FES of approximately $248 million.

(4) Reflects the $1 million of interest coverage portion of LOCs issued in support of floating rate PCRBs with various maturities and the principal amount of floating-rate PCRBs of $92 million, all of which is reflected in currently payable long-term debt on FirstEnergy's consolidated balance sheets.

(5) Includes $7 million issued for various terms pursuant to LOC capacity available under FirstEnergy’s revolving credit facilities, $87 million issued in connection with energy and energy related contracts, $1 million issued in connection with railcar leases and $4 million pledged in connection with the sale and leaseback of Beaver Valley Unit 2 by OE.

FES' debt obligations are generally guaranteed by its subsidiaries, FG and NG, and FES guarantees the debt obligations of each of FG and NG. Accordingly, present and future holders of indebtedness of FES, FG and NG would have claims against each of FES, FG and NG, regardless of whether their primary obligor is FES, FG or NG.

#### Collateral and Contingent-Related Features

In the normal course of business, FE and its subsidiaries routinely enter into physical or financially settled contracts for the sale and purchase of electric capacity, energy, fuel, and emission allowances. Certain bilateral agreements and derivative instruments contain provisions that require FE or its subsidiaries to post collateral. This collateral may be posted in the form of cash or credit support with thresholds contingent upon FE's or its subsidiaries' credit rating from each of the major credit rating agencies. The collateral and credit support requirements vary by contract and by counterparty. The incremental collateral requirement allows for the offsetting of assets and liabilities with the same counterparty, where the contractual right of offset exists under applicable master netting agreements.

Bilateral agreements and derivative instruments entered into by FE and its subsidiaries have margining provisions that require posting of collateral. Based on FES' power portfolio exposures as of June 30, 2016, FES has posted collateral of $145 million.

These credit-risk-related contingent features, or the margining provisions within bilateral agreements, stipulate that if the subsidiary were to be downgraded or lose its investment grade credit rating (based on its senior unsecured debt rating), it would be required to provide additional collateral. Depending on the volume of forward contracts and future price movements, higher amounts for margining, which is the ability to secure additional collateral when needed, could be required.

Subsequent to the occurrence of a senior unsecured credit rating downgrade to below S&P's BBB- and Moody's Baa3, or a “material adverse event,” the immediate posting of collateral or accelerated payments may be required of FE or its subsidiaries. The following table discloses the additional credit contingent contractual obligations that may be required under certain events as of June 30, 2016:

*(In millions)*

| Collateral Provisions | FES/ AE Supply (Tied to FE Corp. Rating) | FES/ AE Supply (Tied to FES Rating) | Utilities | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Split Rating (One rating agency's rating below investment grade) | $25 | $174 | $44 | $243 |
| Non-Investment Grade Ratings (All Rating Agencies at or below BB+/Ba1) | $25 | $187 | $44 | $256 |
| Total Exposure from Contractual Obligations | $25 | $310 | $44 | $379 |

Excluded from the preceding table are the potential collateral obligations due to affiliate transactions between the Regulated Distribution segment and CES segment. As of June 30, 2016, neither FES nor AE Supply had any collateral posted with their affiliates.

#### Other Commitments and Contingencies

FE is a guarantor under a syndicated senior secured term loan facility due March 3, 2020, under which Global Holding borrowed $300 million. In addition to FE, Signal Peak, Global Rail, Global Mining Group, LLC and Global Coal Sales Group, LLC, each being a direct or indirect subsidiary of Global Holding, continue to provide their joint and several guaranties of the obligations of Global Holding under the facility.

In connection with the facility, 69.99% of Global Holding's direct and indirect membership interests in Signal Peak, Global Rail and their affiliates along with FEV's and WMB Marketing Ventures, LLC's respective 33-1/3% membership interests in Global Holding, are pledged to the lenders under the current facility as collateral.

### OFF-BALANCE SHEET ARRANGEMENTS

FES and certain of the Ohio Companies have obligations that are not included on their Consolidated Balance Sheets related to the Perry Unit 1, Beaver Valley Unit 2, and 2007 Bruce Mansfield Unit 1 sale and leaseback arrangements, which are satisfied through operating lease payments. The total present value of these sale and leaseback operating lease commitments, net of trust investments, was $880 million as of June 30, 2016, and primarily relates to the 2007 Bruce Mansfield Unit 1 sale and leaseback arrangement expiring in 2040. From time to time FirstEnergy and these companies enter into discussions with certain parties to the arrangements regarding acquisition of owner participant and other interests. However, FirstEnergy cannot provide assurance that any such acquisitions will occur on satisfactory terms or at all.

As of June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy's leasehold interest was 2.60% of Beaver Valley Unit 2 and 93.83% of Bruce Mansfield Unit 1.

On May 23, 2016, NG completed the purchase of the 3.75% lessor equity interests of the remaining non-affiliated leasehold interest in Perry Unit 1 for $50 million. In addition, the Perry Unit 1 leases expired in accordance with their terms on May 30, 2016, resulting in NG being the sole owner of Perry Unit 1 and entitled to 100% of the unit's output.

### MARKET RISK INFORMATION

FirstEnergy uses various market risk sensitive instruments, including derivative contracts, primarily to manage the risk of price and interest rate fluctuations. FirstEnergy’s Risk Policy Committee, comprised of members of senior management, provides general oversight for risk management activities throughout the company.

#### Commodity Price Risk

FirstEnergy is exposed to financial risks resulting from fluctuating commodity prices, including prices for electricity, natural gas, coal and energy transmission. FirstEnergy's Risk Management Committee is responsible for promoting the effective design and implementation of sound risk management programs and oversees compliance with corporate risk management policies and established risk management practice. FirstEnergy uses a variety of derivative instruments for risk management purposes including forward contracts, options, futures contracts and swaps.

The valuation of derivative contracts is based on observable market information to the extent that such information is available. In cases where such information is not available, FirstEnergy relies on model-based information. The model provides estimates of future regional prices for electricity and an estimate of related price volatility. FirstEnergy uses these results to develop estimates of fair value for financial reporting purposes and for internal management decision making (see Note 8, Fair Value Measurements, of the Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements). Sources of information for the valuation of net commodity derivative assets and liabilities as of June 30, 2016 are summarized by year in the following table:

*(In millions)*

| Source of Information- Fair Value by Contract Year | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | Thereafter | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Prices actively quoted(1) | $4 | $5 | $— | $— | $— | $— | $9 |
| Other external sources(2) | 12 | 5 | (22) | (29) | — | — | (34) |
| Prices based on models | 5 | 2 | — | — | (10) | — | (3) |
| Total(3) | $21 | $12 | $(22) | $(29) | $(10) | $— | $(28) |

(1) Represents exchange traded New York Mercantile Exchange futures and options.

(2) Primarily represents contracts based on broker and ICE quotes.

(3) Includes $(123) million in non-hedge derivative contracts that are primarily related to NUG contracts at certain of the Utilities. NUG contracts are subject to regulatory accounting and do not impact earnings.

FirstEnergy performs sensitivity analyses to estimate its exposure to the market risk of its commodity positions. Based on derivative contracts held as of June 30, 2016, not subject to regulatory accounting, an increase in commodity prices of 10% would decrease net income by approximately $33 million during the next 12 months.

#### Equity Price Risk

As of June 30, 2016, the FirstEnergy pension plan assets were allocated approximately as follows: 41% in equity securities, 35% in fixed income securities, 8% in absolute return strategies, 10% in real estate and 6% in cash and short-term securities. A decline in the value of pension plan assets could result in additional funding requirements. FirstEnergy’s funding policy is based on actuarial computations using the projected unit credit method. During the six months ended June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy made a $160 million contribution to its qualified pension plan. Additionally, in July 2016 FirstEnergy contributed $85 million to its qualified pension plan at FES. See Note 4, Pension and Other Postemployment Benefits, of the Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for additional details on FirstEnergy's pension plans and OPEB. Through June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy's pension plan assets earned approximately 8.1% as compared to an annual expected return on plan assets of 7.5%.

NDT funds have been established to satisfy NG’s and other FirstEnergy subsidiaries' nuclear decommissioning obligations. As of June 30, 2016, approximately 62% of the funds were invested in fixed income securities, 31% of the funds were invested in equity securities and 7% were invested in short-term investments, with limitations related to concentration and investment grade ratings. The investments are carried at their market values of approximately $1,516 million, $770 million and $163 million for fixed income securities, equity securities and short-term investments, respectively, as of June 30, 2016, excluding $7 million of net receivables, payables and accrued income. A hypothetical 10% decrease in prices quoted by stock exchanges would result in a $77 million reduction in fair value as of June 30, 2016. Certain FirstEnergy subsidiaries recognize in earnings the unrealized losses on AFS securities held in its NDT as OTTI. A decline in the value of FirstEnergy’s NDT or a significant escalation in estimated decommissioning costs could result in additional funding requirements. During the six months ended June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy contributed approximately $2 million to the NDT.

#### Interest Rate Risk

FirstEnergy recognizes net actuarial gains or losses for its pension and OPEB plans in the fourth quarter of each fiscal year. A primary factor contributing to these actuarial gains and losses are changes in the discount rates used to value pension and OPEB obligations as of the measurement date of December 31 and the difference between expected and actual returns on the plans' assets. At this time, FirstEnergy is unable to determine or project the mark-to-market adjustment that may be recorded as of December 31, 2016.

### CREDIT RISK

Credit risk is defined as the risk that a counterparty to a transaction will be unable to fulfill its contractual obligations. FirstEnergy and FES evaluate the credit standing of a prospective counterparty based on the prospective counterparty's financial condition. FirstEnergy and FES may impose specific collateral requirements and use standardized agreements that facilitate the netting of cash flows. FirstEnergy and FES monitor the financial conditions of existing counterparties on an ongoing basis. An independent risk management group oversees credit risk.

#### Wholesale Credit Risk

FirstEnergy and FES measure wholesale credit risk as the replacement cost for derivatives in power, natural gas, coal and emission allowances, adjusted for amounts owed to, or due from, counterparties for settled transactions. The replacement cost of open positions represents unrealized gains, net of any unrealized losses, where FirstEnergy and FES have a legally enforceable right of offset. FirstEnergy and FES monitor and manage the credit risk of wholesale marketing, risk management and energy transacting operations through credit policies and procedures, which include an established credit approval process, daily monitoring of counterparty credit limits, the use of credit mitigation measures such as margin, collateral and the use of master netting agreements. The majority of FirstEnergy's and FES' energy contract counterparties maintain investment-grade credit ratings.

#### Retail Credit Risk

FirstEnergy's and FES' principal retail credit risk exposure relates to CES' competitive electricity activities, which serve residential, commercial and industrial companies. Retail credit risk results when customers default on contractual obligations or fail to pay for service rendered. This risk represents the loss that may be incurred due to the nonpayment of customer accounts receivable balances, as well as the loss from the resale of energy previously committed to serve customers.

Retail credit risk is managed through established credit approval policies, monitoring customer exposures and the use of credit mitigation measures such as deposits in the form of LOCs, cash or prepayment arrangements.

Retail credit quality is affected by the economy and the ability of customers to manage through unfavorable economic cycles and other market changes. If the business environment were to be negatively affected by changes in economic or other market conditions, FirstEnergy's and FES' retail credit risk may be adversely impacted.

### OUTLOOK

### STATE REGULATION

Each of the Utilities' retail rates, conditions of service, issuance of securities and other matters are subject to regulation in the states in which it operates - in Maryland by the MDPSC, in Ohio by the PUCO, in New Jersey by the NJBPU, in Pennsylvania by the PPUC, in West Virginia by the WVPSC and in New York by the NYPSC. The transmission operations of PE in Virginia are subject to certain regulations of the VSCC. In addition, under Ohio law, municipalities may regulate rates of a public utility, subject to appeal to the PUCO if not acceptable to the utility.

As competitive retail electric suppliers serving retail customers primarily in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey and Maryland, FES and AE Supply are subject to state laws applicable to competitive electric suppliers in those states, including affiliate codes of conduct that apply to FES, AE Supply and their public utility affiliates. In addition, if any of the FirstEnergy affiliates were to engage in the construction of significant new transmission or generation facilities, depending on the state, they may be required to obtain state regulatory authorization to site, construct and operate the new transmission or generation facility.

### MARYLAND

PE provides SOS pursuant to a combination of settlement agreements, MDPSC orders and regulations, and statutory provisions. SOS supply is competitively procured in the form of rolling contracts of varying lengths through periodic auctions that are overseen by the MDPSC and a third party monitor. Although settlements with respect to SOS supply for PE customers have expired, service continues in the same manner until changed by order of the MDPSC. PE recovers its costs plus a return for providing SOS.

The Maryland legislature adopted a statute in 2008 codifying the EmPOWER Maryland goals to reduce electric consumption and demand and requiring each electric utility to file a plan every three years. PE's current plan, covering the three-year period 2015-2017, was approved by the MDPSC on December 23, 2014. The costs of the 2015-2017 plan are expected to be approximately $68 million for that three-year period, of which $32 million was incurred through June 2016. On July 16, 2015, the MDPSC issued an order setting new incremental energy savings goals for 2017 and beyond, beginning with the level of savings achieved under PE's current plan for 2016, and ramping up 0.2% per year thereafter to reach 2%. PE continues to recover program costs subject to a five-year amortization. Maryland law only allows for the utility to recover lost distribution revenue attributable to energy efficiency or demand reduction programs through a base rate case proceeding, and to date, such recovery has not been sought or obtained by PE.

On February 27, 2013, the MDPSC issued an order (the February 27 Order) requiring the Maryland electric utilities to submit analyses relating to the costs and benefits of making further system and staffing enhancements in order to attempt to reduce storm outage durations. The order further required the Staff of the MDPSC to report on possible performance-based rate structures and to propose additional rules relating to feeder performance standards, outage communication and reporting, and sharing of special needs customer information. PE's responsive filings discussed the steps needed to harden the utility's system in order to attempt to achieve various levels of storm response speed described in the February 27 Order, and projected that it would require approximately $2.7 billion in infrastructure investments over 15 years to attempt to achieve the quickest level of response for the largest storm projected in the February 27 Order. On July 1, 2014, the Staff of the MDPSC issued a set of reports that recommended the imposition of extensive additional requirements in the areas of storm response, feeder performance, estimates of restoration times, and regulatory reporting. The Staff of the MDPSC also recommended the imposition of penalties, including customer rebates, for a utility's failure or inability to comply with the escalating standards of storm restoration speed proposed by the Staff of the MDPSC. In addition, the Staff of the MDPSC proposed that the utilities be required to develop and implement system hardening plans, up to a rate impact cap on cost. The MDPSC conducted a hearing September 15-18, 2014, to consider certain of these matters, and has not yet issued a ruling on any of those matters.

### NEW JERSEY

JCP&L currently provides BGS for retail customers who do not choose a third party EGS and for customers of third party EGSs that fail to provide the contracted service. The supply for BGS is comprised of two components, procured through separate, annually held descending clock auctions, the results of which are approved by the NJBPU. One BGS component reflects hourly real time energy prices and is available for larger commercial and industrial customers. The second BGS component provides a fixed price service and is intended for smaller commercial and residential customers. All New Jersey EDCs participate in this competitive BGS procurement process and recover BGS costs directly from customers as a charge separate from base rates.

Pursuant to the NJBPU's March 26, 2015 final order in JCP&L's 2012 rate case proceeding directing that certain studies be completed, on July 22, 2015, the NJBPU approved the NJBPU staff's recommendation to implement such studies, which include operational and financial components. The independent consultant conducting the review issued a final report on July 27, 2016, recognizing that JCP&L is meeting the NJBPU requirements and making various operational and financial recommendations. The NJBPU is expected to complete its review in the third quarter of 2016.

In an Order issued October 22, 2014, in a generic proceeding to review its policies with respect to the use of a CTA in base rate cases (Generic CTA proceeding), the NJBPU stated that it would continue to apply its current CTA policy in base rate cases, subject to incorporating the following modifications: (i) calculating savings using a five-year look back from the beginning of the test year; (ii) allocating savings with 75% retained by the company and 25% allocated to rate payers; and (iii) excluding transmission assets of electric distribution companies in the savings calculation. On November 5, 2014, the Division of Rate Counsel appealed the NJBPU Order regarding the Generic CTA proceeding to the New Jersey Superior Court and JCP&L has filed to participate as a respondent in that proceeding. Briefing has been completed, and oral argument has not yet been scheduled.

On April 28, 2016, JCP&L filed tariffs with the NJBPU proposing a general rate increase associated with its distribution operations that seeks to improve service and benefit customers by supporting equipment maintenance, tree trimming, and inspections of lines, poles and substations, while also compensating for other business and operating expenses. The filing requested approval to increase annual operating revenues by approximately $142.1 million based upon a hybrid test year for the twelve months ending June 30, 2016. JCP&L requested that the proposed new rates take effect in January 2017. On July 13, 2016, this matter was submitted to the Office of Administrative Law for hearing and the issuance of an Initial Decision. A procedural schedule has not yet been issued.

On June 19, 2015, JCP&L, along with PN, ME, FET and MAIT made filings with FERC, the NJBPU, and the PPUC requesting authorization for JCP&L, PN and ME to contribute their transmission assets to MAIT, a new transmission-only subsidiary of FET. The procedural schedule was suspended while the NJBPU considered a motion on a legal issue regarding whether MAIT can be designated as a "public utility" in New Jersey. On February 24, 2016, the NJBPU issued an Order concluding that MAIT does not satisfy the “electricity distribution” element necessary for “public utility” status because MAIT would not own any electric distribution assets in New Jersey. On April 22, 2016, JCP&L and MAIT filed a supplemental petition and testimony seeking to include certain JCP&L distributions assets in the transfer to satisfy the "electricity distribution" element necessary for "public utility" status in accordance with the NJBPU’s February 24, 2016 order. On July 18, 2016, the procedural schedule was set with evidentiary hearings in late October and early November of 2016. See Transfer of Transmission Assets to MAIT in FERC Matters below for further discussion of this transaction.

### OHIO

The Ohio Companies operated under their ESP 3 plan which expired on May 31, 2016. On May 18, 2016, in response to previous appeals, the Supreme Court of Ohio issued its Opinion affirming in all respects the PUCO's ESP 3 Order.

The Ohio Companies filed an application with the PUCO on August 4, 2014 seeking approval of their ESP IV entitled *Powering Ohio's Progress.* The Ohio Companies filed a Stipulation and Recommendation on December 22, 2014, and supplemental stipulations and recommendations on May 28, 2015, and June 4, 2015. On December 1, 2015, the Ohio Companies filed a Third Supplemental Stipulation and Recommendation, which included PUCO Staff as a signatory party in addition to other signatories.

The material terms of ESP IV, as modified by the stipulations included:

- An eight-year term (June 1, 2016 - May 31, 2024);
- Contemplates continuing a base distribution rate freeze through May 31, 2024;
- An Economic Stability Program that flows through charges or credits through Rider RRS representing the net result of the price paid to FES through an eight-year FERC-jurisdictional PPA, referred to as the ESP IV PPA, for the output of the ESP IV PPA Facilities against the revenues received from selling such output into the PJM markets;
- Continuing to provide power to non-shopping customers at a market-based price set through an auction process;
- Continuing Rider DCR with increased revenue caps of approximately $30 million per year from June 1, 2016 through May 31, 2019; $20 million per year from June 1, 2019 through May 31, 2022; and $15 million per year from June 1, 2022 through May 31, 2024 that supports continued investment related to the distribution system for the benefit of customers;
- Collection of lost distribution revenues associated with energy efficiency and peak demand reduction programs;
- A risk-sharing mechanism that would provide guaranteed credits under Rider RRS in years five through eight to customers as follows: $10 million in year five, $20 million in year six, $30 million in year seven and $40 million in year eight;
- A continuing commitment not to recover from retail customers certain costs related to transmission cost allocations for the longer of the five-year period from June 1, 2011 through May 31, 2016 or when the amount of such costs avoided by customers for certain types of products totals $360 million, including such costs from MISO along with such costs from PJM, subject to the outcome of certain FERC proceedings;
- Potential procurement of 100 MW of new Ohio wind or solar resources subject to a demonstrated need to procure new renewable energy resources as part of a strategy to further diversify Ohio's energy portfolio;
- An agreement to file a case with the PUCO by April 3, 2017, seeking to transition to decoupled base rates for residential customers;
- An agreement to file by February 29, 2016, a Grid Modernization Business Plan for PUCO consideration and approval (which filing was made on February 29, 2016);
- A goal across FirstEnergy to reduce CO2 emissions by 90% below 2005 levels by 2045;
- A contribution of $3 million per year ($24 million over the eight-year term) to fund energy conservation programs, economic development and job retention in the Ohio Companies service territory;
- Contributions of $2.4 million per year ($19 million over the eight-year term) to fund a fuel-fund in each of the Ohio Companies service territories to assist low-income customers; and
- A contribution of $1 million per year ($8 million over the eight-year term) to establish a Customary Advisory Council to ensure preservation and growth of the competitive market in Ohio.

On March 31, 2016, the PUCO issued an Opinion and Order adopting and approving, with modifications, the Ohio Companies’ ESP IV. Certain changes arising from the approval of ESP IV went into effect on June 1, 2016. The PUCO’s modifications of ESP IV, among others, included:

- Limiting average customer bill amounts for the first two years of the plan, subject to certain exceptions, and permitting deferral for the second year;
- Prohibiting recovery of retirement costs of the ESP IV PPA Facilities through Rider RRS;
- Assigning the burden of capacity performance penalties incurred by the ESP IV PPA Facilities to the Ohio Companies, rather than customers, and to provide that all capacity performance bonuses earned by the ESP IV PPA Facilities be retained by the Ohio Companies, rather than customers; and
- Providing for the modification of the severability provision previously included in ESP IV, to also address potential future PJM Tariff or rule changes prohibiting the Ohio Companies from offering output of the ESP IV PPA Facilities into PJM auctions.

FES and the Ohio Companies entered into the ESP IV PPA on April 1, 2016.

On January 27, 2016, certain parties filed a complaint with FERC against FES and the Ohio Companies requesting FERC review the ESP IV PPA under Section 205 of the FPA. On April 27, 2016, FERC issued an order granting the complaint, prohibiting any transactions under the ESP IV PPA pending future authorization by FERC, and directing FES to submit the ESP IV PPA for FERC review if the companies desired to transact under the agreement. Pursuant to FERC's directives in the order, FES and the Ohio Companies submitted required compliance filings. FES and the Ohio Companies did not file the ESP IV PPA for FERC review, but rather agreed to suspend the ESP IV PPA prior to transacting thereunder, pending the outcome of the PUCO and FERC proceedings.

On April 29, 2016 and May 2, 2016, applications for rehearing on the Ohio Companies ESP IV were filed with the PUCO by several parties, including the Ohio Companies. As part of the Ohio Companies’ application for rehearing, the Ohio Companies proposed a modified Rider RRS. The PUCO issued an Entry on Rehearing on May 11, 2016 granting the applications for rehearing for the purpose of further consideration of the matters raised therein. On June 29, 2016, PUCO Staff filed testimony recommending that the Ohio Companies’ modified Rider RRS proposal be denied, and instead recommended a new Distribution Modernization Rider providing for the collection of $131 million annually for three years with a possible extension for an additional two years. The hearing began on July 11, 2016 for the modified Rider RRS proposal. On July 25, 2016, the Ohio Companies filed testimony that continues to recommend that the PUCO approve the proposed modified Rider RRS and that the revenues and expenses of the proposed modified Rider RRS be excluded from the significantly excessive earnings test. The Ohio Companies' filing also provided testimony that a properly designed Distribution Modernization Rider would be valued at $558 million annually for 8 years, include an additional amount, as determined by the PUCO, that recognizes the value of the economic impact of FirstEnergy maintaining its headquarters in Ohio, and would also be excluded from the significantly excessive earnings test.

Several parties filed protests and comments with FERC alleging, among other things, that the modified Rider RRS constitutes a "virtual PPA". The filings and responses thereto are pending before FERC.

On March 21, 2016, a number of generation owners filed with FERC a complaint against PJM requesting that FERC expand the MOPR in the PJM Tariff to prevent the alleged artificial suppression of prices in the PJM capacity markets by state-subsidized generation, in particular alleged price suppression that could result from the ESP IV PPA and other similar agreements. The complaint requested an order by May 1, 2016, so the revised rule could be in effect for the May 2016 BRA, and also that FERC direct PJM to initiate a stakeholder process to develop a long-term MOPR reform for existing resources that receive out-of-market revenue. FERC took no action on the complaint prior to the BRA, and therefore the proposed MOPR was not in effect for the auction. Subsequently, certain municipal and industrial customers and a regulated utility, not affiliated with the Ohio Companies, filed a motion to dismiss the complaint as moot in light of FERC’s April 27, 2016 orders on, among other things, the ESP IV PPA and the resulting suspension of the ESP IV PPA. This proceeding remains pending before FERC.

Under Ohio's energy efficiency standards (SB221 and SB310), and based on the Ohio Companies' amended energy efficiency plans, the Ohio Companies are required to implement energy efficiency programs that achieve a total annual energy savings equivalent of 2,266 GWHs in 2015 and 2,288 GWHs in 2016, and then begin to increase by 1% each year in 2017, subject to legislative amendments to the energy efficiency standards discussed below. The Ohio Companies are also required to retain the 2014 peak demand reduction level for 2015 and 2016 and then increase the benchmark by an additional 0.75% thereafter through 2020, subject to legislative amendments to the peak demand reduction standards discussed below.

On September 30, 2015, the Energy Mandates Study Committee issued its report related to energy efficiency and renewable energy mandates, recommending that the current level of mandates remain in place indefinitely. The report also recommended: (i) an expedited process for review of utility proposed energy efficiency plans; (ii) ensuring maximum credit for all of Ohio's Energy Initiatives; (iii) a switch from energy mandates to energy incentives; and (iv) a declaration be made that the General Assembly may determine the energy policy of the state. Legislation was introduced to address issues raised in the Energy Mandates Study Committee report, namely SB320 and HB554. SB320 proposes to freeze energy efficiency and renewable energy requirements for an additional four years at 2014 levels, as well as addressing net metering issues. HB554 proposes to freeze energy efficiency and renewable energy requirements through 2027 at 2014 levels.

On September 24, 2014, the Ohio Companies filed an amendment to their energy efficiency portfolio plan as contemplated by SB310, seeking to suspend certain programs for the 2015-2016 period in order to better align the plan with the new benchmarks under SB310. On November 20, 2014, the PUCO approved the Ohio Companies' amended portfolio plan. Several applications for rehearing were filed, and the PUCO granted those applications for further consideration of the matters specified in those applications and the matter remains pending before the PUCO.

On April 15, 2016, the Ohio Companies filed an application for approval of their three-year energy efficiency portfolio plans for the period from January 1, 2017 through December 31, 2019. The plans as proposed comply with benchmarks contemplated by SB310 and provisions of the ESP IV, and include a portfolio of energy efficiency programs targeted to a variety of customer segments, including residential customers, low income customers, small commercial customers, large commercial and industrial customers and governmental entities. The Ohio Companies anticipate the cost of the plans will be approximately $323 million over the life of the portfolio plans and such costs are expected to be recovered through the Ohio Companies’ existing rate mechanisms. A hearing in this matter has been scheduled for October 11, 2016.

On September 16, 2013, the Ohio Companies filed with the Supreme Court of Ohio a notice of appeal of the PUCO's July 17, 2013 Entry on Rehearing related to energy efficiency, alternative energy, and long-term forecast rules stating that the rules issued by the PUCO are inconsistent with, and are not supported by, statutory authority. On October 23, 2013, the PUCO filed a motion to dismiss the appeal, which was denied. The matter has been scheduled for oral argument on August 17, 2016.

Ohio law requires electric utilities and electric service companies in Ohio to serve part of their load from renewable energy resources measured by an annually increasing percentage amount through 2026, subject to legislative amendments discussed above, except 2015 and 2016 that remain at the 2014 level. The Ohio Companies conducted RFPs in 2009, 2010 and 2011 to secure RECs to help meet these renewable energy requirements. In September 2011, the PUCO opened a docket to review the Ohio Companies' alternative energy recovery rider through which the Ohio Companies recover the costs of acquiring these RECs. The PUCO issued an Opinion and Order on August 7, 2013, approving the Ohio Companies' acquisition process and their purchases of RECs to meet statutory mandates in all instances except for certain purchases arising from one auction and directed the Ohio Companies to credit non-shopping customers in the amount of $43.4 million, plus interest, on the basis that the Ohio Companies did not prove such purchases were prudent. On December 24, 2013, following the denial of their application for rehearing, the Ohio Companies filed a notice of appeal and a motion for stay of the PUCO's order with the Supreme Court of Ohio, which was granted. On February 18, 2014, the OCC and the ELPC also filed appeals of the PUCO's order. The Ohio Companies timely filed their merit brief with the Supreme Court of Ohio and the briefing process has concluded. The matter is not yet scheduled for oral argument.

On April 9, 2014, the PUCO initiated a generic investigation of marketing practices in the competitive retail electric service market, with a focus on the marketing of fixed-price or guaranteed percent-off SSO rate contracts where there is a provision that permits the pass-through of new or additional charges. On November 18, 2015, the PUCO ruled that on a going-forward basis, pass-through clauses may not be included in fixed-price contracts for all customer classes. On December 18, 2015, FES filed an Application for Rehearing seeking to change the ruling or have it only apply to residential and small commercial customers.

### PENNSYLVANIA

The Pennsylvania Companies currently operate under DSPs that expire on May 31, 2017, and provide for the competitive procurement of generation supply for customers that do not choose an alternative EGS or for customers of alternative EGSs that fail to provide the contracted service. The default service supply is currently provided by wholesale suppliers through a mix of long-term and short-term contracts procured through spot market purchases, quarterly descending clock auctions for 3, 12- and 24-month energy contracts, and one RFP seeking 2-year contracts to serve SRECs for ME, PN and Penn.

On November 3, 2015, the Pennsylvania Companies filed their DSPs for the June 1, 2017 through May 31, 2019 delivery period, which would provide for the competitive procurement of generation supply for customers who do not choose an alternative EGS or for customers of alternative EGSs that fail to provide the contracted service. Under the programs, the supply would be provided by wholesale suppliers through a mix of 12 and 24-month energy contracts, as well as one RFP for 2-year SREC contracts for ME, PN and Penn. In addition, the plan includes modifications to the Pennsylvania Companies’ existing POR programs in order to reduce the level of uncollectible expense the Pennsylvania Companies experience associated with alternative EGS charges. A hearing was held on February 25, 2016. A Joint Petition for Settlement resolving all issues was filed on April 1, 2016 and was approved by the PPUC on May 19, 2016.

Pursuant to Pennsylvania's EE&C legislation (Act 129 of 2008) and PPUC orders, Pennsylvania EDCs implement energy efficiency and peak demand reduction programs. The Pennsylvania Companies' Phase II EE&C Plans were effective through May 31, 2016. Total Phase II costs of these plans were expected to be approximately $175 million and recoverable through the Pennsylvania Companies' reconcilable EE&C riders. On June 19, 2015, the PPUC issued a Phase III Final Implementation Order setting: demand reduction targets, relative to each Pennsylvania Companies' 2007-2008 peak demand (in MW), at 1.8% for ME, 1.7% for Penn, 1.8% for WP, and 0% for PN; and energy consumption reduction targets, as a percentage of each Pennsylvania Companies’ historic 2010 forecasts (in MWH), at 4.0% for ME, 3.9% for PN, 3.3% for Penn, and 2.6% for WP. The Pennsylvania Companies filed their Phase III EE&C plans for the June 2016 through May 2021 period on November 23, 2015, which are designed to achieve the targets established in the PPUC's Phase III Final Implementation Order. EDCs are permitted to recover costs for implementing their EE&C plans. On February 10, 2016, the Pennsylvania Companies and the parties intervening in the PPUC's Phase III proceeding filed a joint settlement resolving all issues, which was subject to PPUC approval. On March 10, 2016, the PPUC entered an Opinion and Order approving the settlement and directing that the Pennsylvania Companies modify certain cost recovery methodologies to describe the allocation of EE&C Phase III common costs among customer classes and to describe the recovery of remaining costs of their Phase II EE&C Plans. None of the parties to the joint settlement elected to withdraw from the joint settlement due to the modifications. On May 24, 2016, the PPUC issued a Secretarial Letter permitting the as filed EE&C rates for the Pennsylvania Companies to become effective on June 1, 2016.

Pursuant to Act 11 of 2012, Pennsylvania EDCs may establish a DSIC to recover costs of infrastructure improvements and costs related to highway relocation projects with PPUC approval. Pennsylvania EDCs must file LTIIPs outlining infrastructure improvement plans for PPUC review and approval prior to approval of a DSIC. On October 19, 2015, each of the Pennsylvania Companies filed LTIIPs with the PPUC for infrastructure improvement over the five-year period of 2016 to 2020 for the following costs: WP $88.34 million; PN $56.74 million; Penn $56.35 million; and ME $43.44 million. On February 11, 2016, the PPUC approved the Pennsylvania Companies' LTIIPs. On February 16, 2016, the Pennsylvania Companies filed DSIC riders for PPUC approval for quarterly cost recovery associated with the capital projects approved in the LTIIPs. On June 9, 2016, the PPUC approved the Pennsylvania Companies’ DSIC riders to be effective July 1, 2016, subject to hearings and refund or reallocation among customers.

On April 28, 2016, each of the Pennsylvania Companies filed tariffs with the PPUC proposing general rate increases associated with their distribution operations that will benefit customers by modernizing the grid with smart technologies, increasing vegetation management activities, and continuing other customer service enhancements. The filings request approval to increase annual operating revenues by approximately $140.2 million at ME, $158.8 million at PN, $42.0 million at Penn, and $98.2 million at WP, based upon fully projected future test years for the twelve months ending December 31, 2017 at each of the Pennsylvania Companies. As a result of the enactment of Act 40 of 2016 that terminated the practice of making a CTA when calculating a utility’s federal income taxes for ratemaking purposes, the Pennsylvania Companies submitted supplemental testimony on July 7, 2016, that quantified the value of the elimination of the CTA and outlined their plan for investing 50 percent of that amount in rate base eligible equipment as required by the new law. A procedural schedule has been set with hearings commencing on September 6, 2016. The proposed new rates are expected to take effect in January 2017, pending regulatory approval.

On June 19, 2015, ME and PN, along with JCP&L, FET and MAIT made filings with FERC, the NJBPU, and the PPUC requesting authorization for JCP&L, PN and ME to contribute their transmission assets to MAIT, a new transmission-only subsidiary of FET. On March 4, 2016, a Joint Petition for Full Settlement was submitted to the PPUC for consideration and approval. On April 18, 2016, the ALJs issued an Initial Decision approving the Joint Petition for Full Settlement without modifications. On July 21, 2016, the PPUC adopted a Motion approving the Joint Petition for Full Settlement with minor modifications. A final order consistent with the Motion is expected in the near future. See Transfer of Transmission Assets to MAIT in FERC Matters below for further discussion of this transaction.

### WEST VIRGINIA

MP and PE provide electric service to all customers through traditional cost-based, regulated utility ratemaking. MP and PE recover net power supply costs, including fuel costs, purchased power costs and related expenses, net of related market sales revenue through the ENEC. MP's and PE's ENEC rate is updated annually.

MP and PE filed with the WVPSC on March 31, 2016 their Phase II energy efficiency program proposal for approval. MP and PE are proposing three energy efficiency programs to meet their Phase II requirement of energy efficiency reductions of 0.5% of 2013 distribution sales for the January 1, 2017 through May 31, 2018 period, as agreed to by MP and PE, and approved by the WVPSC in the 2012 proceeding approving the transfer of ownership of Harrison Power Station to MP. The costs for the program are expected to be $9.9 million and would be recovered through the existing energy efficiency rider which is reviewed in the fuel (ENEC) case each year. A hearing is scheduled to commence on August 18, 2016. MP and PE are requesting WVPSC approval by October 1, 2016 so MP and PE can implement the programs beginning January 1, 2017.

### RELIABILITY MATTERS

Federally-enforceable mandatory reliability standards apply to the bulk electric system and impose certain operating, record-keeping and reporting requirements on the Utilities, FES, AE Supply, FG, FENOC, NG, ATSI and TrAIL. NERC is the ERO designated by FERC to establish and enforce these reliability standards, although NERC has delegated day-to-day implementation and enforcement of these reliability standards to eight regional entities, including RFC. All of FirstEnergy's facilities are located within the RFC region. FirstEnergy actively participates in the NERC and RFC stakeholder processes, and otherwise monitors and manages its companies in response to the ongoing development, implementation and enforcement of the reliability standards implemented and enforced by RFC.

FirstEnergy believes that it is in compliance with all currently-effective and enforceable reliability standards. Nevertheless, in the course of operating its extensive electric utility systems and facilities, FirstEnergy occasionally learns of isolated facts or circumstances that could be interpreted as excursions from the reliability standards. If and when such occurrences are found, FirstEnergy develops information about the occurrence and develops a remedial response to the specific circumstances, including in appropriate cases “self-reporting” an occurrence to RFC. Moreover, it is clear that NERC, RFC and FERC will continue to refine existing reliability standards as well as to develop and adopt new reliability standards. Any inability on FirstEnergy's part to comply with the reliability standards for its bulk electric system could result in the imposition of financial penalties, and obligations to upgrade or build transmission facilities, that could have a material adverse effect on its financial condition, results of operations and cash flows.

### FERC MATTERS

#### Ohio ESP IV PPA

For information regarding matters before FERC related to the ESP IV PPA between FES and the Ohio Companies, see “Regulatory Matters - Ohio” above.

#### PJM Transmission Rates

PJM and its stakeholders have been debating the proper method to allocate costs for new transmission facilities. While FirstEnergy and other parties advocate for a traditional "beneficiary pays" (or usage based) approach, others advocate for “socializing” the costs on a load-ratio share basis, where each customer in the zone would pay based on its total usage of energy within PJM. This question has been the subject of extensive litigation before FERC and the appellate courts, including before the Seventh Circuit. On June 25, 2014, a divided three-judge panel of the Seventh Circuit ruled that FERC had not quantified the benefits that western PJM utilities would derive from certain new 500 kV or higher lines and thus had not adequately supported its decision to socialize the costs of these lines. The majority found that eastern PJM utilities are the primary beneficiaries of the lines, while western PJM utilities are only incidental beneficiaries, and that, while incidental beneficiaries should pay some share of the costs of the lines, that share should be proportionate to the benefit they derive from the lines, and not on load-ratio share in PJM as a whole. The court remanded the case to FERC, which issued an order setting the issue of cost allocation for hearing and settlement proceedings. On June 15, 2016 various parties, including ATSI and the Utilities, filed a settlement agreement at FERC agreeing to apply a combined usage based/socialization approach to cost allocation for charges to transmission customers in the PJM region for transmission projects operating at or above 500 kV. Certain parties in the proceeding did not agree to the settlement and filed protests to the settlement, to which the settling parties, including ATSI and the Utilities, responded on July 15, 2016. On July 15, 2016, and July 25, 2016, the protesting parties filed to strike certain of the evidence advanced by FirstEnergy and certain of the other settling parties in support of the settlement, as well as provided further comments in opposition to the settlement. The PJM TOs intend to submit responses to the motions to strike, and to the further comments of the protesting parties.

In a series of orders in certain Order No. 1000 dockets, FERC asserted that the PJM transmission owners do not hold an incumbent “right of first refusal” to construct, own and operate transmission projects within their respective footprints that are approved as part of PJM’s RTEP process. FirstEnergy and other PJM transmission owners appealed these rulings to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit which, in a July 1, 2016 opinion, ruled that the PJM transmission owners failed to preserve their arguments in the legal proceedings before FERC and, on that basis, denied the appeal. In a related case brought by the Southwest Power Pool transmission owners and issued on the same day, the court ruled that the *Mobile-Sierra* standard does not protect transmission owners’ rights of first refusal that may be provided for in RTO tariffs because, according to the court, the tariff language is designed to block competition. The *Mobile-Sierra* standard presumes that rates negotiated by private parties at arm’s length are just and reasonable and prohibits FERC from modifying such rates unless the public interest requires.

The outcome of these proceedings and their impact, if any, on FirstEnergy cannot be predicted at this time.

#### RTO Realignment

On June 1, 2011, ATSI and the ATSI zone transferred from MISO to PJM. While many of the matters involved with the move have been resolved, FERC denied recovery under ATSI's transmission rate for certain charges that collectively can be described as "exit fees" and certain other transmission cost allocation charges totaling approximately $78.8 million until such time as ATSI submits a cost/benefit analysis demonstrating net benefits to customers from the transfer to PJM. Subsequently, FERC rejected a proposed settlement agreement to resolve the exit fee and transmission cost allocation issues, stating that its action is without prejudice to ATSI submitting a cost/benefit analysis demonstrating that the benefits of the RTO realignment decisions outweigh the exit fee and transmission cost allocation charges. On March 17, 2016, FERC denied FirstEnergy's request for rehearing of FERC's earlier order rejecting the settlement agreement and affirmed its prior ruling that ATSI must submit the cost/benefit analysis.

Separately, the question of ATSI's responsibility for certain costs for the “Michigan Thumb” transmission project continues to be disputed. Potential responsibility arises under the MISO MVP tariff, which has been litigated in complex proceedings before FERC and certain United States appellate courts. On October 29, 2015, FERC issued an order finding that ATSI and the ATSI zone do not have to pay MISO MVP charges for the Michigan Thumb transmission project. MISO and the MISO TOs filed a request for rehearing, which FERC denied on May 19, 2016. On July 15, 2016, the MISO TOs filed an appeal of FERC's orders with the Sixth Circuit. FirstEnergy expects to intervene and participate in the appeal. On a related issue, FirstEnergy joined certain other PJM transmission owners in a protest of MISO's proposal to allocate MVP costs to energy transactions that cross MISO's borders into the PJM Region. On July 13, 2016, FERC issued its order finding it appropriate for MISO to assess an MVP usage charge for transmission exports from MISO to PJM. FirstEnergy and the other PJM TOs are evaluating whether to seek rehearing of FERC’s order.

In addition, in a May 31, 2011 order, FERC ruled that the costs for certain "legacy RTEP" transmission projects in PJM approved before ATSI joined PJM could be charged to transmission customers in the ATSI zone. The amount to be paid, and the question of derived benefits, is pending before FERC as a result of the Seventh Circuit's June 25, 2014 order described above under PJM Transmission Rates.

The outcome of the proceedings that address the remaining open issues related to costs for the "Michigan Thumb" transmission project and "legacy RTEP" transmission projects cannot be predicted at this time.

#### Transfer of Transmission Assets to MAIT

On June 10, 2015, MAIT, a Delaware limited liability company, was formed as a new transmission-only subsidiary of FET for the purposes of owning and operating all FERC-jurisdictional transmission assets of JCP&L, ME and PN following the receipt of all necessary state and federal regulatory approvals. On June 19, 2015, JCP&L, PN, ME, FET, and MAIT made filings with FERC, the NJBPU, and the PPUC requesting authorization for JCP&L, PN and ME to contribute their transmission assets to MAIT. Additionally, the filings requested approval from the NJBPU and PPUC, as applicable, of: (i) a lease to MAIT of real property and rights-of-way associated with the utilities' transmission assets; (ii) a Mutual Assistance Agreement; (iii) MAIT being deemed a public utility under state law; (iv) MAIT's participation in FE's regulated companies' money pool; and (v) certain affiliated interest agreements. If approved, JCP&L, ME, and PN will contribute their transmission assets at net book value and an allocated portion of goodwill in a tax-free exchange to MAIT, which will operate similar to FET's two existing stand-alone transmission subsidiaries, ATSI and TrAIL. MAIT's transmission facilities will remain under the functional control of PJM, and PJM will provide transmission service using these facilities under the PJM Tariff. FERC approved the transaction on February 18, 2016. The PPUC approved the transaction on July 21, 2016, subject to the entry of a final order. Upon receipt of all applicable regulatory approvals with respect to the transfer, MAIT expects to file a Section 204 application with FERC, and other necessary filings with the PPUC and the NJBPU, seeking authorization to issue equity to FET, JCP&L, PN and ME for their respective contributions, and to issue debt. MAIT will also make a Section 205 formula rate application with FERC to establish its transmission rate. See New Jersey and Pennsylvania in State Regulation above for further discussion of this transaction.

#### California Claims Litigation

In October 2006, several California governmental and utility parties presented AE Supply with a settlement proposal to resolve alleged overcharges for power sales by AE Supply to the California Energy Resource Scheduling division of the CDWR during 2001. The settlement proposal claims that CDWR is owed approximately $190 million for these alleged overcharges. This proposal was made in the context of mediation efforts by FERC and the Ninth Circuit in several pending proceedings to resolve all outstanding refund and other claims, including claims of alleged price manipulation in the California energy markets during 2000 and 2001. The Ninth Circuit had previously remanded one of those proceedings to FERC, which dismissed the claims of the California parties in May 2011. The California parties appealed FERC's decision back to the Ninth Circuit. AE Supply joined with other intervenors in the case and filed a brief in support of FERC's dismissal of the case. On April 29, 2015, the Ninth Circuit remanded the case to FERC for further proceedings. On November 3, 2015, FERC set for hearing and settlement procedures the remanded issue of whether any individual public utility seller’s violation of FERC’s market-based rate quarterly reporting requirement led to an unjust and unreasonable rate for that particular seller in California during the 2000-2001 period. Settlement discussions under a FERC-appointed settlement judge are ongoing. On March 1, 2016, FERC issued an order on rehearing clarifying the scope of the evidentiary hearing and the standard of review on remand. In particular, FERC clarified that certain bilateral transactions, including those of AE Supply to the California parties, are protected by the *Mobile-Sierra* standard, which requires a demonstration of harm to the public interest to determine liability and obligation to make refunds. The California parties requested rehearing of FERC’s March 1, 2016 order; FERC's order on rehearing remains pending. The California Parties also appealed FERC’s November 3, 2015, and March 1, 2016 orders to the Ninth Circuit, which has stayed its review pending the outcome of the ongoing proceeding discussed above.

In another proceeding, in May 2009, the California Attorney General, on behalf of certain California parties, filed a complaint with FERC against various sellers, including AE Supply, again seeking refunds for transactions in the California energy markets during 2000 and 2001. The above-noted transactions with CDWR are the basis for including AE Supply in this complaint. AE Supply and other parties filed motions to dismiss, which FERC granted. The California Attorney General appealed FERC's dismissal of its complaint to the Ninth Circuit, which has consolidated the case with other pending appeals related to California refund claims, and stayed the proceedings pending further order.

The outcome of either of the above matters or estimate of loss or range of loss cannot be predicted at this time.

#### PATH Transmission Project

On August 24, 2012, the PJM Board of Managers canceled the PATH project, a proposed transmission line from West Virginia through Virginia and into Maryland which PJM had previously suspended in February 2011. As a result of PJM canceling the project, approximately $62 million and approximately $59 million in costs incurred by PATH-Allegheny and PATH-WV, respectively, were reclassified from net property, plant and equipment to a regulatory asset for future recovery. PATH-Allegheny and PATH-WV requested authorization from FERC to recover the costs with a proposed ROE of 10.9% (10.4% base plus 0.5% for RTO membership) from PJM customers over five years. FERC issued an order denying the 0.5% ROE adder for RTO membership and allowing the tariff changes enabling recovery of these costs to become effective on December 1, 2012, subject to settlement proceedings and hearing if the parties could not agree to a settlement. On March 24, 2014, the FERC Chief ALJ terminated settlement proceedings and appointed an ALJ to preside over the hearing phase of the case, including discovery and additional pleadings leading up to hearing, which subsequently included the parties addressing the application of FERC's Opinion No. 531, discussed below, to the PATH proceeding. On September 14, 2015, the ALJ issued his initial decision, disallowing recovery of certain costs. The initial decision and exceptions thereto remain before FERC for review and a final order. FirstEnergy continues to believe the costs are recoverable, subject to final ruling from FERC.

#### FERC Opinion No. 531

On June 19, 2014, FERC issued Opinion No. 531, in which FERC revised its approach for calculating the discounted cash flow element of FERC’s ROE methodology, and announced the potential for a qualitative adjustment to the ROE methodology results. Under the old methodology, FERC used a five-year forecast for the dividend growth variable, whereas going forward the growth variable will consist of two parts: (a) a five-year forecast for dividend growth (2/3 weight); and (b) a long-term dividend growth forecast based on a forecast for the U.S. economy (1/3 weight). Regarding the qualitative adjustment, for single-utility rate cases FERC formerly pegged ROE at the median of the “zone of reasonableness” that came out of the ROE formula, whereas going forward, FERC may rely on record evidence to make qualitative adjustments to the outcome of the ROE methodology in order to reach a level sufficient to attract future investment. On October 16, 2014, FERC issued its Opinion No. 531-A, applying the revised ROE methodology to certain ISO New England transmission owners, and on March 3, 2015, FERC issued Opinion No. 531-B affirming its prior rulings. Appeals of Opinion Nos. 531, 531-A and 531-B are pending before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.

#### MISO Capacity Portability

On June 11, 2012, in response to certain arguments advanced by MISO, FERC requested comments regarding whether existing rules on transfer capability act as barriers to the delivery of capacity between MISO and PJM. FirstEnergy and other parties submitted filings arguing that MISO's concerns largely are without foundation, FERC did not mandate a solution in response to MISO's concerns. At FERC's direction, in May, 2015, PJM, MISO, and their respective independent market monitors provided additional information on their various joint issues surrounding the PJM/MISO seam to assist FERC's understanding of the issues and what, if any, additional steps FERC should take to improve the efficiency of operations at the PJM/MISO seam. Stakeholders, including FESC on behalf of certain of its affiliates and as part of a coalition of certain other PJM utilities, filed responses to the RTO submissions. The various submissions and responses remain before FERC for consideration.

Changes to the criteria and qualifications for participation in the PJM RPM capacity auctions could have a significant impact on the outcome of those auctions, including a negative impact on the prices at which those auctions would clear.

### ENVIRONMENTAL MATTERS

Various federal, state and local authorities regulate FirstEnergy with regard to air and water quality and other environmental matters. Compliance with environmental regulations could have a material adverse effect on FirstEnergy's earnings and competitive position to the extent that FirstEnergy competes with companies that are not subject to such regulations and, therefore, do not bear the risk of costs associated with compliance, or failure to comply, with such regulations.

#### Clean Air Act

FirstEnergy complies with SO2 and NOx emission reduction requirements under the CAA and SIP(s) by burning lower-sulfur fuel, utilizing combustion controls and post-combustion controls, generating more electricity from lower or non-emitting plants and/or using emission allowances.

CSAPR requires reductions of NOx and SO2 emissions in two phases (2015 and 2017), ultimately capping SO2 emissions in affected states to 2.4 million tons annually and NOx emissions to 1.2 million tons annually. CSAPR allows trading of NOx and SO2 emission allowances between power plants located in the same state and interstate trading of NOx and SO2 emission allowances with some restrictions. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ordered the EPA on July 28, 2015, to reconsider the CSAPR caps on NOx and SO2 emissions from power plants in 13 states, including Ohio, Pennsylvania and West Virginia. This follows the 2014 U.S. Supreme Court ruling generally upholding EPA’s regulatory approach under CSAPR, but questioning whether EPA required upwind states to reduce emissions by more than their contribution to air pollution in downwind states. EPA proposed a CSAPR update rule on November 16, 2015, that would reduce summertime NOx emissions from power plants in 23 states in the eastern U.S., including Ohio, Pennsylvania and West Virginia, beginning in 2017. Depending on how the EPA and the states implement CSAPR, the future cost of compliance may be material and changes to FirstEnergy's and FES' operations may result.

EPA tightened the primary and secondary NAAQS for ozone from the 2008 standard levels of 75 PPB to 70 PPB on October 1, 2015. EPA stated the vast majority of U.S. counties will meet the new 70 PPB standard by 2025 due to other federal and state rules and programs but EPA will designate those counties that fail to attain the new 2015 ozone NAAQS by October 1, 2017. States will then have roughly three years to develop implementation plans to attain the new 2015 ozone NAAQS. Depending on how the EPA and the states implement the new 2015 ozone NAAQS, the future cost of compliance may be material and changes to FirstEnergy’s and FES’ operations may result.

MATS imposes emission limits for mercury, PM, and HCl for all existing and new fossil fuel fired electric generating units effective in April 2015 with averaging of emissions from multiple units located at a single plant. FirstEnergy's total capital cost for compliance (over the 2012 to 2018 time period) is currently expected to be approximately $345 million (CES segment of $168 million and Regulated Distribution segment of $177 million), of which $253 million has been spent through June 30, 2016 ($108 million at CES and $145 million at Regulated Distribution).

On August 3, 2015, FG, a subsidiary of FES, submitted to the AAA office in New York, N.Y., a demand for arbitration and statement of claim against BNSF and CSX seeking a declaration that MATS constituted a force majeure that excuses FG’s performance under its coal transportation contract with these parties. Specifically, the dispute arises from a contract for the transportation by BNSF and CSX of a minimum of 3.5 million tons of coal annually through 2025 to certain coal-fired power plants owned by FG that are located in Ohio. As a result of and in compliance with MATS, those plants were deactivated by April 16, 2015. In January 2012, FG notified BNSF and CSX that MATS constituted a force majeure event under the contract that excused FG’s further performance. Separately, on August 4, 2015, BNSF and CSX submitted to the AAA office in Washington, D.C., a demand for arbitration and statement of claim against FG alleging that FG breached the contract and that FG’s declaration of a force majeure under the contract is not valid and seeking damages under the contract through 2025. On May 31, 2016, the parties agreed to a stipulation that if FG’s force majeure defense is determined to be wholly or partially invalid, liquidated damages are the sole remedy available to BNSF and CSX. The arbitration panel has determined to consolidate the claims with a liability hearing expected to begin in November 2016, and, if necessary, a damages hearing is expected to begin in May 2017. The decision on liability is expected to be issued within sixty days from the end of the liability hearings. FirstEnergy and FES continue to believe that MATS constitutes a force majeure event under the contract as it relates to the deactivated plants and that FG’s performance under the contract is therefore excused. FirstEnergy and FES intend to vigorously assert their position in the arbitration proceedings. If, however, the arbitration panel rules in favor of BNSF and CSX, the results of operations and financial condition of both FirstEnergy and FES could be materially adversely impacted. FirstEnergy and FES are unable to estimate the loss or range of loss.

FG is also a party to another coal transportation contract covering the delivery of 2.5 million tons annually through 2025, a portion of which is to be delivered to another coal-fired plant owned by FG that was deactivated as a result of MATS. FG has asserted a defense of force majeure in response to delivery shortfalls to such plant under this contract as well. If FirstEnergy and FES fail to reach a resolution with the applicable counterparties to the contract, and if it were ultimately determined that, contrary to FirstEnergy’s and FES’ belief, the force majeure provisions of that contract do not excuse the delivery shortfalls to the deactivated plant, the results of operations and financial condition of both FirstEnergy and FES could be materially adversely impacted. FirstEnergy and FES are unable to estimate the loss or range of loss.

As to both coal transportation agreements referenced above, FG paid approximately $70 million in the aggregate in liquidated damages to settle delivery shortfalls in 2014 related to its deactivated plants, which approximated full liquidated damages under the agreements for such year related to the plant deactivations. Liquidated damages for the period of 2015-2025 remain in dispute.

As to a specific coal supply agreement, FirstEnergy and AE Supply have asserted termination rights effective in 2015. In response to notification of the termination, the coal supplier commenced litigation alleging FirstEnergy and AE Supply do not have sufficient justification to terminate the agreement. FirstEnergy and AE Supply have filed an answer denying any liability related to the termination. This matter is currently in the discovery phase of litigation and no trial date has been established. There are approximately 5.5 million tons remaining under the contract for delivery. At this time, FirstEnergy cannot estimate the loss or range of loss regarding the on-going litigation with respect to this agreement.

In September 2007, AE received an NOV from the EPA alleging NSR and PSD violations under the CAA, as well as Pennsylvania and West Virginia state laws at the coal-fired Hatfield's Ferry and Armstrong plants in Pennsylvania and the coal-fired Fort Martin and Willow Island plants in West Virginia. The EPA's NOV alleges equipment replacements during maintenance outages triggered the pre-construction permitting requirements under the NSR and PSD programs. On June 29, 2012, January 31, 2013, and March 27, 2013, EPA issued CAA section 114 requests for the Harrison coal-fired plant seeking information and documentation relevant to its operation and maintenance, including capital projects undertaken since 2007. On December 12, 2014, EPA issued a CAA section 114 request for the Fort Martin coal-fired plant seeking information and documentation relevant to its operation and maintenance, including capital projects undertaken since 2009. FirstEnergy intends to comply with the CAA but, at this time, is unable to predict the outcome of this matter or estimate the loss or range of loss.

#### Climate Change

FirstEnergy has established a goal to reduce CO2 emissions by 90% below 2005 levels by 2045. There are a number of initiatives to reduce GHG emissions at the state, federal and international level. Certain northeastern states are participating in the RGGI and western states led by California, have implemented programs, primarily cap and trade mechanisms, to control emissions of certain GHGs. Additional policies reducing GHG emissions, such as demand reduction programs, renewable portfolio standards and renewable subsidies have been implemented across the nation.

The EPA released its final “Endangerment and Cause or Contribute Findings for Greenhouse Gases under the Clean Air Act” in December 2009, concluding that concentrations of several key GHGs constitutes an "endangerment" and may be regulated as "air pollutants" under the CAA and mandated measurement and reporting of GHG emissions from certain sources, including electric generating plants. The EPA released its final regulations in August 2015, to reduce CO2 emissions from existing fossil fuel fired electric generating units that would require each state to develop SIPs by September 6, 2016, to meet the EPA’s state specific CO2 emission rate goals. The EPA’s CPP allows states to request a two-year extension to finalize SIPs by September 6, 2018. If states fail to develop SIPs, the EPA also proposed a federal implementation plan that can be implemented by the EPA that included model emissions trading rules which states can also adopt in their SIPs. The EPA also finalized separate regulations imposing CO2 emission limits for new, modified, and reconstructed fossil fuel fired electric generating units. On June 23, 2014, the United States Supreme Court decided that CO2 or other GHG emissions alone cannot trigger permitting requirements under the CAA, but that air emission sources that need PSD permits due to other regulated air pollutants can be required by the EPA to install GHG control technologies. Numerous states and private parties filed appeals and motions to stay the CPP with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in October 2015. On January 21, 2015, a panel of the D.C. Circuit denied the motions for stay and set an expedited schedule for briefing and argument. On February 9, 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court stayed the rule during the pendency of the challenges to the D.C. Circuit and U.S. Supreme Court. Depending on the outcome of further appeals and how any final rules are ultimately implemented, the future cost of compliance may be material.

At the international level, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change resulted in the Kyoto Protocol requiring participating countries, which does not include the U.S., to reduce GHGs commencing in 2008 and has been extended through 2020. The Obama Administration submitted in March 2015, a formal pledge for the U.S. to reduce its economy-wide greenhouse gas emissions by 26 to 28 percent below 2005 levels by 2025 and joined in adopting the agreement reached on December 12, 2015 at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change meetings in Paris. The Paris Agreement must be ratified by at least 55 countries representing at least 55% of global GHG emissions before its non-binding obligations to limit global warming to well below two degrees Celsius become effective. FirstEnergy cannot currently estimate the financial impact of climate change policies, although potential legislative or regulatory programs restricting CO2 emissions, or litigation alleging damages from GHG emissions, could require material capital and other expenditures or result in changes to its operations. The CO2 emissions per KWH of electricity generated by FirstEnergy is lower than many of its regional competitors due to its diversified generation sources, which include low or non-CO2 emitting gas-fired and nuclear generators.

#### Clean Water Act

Various water quality regulations, the majority of which are the result of the federal CWA and its amendments, apply to FirstEnergy's plants. In addition, the states in which FirstEnergy operates have water quality standards applicable to FirstEnergy's operations.

The EPA finalized CWA Section 316(b) regulations in May 2014, requiring cooling water intake structures with an intake velocity greater than 0.5 feet per second to reduce fish impingement when aquatic organisms are pinned against screens or other parts of a cooling water intake system to a 12% annual average and requiring cooling water intake structures exceeding 125 million gallons per day to conduct studies to determine site-specific controls, if any, to reduce entrainment, which occurs when aquatic life is drawn into a facility's cooling water system. FirstEnergy is studying various control options and their costs and effectiveness, including pilot testing of reverse louvers in a portion of the Bay Shore plant's cooling water intake channel to divert fish away from the plant's cooling water intake system. Depending on the results of such studies and any final action taken by the states based on those studies, the future capital costs of compliance with these standards may be substantial.

On September 30, 2015, the EPA finalized new, more stringent effluent limits for the Steam Electric Power Generating category (40 CFR Part 423) for arsenic, mercury, selenium and nitrogen for wastewater from wet scrubber systems and zero discharge of pollutants in ash transport water. The treatment obligations will phase-in as permits are renewed on a five-year cycle from 2018 to 2023. The final rule also allows plants to commit to more stringent effluent limits for wet scrubber systems based on evaporative technology and in return have until the end of 2023 to meet the more stringent limits. Depending on the outcome of appeals and how any final rules are ultimately implemented, the future costs of compliance with these standards may be substantial and changes to FirstEnergy's and FES' operations may result.

In October 2009, the WVDEP issued an NPDES water discharge permit for the Fort Martin plant, which imposes TDS, sulfate concentrations and other effluent limitations for heavy metals, as well as temperature limitations. Concurrent with the issuance of the Fort Martin NPDES permit, WVDEP also issued an administrative order setting deadlines for MP to meet certain of the effluent limits that were effective immediately under the terms of the NPDES permit. MP appealed, and a stay of certain conditions of the NPDES permit and order have been granted pending a final decision on the appeal and subject to WVDEP moving to dissolve the stay. The Fort Martin NPDES permit could require an initial capital investment ranging from $150 million to $300 million in order to install technology to meet the TDS and sulfate limits, which technology may also meet certain of the other effluent limits. Additional technology may be needed to meet certain other limits in the Fort Martin NPDES permit. MP intends to vigorously pursue these issues but cannot predict the outcome of the appeal or estimate the possible loss or range of loss.

FirstEnergy intends to vigorously defend against the CWA matters described above but, except as indicated above, cannot predict their outcomes or estimate the loss or range of loss.

#### Regulation of Waste Disposal

Federal and state hazardous waste regulations have been promulgated as a result of the RCRA, as amended, and the Toxic Substances Control Act. Certain coal combustion residuals, such as coal ash, were exempted from hazardous waste disposal requirements pending the EPA's evaluation of the need for future regulation.

In December 2014, the EPA finalized regulations for the disposal of CCRs (non-hazardous), establishing national standards regarding landfill design, structural integrity design and assessment criteria for surface impoundments, groundwater monitoring and protection procedures and other operational and reporting procedures to assure the safe disposal of CCRs from electric generating plants. Based on an assessment of the finalized regulations, the future cost of compliance and expected timing of spend had no significant impact on FirstEnergy's or FES' existing AROs associated with CCRs. Although unexpected, changes in timing and closure plan requirements in the future could impact our asset retirement obligations significantly.

Pursuant to a 2013 consent decree, PA DEP issued a 2014 permit for the Little Blue Run CCR impoundment requiring the Bruce Mansfield plant to cease disposal of CCRs by December 31, 2016 and FG to provide bonding for 45 years of closure and post-closure activities and to complete closure within a 12-year period, but authorizing FG to seek a permit modification based on "unexpected site conditions that have or will slow closure progress." The permit does not require active dewatering of the CCRs, but does require a groundwater assessment for arsenic and abatement if certain conditions in the permit are met. The Bruce Mansfield plant is pursuing several options for disposal of CCRs following December 31, 2016 and expects beneficial reuse and disposal options will be sufficient for the ongoing operation of the plant. On May 22, 2015 and September 21, 2015, the PA DEP reissued a permit for the Hatfield's Ferry CCR disposal facility and then modified that permit to allow disposal of Bruce Mansfield plant CCR. On July 6, 2015 and October 22, 2015, the Sierra Club filed Notices of Appeal with the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board challenging the renewal, reissuance and modification of the permit for the Hatfield’s Ferry CCR disposal facility.

FirstEnergy or its subsidiaries have been named as potentially responsible parties at waste disposal sites, which may require cleanup under the CERCLA. Allegations of disposal of hazardous substances at historical sites and the liability involved are often unsubstantiated and subject to dispute; however, federal law provides that all potentially responsible parties for a particular site may be liable on a joint and several basis. Environmental liabilities that are considered probable have been recognized on the Consolidated Balance Sheets as of June 30, 2016 based on estimates of the total costs of cleanup, FE's and its subsidiaries' proportionate responsibility for such costs and the financial ability of other unaffiliated entities to pay. Total liabilities of approximately $124 million have been accrued through June 30, 2016. Included in the total are accrued liabilities of approximately $89 million for environmental remediation of former manufactured gas plants and gas holder facilities in New Jersey, which are being recovered by JCP&L through a non-bypassable SBC. FirstEnergy or its subsidiaries could be found potentially responsible for additional amounts or additional sites, but the loss or range of losses cannot be determined or reasonably estimated at this time.

### OTHER LEGAL PROCEEDINGS

#### Nuclear Plant Matters

Under NRC regulations, FirstEnergy must ensure that adequate funds will be available to decommission its nuclear facilities. As of June 30, 2016, FirstEnergy had approximately $2.5 billion invested in external trusts to be used for the decommissioning and environmental remediation of Davis-Besse, Beaver Valley, Perry and TMI-2. The values of FirstEnergy's NDTs fluctuate based on market conditions. If the value of the trusts decline by a material amount, FirstEnergy's obligation to fund the trusts may increase. Disruptions in the capital markets and their effects on particular businesses and the economy could also affect the values of the NDTs. FE and FES have also entered into a total of $24.5 million in parental guarantees in support of the decommissioning of the spent fuel storage facilities located at the nuclear facilities. As required by the NRC, FirstEnergy annually recalculates and adjusts the amount of its parental guarantees, as appropriate.

In August 2010, FENOC submitted an application to the NRC for renewal of the Davis-Besse operating license for an additional twenty years. On December 8, 2015, the NRC renewed the operating license for Davis-Besse, which is now authorized to continue operation through April 22, 2037. Prior to that decision, the NRC Commissioners denied an intervenor's request to reopen the record and admit a contention on the NRC’s Continued Storage Rule. On August 6, 2015, this intervenor sought review of the NRC Commissioners' decision before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit. FENOC intervened in that proceeding.

As part of routine inspections of the concrete shield building at Davis-Besse in 2013, FENOC identified changes to the subsurface laminar cracking condition originally discovered in 2011. These inspections revealed that the cracking condition had propagated a small amount in select areas. FENOC's analysis confirms that the building continues to maintain its structural integrity, and its ability to safely perform all of its functions. In a May 28, 2015, Inspection Report regarding the apparent cause evaluation on crack propagation, the NRC issued a non-cited violation for FENOC’s failure to request and obtain a license amendment for its method of evaluating the significance of the shield building cracking. The NRC also concluded that the shield building remained capable of performing its design safety functions despite the identified laminar cracking and that this issue was of very low safety significance. FENOC plans to submit a license amendment application related to the Shield Building analysis in 2016.

On March 12, 2012, the NRC issued orders requiring safety enhancements at U.S. reactors based on recommendations from the lessons learned Task Force review of the accident at Japan's Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant. These orders require additional mitigation strategies for beyond-design-basis external events, and enhanced equipment for monitoring water levels in spent fuel pools. The NRC also requested that licensees including FENOC: re-analyze earthquake and flooding risks using the latest information available; conduct earthquake and flooding hazard walkdowns at their nuclear plants; assess the ability of current communications systems and equipment to perform under a prolonged loss of onsite and offsite electrical power; and assess plant staffing levels needed to fill emergency positions. These and other NRC requirements adopted as a result of the accident at Fukushima Daiichi are likely to result in additional material costs from plant modifications and upgrades at FirstEnergy's nuclear facilities.

#### Other Legal Matters

There are various lawsuits, claims (including claims for asbestos exposure) and proceedings related to FirstEnergy's normal business operations pending against FirstEnergy and its subsidiaries. The loss or range of loss in these matters is not expected to be material to FirstEnergy or its subsidiaries. The other potentially material items not otherwise discussed above are described under Note 11, Regulatory Matters of the Combined Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.

FirstEnergy accrues legal liabilities only when it concludes that it is probable that it has an obligation for such costs and can reasonably estimate the amount of such costs. In cases where FirstEnergy determines that it is not probable, but reasonably possible that it has a material obligation, it discloses such obligations and the possible loss or range of loss if such estimate can be made. If it were ultimately determined that FirstEnergy or its subsidiaries have legal liability or are otherwise made subject to liability based on any of the matters referenced above, it could have a material adverse effect on FirstEnergy's or its subsidiaries' financial condition, results of operations and cash flows.

### NEW ACCOUNTING PRONOUNCEMENTS

In May 2014, the FASB issued, ASU 2014-09 "Revenue from Contracts with Customers", requiring entities to recognize revenue by applying a five-step model in accordance with the core principle to depict the transfer of promised goods or services to customers in an amount that reflects the consideration to which the entity expects to be entitled in exchange for those goods or services. In addition, the accounting for costs to obtain or fulfill a contract with a customer is specified and disclosure requirements for revenue recognition are expanded. In August 2015, the FASB issued a final ASU deferring the effective date until fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2017. Earlier application is permitted only as of annual reporting periods beginning after December 15, 2016, (the original effective date). In March 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-08, “Principal versus Agent Considerations (Reporting Revenue Gross versus Net)", clarifying the principal versus agent implementation guidance in the following areas: unit of account at which the principal/agent determination is made; applying the control principle to certain types of transactions and the control principle and principal/agent indicators. In April 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-10, “Identifying Performance Obligations and Licensing”, clarifying the identification of performance obligations and the licensing implementation guidance. In May 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-11, “Rescission of SEC Guidance Because of Accounting Standards Updates 2014-09 and 2014-16 Pursuant

to Staff Announcements at the March 3, 2016 EITF Meeting”, rescinding certain SEC Staff Observer comments that are codified in Topic 605, Revenue Recognition, and Topic 932, Extractive Activities-Oil and Gas, effective upon adoption of Topic 606. In May 2016, FASB issued ASU 2016-12 "Narrow-Scope Improvements and Practical Expedients", which is intended to not change the core principle of the guidance in Topic 606, but rather affect only the narrow aspects of Topic 606 by reducing the potential for diversity in practice at initial application and by reducing the cost and complexity of applying Topic 606 both at transition and on an ongoing basis. The standards shall be applied retrospectively to each period presented or as a cumulative-effect adjustment as of the date of adoption. FirstEnergy is currently evaluating the impact on its financial statements of adopting these standards.

In February 2015, the FASB issued, ASU 2015-02 "Consolidations: Amendments to the Consolidation Analysis", which amends current consolidation guidance including changes to both the variable and voting interest models used by companies to evaluate whether an entity should be consolidated. A reporting entity must apply the amendments using a modified retrospective approach by recording a cumulative-effect adjustment to equity as of the beginning of the period of adoption or apply the amendments retrospectively. FirstEnergy's adoption of ASU 2015-02, on January 1, 2016, did not result in a change in the consolidation of VIEs by FirstEnergy or its subsidiaries. See Note 7, Variable Interest Entities, for additional information.

In April 2015, the FASB issued, ASU 2015-03 "Simplifying the Presentation of Debt Issuance Costs", which requires debt issuance costs to be presented on the balance sheet as a direct deduction from the carrying value of the associated debt liability, consistent with the presentation of a debt discount. In addition, in August 2015, the FASB issued ASU 2015-15, "Presentation and Subsequent Measurement of Debt Issuance Costs Associated with Line-of-Credit Arrangements", which allows debt issuance costs related to line of credit arrangements to be presented as an asset and amortized ratably over the term of the arrangement, regardless of whether there are any outstanding borrowings on the line-of-credit. FirstEnergy adopted ASU 2015-15 and ASU 2015-03 beginning January 1, 2016. As of December 31, 2015, FirstEnergy and FES reclassified $93 million and $17 million of debt issuance costs included in Deferred charges and other assets to Long-term debt and other long-term obligations. FirstEnergy will elect to continue presenting debt issuance costs relating to its revolving credit facilities as an asset.

In January of 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-01, "Financial Instruments-Overall: Recognition and Measurement of Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities", which primarily affects the accounting for equity investments, financial liabilities under the fair value option, and the presentation and disclosure requirements for financial instruments. In addition, the FASB clarified guidance related to the valuation allowance assessment when recognizing deferred tax assets resulting from unrealized losses on available-for-sale debt securities. The ASU will be effective in fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2017, including interim periods within those fiscal years. Early adoption for certain provisions can be elected for all financial statements of fiscal years and interim periods that have not yet been issued or that have not yet been made available for issuance. FirstEnergy is currently evaluating the impact on its financial statements of adopting this standard.

In February 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-02, "Leases (Topic 842)", which will require organizations that lease assets with lease terms of more than 12 months to recognize assets and liabilities for the rights and obligations created by those leases on their balance sheets. In addition, new qualitative and quantitative disclosures of the amounts, timing, and uncertainty of cash flows arising from leases will be required. The ASU will be effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2018, with early adoption permitted. Lessors and lessees will be required to apply a modified retrospective transition approach, which requires adjusting the accounting for any leases existing at the beginning of the earliest comparative period presented in the adoption-period financial statements. Any leases that expire before the initial application date will not require any accounting adjustment. FirstEnergy is currently evaluating the impact on its financial statements of adopting this standard.

In March of 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-09, "Improvements to Employee Share-Based Payment Accounting", which simplifies several aspects of the accounting for employee share-based payment. The new guidance will require all income tax effects of awards to be recognized in the income statement when the awards vest or are settled. It also will not require liability accounting when an employer repurchases more of an employee’s shares for tax withholding purposes. The ASU will be effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2016, with early adoption permitted. FirstEnergy is currently evaluating the impact on its financial statements of adopting this standard.

In June 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-13, “Financial Instruments - Credit Losses (Topic 326): Measurement of Credit Losses on Financial Instruments,” which removes all recognition thresholds and will require companies to recognize an allowance for credit losses for the difference between the amortized cost basis of a financial instrument and the amount of amortized cost that the company expects to collect over the instrument’s contractual life. The ASU is effective for fiscal years and for interim periods with those fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2019. Early adoption is permitted for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2018. FirstEnergy is currently evaluating the impact on its financial statements of adopting this standard.

Additionally, during 2016, the FASB issued the following ASUs:

- ASU 2016-05, “Effect of Derivative Contract Novations on Existing Hedge Accounting Relationships”,
- ASU 2016-06, “Contingent Put and Call Options in Debt Instruments (a consensus of the FASB Emerging Issues Task Force)",and
- ASU 2016-07, “Simplifying the Transition to the Equity Method of Accounting”.

FirstEnergy does not expect these ASUs to have a material effect on its financial statements.

### MANAGEMENT’S NARRATIVE

### ANALYSIS OF RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

FES is a wholly owned subsidiary of FE. FES provides energy-related products and services to retail and wholesale customers, and through its principal subsidiaries, FG and NG, owns or leases, operates and maintains FirstEnergy’s fossil and hydroelectric generation facilities (excluding AE Supply and MP), and owns, through its subsidiary, NG, FirstEnergy’s nuclear generation facilities. FENOC, a wholly owned subsidiary of FE, operates and maintains the nuclear generating facilities. FES purchases the entire output of the generation facilities owned by FG, NG and AE Supply, as well as the output relating to leasehold interests of OE and TE in Beaver Valley Unit 2 which remains subject to sale and leaseback arrangements, and pursuant to full output, cost-of-service PSAs.

FES’ revenues are derived primarily from sales to individual retail customers, sales to customers in the form of governmental aggregation programs, and participation in affiliated and non-affiliated POLR auctions. FES’ sales are primarily concentrated in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey and Maryland. The demand for electricity produced and sold by FES, along with the price of that electricity, is principally impacted by conditions in competitive power markets, global economic activity as well as economic activity and weather conditions in the Midwest and Mid-Atlantic regions of the United States.

The ESP IV, as modified and approved by the PUCO in March 2016, included an Economic Stability Program that relied upon a PPA between the Ohio Companies and FES, referred to as the ESP IV PPA, which was the subject of a complaint before FERC. FES and the Ohio Companies entered into the ESP IV PPA on April 1, 2016. On April 27, 2016, FERC issued an Order rescinding the existing affiliate waiver between the Ohio Companies and FES as it applies to the ESP IV PPA, precluding implementation of the ESP IV PPA without prior authorization from FERC. FES and the Ohio Companies did not file the ESP IV PPA for FERC review, but rather agreed to suspend the ESP IV PPA prior to transacting thereunder, pending the outcome of the PUCO and FERC proceedings. Several parties filed protests and comments to the compliance filings. The compliance filings and responses thereto are pending before FERC. As the ESP IV PPA is suspended, FES will not realize the revenues originally intended by the arrangement, which could have further material and adverse impacts to the credit ratings, results of operations and financial condition of FES. Also, in response to the Ohio Companies' filing of the modified Rider RRS proposal with the PUCO, several parties filed protests and comments with FERC, alleging, among other things, that the modified Rider RRS constitutes a "virtual PPA". The filings and responses thereto are pending before FERC.

Current market dynamics continue to challenge FES. FES will continue to review the economics of all generating units on an ongoing basis, and is expected to be cash flow positive 2016 through 2018 each year, with the ability to reinvest in its own business and cover currently anticipated capital expenditures during that time. FirstEnergy does not intend to infuse additional equity into FES in order to support their credit ratings. Furthermore, FES delayed its Beaver Valley Unit 2 steam generator replacement project from 2020 to 2023. FES will continue to invest in its nuclear units in order to maintain safe and reliable operations in accordance with nuclear industry standards. Market conditions will continue to impact capital investments in the fossil fleet, with current conditions favoring limited investments.

Competitive markets continue to challenge coal and nuclear baseload generation within FirstEnergy’s footprint. Because FES is subject to wholesale market prices and capacity auction prices, which continue to be depressed, FirstEnergy and FES' future results of operations and financial condition could be negatively and materially impacted.

Further, as FirstEnergy continues to advocate for reforms that ensure competitive wholesale markets adequately value baseload generation, which is essential to maintaining grid reliability, if FES determines that these options are not possible or are only possible for a portion of its fleet and market conditions continue to be depressed, FES may consider other options, including the sale or deactivation of generating plants. No assurance can be given, however, that any such options will be realized.

FES considers a variety of factors, including wholesale power prices, in its decision to operate, or not operate, a generating plant. If wholesale power prices represent a lower cost option, FES may fulfill its load obligation through purchasing electricity in the wholesale market as opposed to operating a generating plant. The effect of this economic decision would be to displace higher per unit fuel expense with lower per unit purchased power.

As a result of low capacity prices associated with the 2019/2020 BRA in May 2016, as well as an update to its fundamental long-term capacity and energy price forecast, FES recorded a pre-tax charge of approximately $23 million associated with an impairment of goodwill. Additionally on July 19, 2016, FirstEnergy and FES committed to exit operations of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station (720 MW) by May 31, 2020 and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station (136 MW) by October 1, 2020, resulting in non-cash pre-tax impairment charges of $517 million. While FirstEnergy and FES made the decision to sell or deactivate the unit at Bay Shore and deactivate Sammis Units 1-4, deactivation is subject to review by PJM.

Through its own facilities and purchased power agreements with affiliates described above, based upon present forward market indicators it is anticipated that FES will produce approximately 70 to 75 million MWHs of electricity annually, with up to an additional five million MWHs available from purchased power agreements for wind, solar and FES' entitlement in OVEC. In 2017 and going forward, FES expects to hedge 75% - 85% of its generation output by targeting approximately 50 to 65 million MWHs in annual retail and wholesale contract sales and maintaining up to 25 million MWHs as reserve margin. For the period July 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016, FES’ generation supply, including committed purchases, is 100% hedged against committed sales, assuming normal weather conditions. Contractual sales obligations for the periods July 1, 2016 to December 31, 2016 and 2017 are approximately 31 million MWHs and 51 million MWHs, respectively.

FES is exposed to various market and financial risks, including the risk of price fluctuations in the wholesale power markets. Wholesale power prices may be impacted by the prices of other commodities, including coal and natural gas, and energy efficiency and DR programs, as well as regulatory and legislative actions, such as MATS among other factors. FES attempts to mitigate the market risk inherent in its energy position by economically hedging its exposure and continuously monitoring various risk measurement metrics to ensure compliance with its risk management policies.

For additional information with respect to FES, please see the information contained in FirstEnergy’s Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations under the following subheadings, which information is incorporated by reference herein: FirstEnergy's Business, Executive Summary, Capital Resources and Liquidity, Guarantees and Other Assurances, Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements, Market Risk Information, Credit Risk and Outlook.

### Results of Operations

Operating results decreased $283 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily from higher capacity revenue resulting from higher capacity auction prices. Additionally, operating results were impacted by charges associated with the impairments of goodwill, Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station, and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station, settlement and termination costs associated with coal contracts, partially offset by higher net mark-to-market gains on commodity contract positions. Furthermore, lower sales volumes were offset by lower fuel, purchased power and transmission expenses.

#### Revenues -

Total revenues decreased $195 million, in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower sales volumes resulting from the continuation of FES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. Revenues were also impacted by higher capacity revenues and higher net gains on financially settled contracts, as further described below.

The change in total revenues resulted from the following sources:

*(In millions)*

| Revenues by Type of Service Contract Sales: | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $402 | $717 | $(315) |
| Governmental Aggregation | 431 | 506 | (75) |
| Mass Market | 85 | 160 | (75) |
| POLR | 282 | 445 | (163) |
| Structured Sales | 265 | 246 | 19 |
| Total Contract Sales | 1,465 | 2,074 | (609) |
| Wholesale | 712 | 244 | 468 |
| Transmission | 37 | 83 | (46) |
| Other | 87 | 95 | (8) |
| **Total Revenues** | $2,301 | $2,496 | $(195) |

102

*(In thousands)*

| MWH Sales by Channel Contract Sales: | For the Six Months Ended June 30 2016 | 2015 | Increase (Decrease) |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | 7,478 | 13,319 | (43.9)% |
| Governmental Aggregation | 6,560 | 8,052 | (18.5)% |
| Mass Market | 1,239 | 2,340 | (47.1)% |
| POLR | 4,632 | 7,742 | (40.2)% |
| Structured Sales | 6,534 | 5,673 | 15.2% |
| Wholesale | 3,959 | 161 | NM |
| **Total MWH Sales** | 30,402 | 37,287 | (18.5)% |

#### NM - Not Meaningful

The following table summarizes the price and volume factors contributing to changes in revenues in the first six months of 2016 compared with the same period of 2015:

*(In millions)*

| MWH Sales Channel: | Source of Change in Revenues Increase (Decrease) Sales Volumes | Prices | Gain on Settled Contracts | Capacity Revenue | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Direct | $(315) | $— | $— | $— | $(315) |
| Governmental Aggregation | (94) | 19 | — | — | (75) |
| Mass Market | (76) | 1 | — | — | (75) |
| POLR | (179) | 16 | — | — | (163) |
| Structured Sales | 37 | (18) | — | — | 19 |
| Wholesale | 66 | 31 | 122 | 249 | 468 |

Lower sales volumes in Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market channels primarily reflects the continuation of CES' strategy to more effectively hedge its generation. The Direct, Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market customer base was 1.5 million as of June 30, 2016, compared to 1.9 million as of June 30, 2015. Although unit pricing was higher year-over-year in the Governmental Aggregation and Mass Market channels, the increase was primarily attributable to higher capacity expense as discussed below, which is a component of the retail price.

The decrease in POLR sales of $163 million was due to lower volumes, partially offset by higher rates associated with recent POLR auctions. Structured Sales increased $19 million primarily due to higher volumes, partially offset by the impact of lower market prices.

Wholesale revenues increased $468 million, primarily due to an increase in capacity revenue from higher capacity auction prices, higher net gains on financially settled contracts and an increase in short-term (net hourly position) transactions at higher rates. Although wholesale short-term transactions increased year-over-year, low average spot market energy prices reduced the economic dispatch of fossil generating units, limiting additional wholesale sales.

Transmission revenue decreased $46 million in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower congestion revenues associated with less volatile market conditions.

Other revenues decreased $8 million, primarily due to the absence of a pre-tax gain on the sale of property to a regulated affiliate in the second quarter of 2015 and lower lease revenues from the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement.

#### Operating Expenses -

Total operating expenses increased $162 million in the first six months of 2016 compared to the same period of 2015.

The following table summarizes the factors contributing to the changes in fuel and purchased power costs in the first six months of 2016 compared with the same period of 2015:

*(In millions)*

| Operating Expense | Source of Change Increase (Decrease) Volumes | Prices | Loss on Settled Contracts | Capacity Expense | Total |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Fossil Fuel | $(78) | $(22) | $70 | $— | $(30) |
| Nuclear Fuel | 3 | (1) | — | — | 2 |
| Affiliated Purchased Power | 12 | (39) | 129 | — | 102 |
| Non-affiliated Purchased Power | (340) | (31) | 55 | 24 | (292) |

Fossil and nuclear fuel costs decreased $28 million, primarily due to lower generation associated with outages and economic dispatch of fossil units resulting from low wholesale spot market energy prices, as described above, as well as lower unit prices on fuel contracts. Additionally, fuel costs were impacted by $58 million in settlement and termination costs on coal contracts recognized in the second quarter of 2016.

Affiliated purchased power costs increased $102 million, primarily associated with net losses on settled contracts with AE Supply resulting from lower wholesale spot market prices in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015.

Non-affiliated purchased power costs decreased $292 million due to lower volumes ($340 million) and lower prices ($31 million), partially offset by higher capacity expenses ($24 million) and higher losses on financially settled purchased power contracts ($55 million). Lower volumes primarily resulted from lower contract sales as discussed above, partially offset by economic purchases resulting from the low wholesale spot market price environment. Lower unit prices and higher losses on financially settled contracts were both due to lower wholesale spot market prices in the first six months of 2016, as compared to the same period of 2015. The increase in capacity expense, which is a component of FES' retail price, was primarily the result of higher capacity rates associated with FES' retail sales obligations.

Other operating expenses decreased $141 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to the following:

- Fossil operating costs increased $10 million primarily due to increased outage costs.
- Nuclear operating costs decreased $33 million as a result of lower planned refueling outage costs. There was one planned refueling outage during the first six months of 2016 as compared to two planned refueling outages during the same period of 2015.
- Retirement benefit costs increased $15 million.
- Transmission expenses decreased $129 million, primarily due to lower congestion and market-based ancillary costs associated with less volatile market conditions as compared to the first six months of 2015, as well as lower load requirements.
- Other operating expenses decreased $4 million, primarily due to a $14 million increase in mark-to-market gains on commodity contract positions, lower lease expense as a result of the expiration of a nuclear sale-leaseback agreement and lower retail-related costs.

Depreciation expense increased $6 million as a result of a higher asset base.

General taxes decreased $9 million, primarily due to lower gross receipts taxes associated with decreased retail sales.

Impairment of assets increased $524 million due to the impairment of goodwill and a decision to exit operations of Units 1-4 of the W. H. Sammis generating station by May 31, 2020 and the Bay Shore Unit 1 generating station by October 1, 2020, resulting in an impairment of $517 million.

#### Other Expense —

Total other income (expense) decreased $19 million in the first six months of 2016, compared to the same period of 2015, primarily due to lower OTTI on NDT investments.

#### Income Tax Benefits —

FES' effective tax rate for the six months ended June 30, 2016 and 2015 was 16.6% and 20.0%, respectively. The decrease in the effective tax rate is primarily due to valuation allowances of $65 million recorded against state and local NOL carryforwards that management believes, more likely than not, will not be realized as well as the impairment of goodwill which is non-deductible for tax purposes.

## Market risk

As filed, 134 characters.

See “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations — Market Risk Information” in Item 2 above.

## Controls and procedures

As filed, 992 characters.

### (a) Evaluation of Disclosure Controls and Procedures

The management of FirstEnergy and FES, with the participation of each registrant's chief executive officer and chief financial officer, have reviewed and evaluated the effectiveness of their registrant's disclosure controls and procedures, as defined in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e), as of the end of the period covered by this report. Based on that evaluation, the chief executive officer and chief financial officer of FE and FES have concluded that their respective registrant's disclosure controls and procedures were effective as of the end of the period covered by this report.

### (b) Changes in Internal Control over Financial Reporting

During the quarter ended June 30, 2016, there were no changes in internal control over financial reporting that have materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, FE's and FES' internal control over financial reporting.

## Risk factors

As filed, 4,195 characters.

In addition to the other information set forth in this report including, without limitation, the first below revised and updated risk factor and the new additional risk factor, the reader should carefully consider the factors discussed in "Item 1A. Risk Factors" in the Registrants' Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2015, which could materially affect the Registrants' business, financial condition or future results.

*Should there be a Denial of the Modified RRS Proposal associated with the Ohio Companies' ESP IV, then there may be a Material and Adverse Impact to the Credit Ratings, Results of Operations and Financial Condition of FE*

The Ohio Companies’ modified Rider RRS proposal is currently under consideration by the PUCO in connection with the rehearings for the Ohio Companies’ ESP IV. Additionally, several parties have filed protests at FERC alleging, among other things, that the modified Rider RRS constitutes a "virtual PPA" in lieu of the ESP IV PPA. On June 29, 2016, PUCO Staff filed testimony in connection with the ESP IV rehearing recommending that the Ohio Companies’ modified Rider RRS proposal be denied, and instead recommended a new Distribution Modernization Rider providing for the collection of $131 million annually for three years with a possible extension for an additional two years. On July 25, 2016, the Ohio Companies filed rebuttal testimony that, among other things, continues to recommend that the PUCO approve the proposed modified Rider RRS, while also properly valuing the Distribution Modernization Rider by the PUCO's Staff. Any denial, invalidation or modification of the Ohio Companies’ modified RRS approach, or the PUCO’s adoption of the recommended Distribution Modernization Rider without the Ohio Companies' proposed modifications, could impose significant risks on our operations and materially and adversely impact the credit ratings, results of operations and financial condition of FE.

*Continued depressed prices in the wholesale energy and capacity markets may further negatively and materially impact the future results of operations and financial condition of FE and FES and could result in FE and FES exploring business alternatives, including the sale or deactivation of additional generating units, which may have a further material adverse effect on the results of operations and financial condition of FE and FES*

As the ESP IV PPA is suspended, FES will not realize the revenues originally intended by the arrangement, which could have further material and adverse impacts to the credit ratings, results of operations and financial condition of FES. Further, depressed prices in the wholesale energy and capacity markets continue to challenge the coal and nuclear baseload generating units within the CES business segment, including those of FES. The continued depression of these markets may further negatively and materially impact the credit ratings, future results of operations and financial condition of FE and FES.

FE does not intend to infuse additional equity into CES, including FES, in order to support their credit ratings. However, FE continues to evaluate alternative options that would de-risk the competitive generation fleet and convert MWs from competitive markets to a regulated or regulated-like construct. Market conditions will continue to impact capital investments in the fossil fleet, with current conditions involving favoring limited investments. No assurance can be given, however, that such expectations will not change or that the alternatives for CES, including FES, such as those discussed in “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Registrant and Subsidiaries – Executive Summary”, are viable or will be achieved or sufficiently realized. If options that retain the current fleet cannot be implemented, can only be implemented for a portion of the CES fleet, including FES, or market conditions continue to be depressed, we may consider other options, including the sale or deactivation of additional generating units within CES, including FES, which may have a further material adverse effect on the results of operations and financial condition of FE and FES.

Filed Jul 28, 2016.
Source: SEC EDGAR, the filing index for accession 0001031296-16-000102. Last ingested by Listed: Oct 27, 2026, 16:32 ET. No prices; not investment advice.
