OLD MARKET CAPITAL Corp: Form 10-K for the period ended Mar 31, 2019
Filed with the SEC on Jun 28, 2019 and accepted by EDGAR at Jun 28, 2019, 09:02 ET.
Business
As filed, 44,313 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
General
Nicholas Financial, Inc. (“Nicholas Financial-Canada”) is a Canadian holding company incorporated under the laws of British Columbia in 1986. The business activities of Nicholas Financial-Canada are currently conducted exclusively through its wholly-owned indirect subsidiary, Nicholas Financial, Inc., a Florida corporation (“Nicholas Financial”). Nicholas Financial is a specialized consumer finance company engaged primarily in acquiring and servicing automobile finance installment contracts (“Contracts”) for purchases of used and new automobiles and light trucks. To a lesser extent, Nicholas Financial also originates direct consumer loans (“Direct Loans”) and sells consumer-finance related products. A second Florida subsidiary, Nicholas Data Services, Inc. (“NDS”), serves as the intermediate holding company for Nicholas Financial. In addition, NF Funding I, LLC (“NF Funding I”), is a newly formed, wholly-owned, special purpose financing subsidiary of Nicholas Financial.
Nicholas Financial-Canada, Nicholas Financial, NDS, and NF Funding I are hereafter collectively referred to as the “Company”. Nicholas Financial’s operations accounted for approximately 100% of the Company’s consolidated revenue for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, as NF Funding I accounted for less than 1% of consolidated revenue for fiscal 2019. Nicholas Financial’s operations accounted for 100% of the Company’s consolidated revenue for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018.
All financial information herein is designated in United States dollars. References to “fiscal 2019” are to the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 and references to “fiscal 2018” are to the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018.
The Company’s principal executive offices are located at 2454 McMullen Booth Road, Building C, Clearwater, Florida 33759, and its telephone number is (727) 726-0763.
Available Information
The Company’s filings with the SEC, including annual reports on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, definitive proxy statements on Schedule 14A, current reports on Form 8-K, and any amendments to those reports filed pursuant to Sections 13, 14 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, are made available free of charge through the Investor Center section of the Company’s Internet website at http://www.nicholasfinancial.com as soon as reasonably practicable after the Company electronically files such material with, or furnishes it to, the SEC. The Company is not including the information contained on or available through its web site as a part of, or incorporating such information by reference into, this Report. Copies of any materials the Company files with the SEC can also be obtained free of charge through the SEC’s website at http://www.sec.gov or at the SEC’s Public Reference Room at 100 F Street, N.E., Washington, D.C. 20549. Information regarding the operation of the Public Reference Room may be obtained by calling the SEC at 1-800-SEC-0330.
Operating Strategy
The Company remains committed to its branch-based model and its core product of financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower. The Company will strategically employ the use of centralized servicing departments to supplement the branch operations and improve operational efficiencies, but its focus will be on its core business model of decentralized operations. The Company’s strategy will also include pricing based on risk (rate, yield, advance, etc.) and a commitment to the underwriting discipline required for optimal portfolio performance. The Company’s principal goals are to increase its profitability and its long-term shareholder value. During fiscal 2019, the Company focused on the following items:
- recommitted to branch model;
- restored accountability to branch managers;
- focused on return on assets;
- returned to core products;
- focused on profitability over volume;
- focused on independent dealers;
- stopped chasing the competition;
- focused more on pricing;
- focused on growing the Direct Loan portfolio.
The Company also focused on selecting the right markets to have branch locations. As of March 31, 2019, the Company operated in 15 states — Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Wisconsin (with the Wisconsin operations being conducted out the Charlotte, NC office).
During fiscal 2018, the Company consolidated branch offices located in Dayton, Ohio, Doral, Florida, and Villa Park, Illinois with other branches in those markets. During fiscal 2019, the Company exited the Maryland market by closing its branch office located in Baltimore. The Company also consolidated offices in Florida (the Sunrise branch was consolidated with the Pompano branch) and in North Carolina (the Winston-Salem branch consolidated with the Greensboro branch). In addition, the Company announced that it was exiting the Texas and Virginia markets. During the first quarter of fiscal 2020, the Company also consolidated two branches in North Carolina and two branches in Georgia. The Company will continue to evaluate underperforming markets and underperforming branches, as needed.
During fiscal 2019, the Company expanded into Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and once receivables reach an acceptable level, the Company intends to open a physical brick-and-mortar location there. The Company also continues to look for other expansion opportunities. Although the Company cannot assert how many new markets it will enter (if any) in the foreseeable future, it does remain focused on growing the branch network where conditions are favorable.
On April 30, 2019 the Company acquired substantially all of the assets of ML Credit Group, LLC (d/b/a Metrolina Credit Company) (“Metrolina”). Metrolina provides automobile financing to consumers by direct loans and through purchases of retail installment sales contracts originated by automobile dealers in the states of North Carolina and South Carolina. This acquisition represents the first bulk purchase of Contracts in over two decades. If other opportunities arise, the Company may consider possible acquisitions of portfolios of seasoned Contracts from dealers or lenders in bulk transactions as a means of further penetrating its existing markets or expanding its presence in targeted geographic locations.
The Company is currently licensed to provide Direct Loans in Florida, North Carolina, Ohio, and has also started writing deregulated direct loans over $3,000 in Georgia. The Company solicits current and former customers in these states for the purpose of selling Direct Loans to such customers. In addition, the Company is focused on the expansion of its Direct Loan capabilities to the other states in which it acquires Contracts. Even with this targeted expansion, the Company expects its total Direct Loans portfolio to remain between 3% and 10% of its total portfolio for the foreseeable future.
The Company cannot provide any assurances that it will be able to expand in either its current markets or any targeted new markets.
Automobile Finance Business – Contracts
The Company is engaged in the business of providing financing programs, primarily to purchasers of used cars and light trucks who meet the Company’s credit standards but who do not meet the credit standards of traditional lenders, such as banks and credit unions, because of the customer’s credit history, job instability, the age of the vehicle being financed, or some other factor(s). Unlike traditional lenders, which look primarily to the credit history of the borrower in making lending decisions and typically finance new automobiles, the Company is willing to purchase Contracts for purchases made by borrowers who do not have a good credit history and for older model and high-mileage automobiles. In making decisions regarding the purchase of a particular Contract, the Company considers the following factors related to the borrower: current income; credit history; history in making installment payments for automobiles; current and prior job status; and place and length of residence. In addition, the Company examines its prior experience with Contracts purchased from the dealer from which the Company is purchasing the Contract, and the value of the automobile in relation to the purchase price and the term of the Contract.
As of the date of this Annual Report on Form 10-K, the Company’s automobile finance programs are conducted in 15 states through a total of 50 branch offices located in the states of Florida, Georgia, Ohio, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Missouri, North Carolina, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee, Michigan, Kansas, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. The Company acquires Contracts in Wisconsin using the underwriting staff of the Charlotte, North Carolina branch location. As of March 31, 2019, the Company had non-exclusive agreements with approximately 4,500 dealers, of which approximately 1,400 were active, for the purchase of individual Contracts that meet the Company’s financing criteria. The Company considers a dealer agreement to be active if the Company has purchased a Contract thereunder in the last six months. Each dealer agreement requires the dealer to originate Contracts in accordance with the Company’s guidelines. Once a Contract is purchased by the Company, the dealer is no longer involved in the relationship between the Company and the borrower, other than through the existence of limited representations and warranties of the dealer in favor of the Company.
A customer under a Contract typically makes a down payment, in the form of cash and/or trade-in, ranging from 5% to 35% of the sale price of the vehicle financed. The balance of the purchase price of the vehicle plus taxes, title fees and, if applicable, premiums for extended service contracts, gap insurance, roadside assistance plans, credit disability insurance and/or credit life insurance are generally financed over a period of 12 to 60 months. At approximately the time of origination, the Company purchases a Contract from an automobile dealer at a negotiated price that is less than the original principal amount being financed by the purchaser of the automobile. The Company refers to the difference between the negotiated price and the original principal amount being financed as the dealer discount. The amount of the dealer discount depends upon factors such as the age and value of the automobile and the creditworthiness of the customer. The Company has recommitted to maintaining pricing discipline and therefore places less emphasis on competition when pricing the discount. Generally, the Company will pay more (i.e., purchase the Contract at a smaller discount from the original principal amount) for Contracts as the credit risk of the customer improves. To date, the Contracts purchased by the Company have been purchased at discounts that range from 1% to 15% of the original principal amount of each Contract. As of March 31, 2019, the Company’s loan portfolio consisted exclusively of Contracts purchased without recourse to the dealer, however each dealer remains potentially liable to the Company for breaches of certain representations and warranties made by the dealer with respect to compliance with applicable federal and state laws and valid title to the vehicle. The Company’s policy is to only purchase a Contract after the dealer has provided the Company with the requisite proof that (a) the Company has a first priority lien on the financed vehicle (or the Company has, in fact, perfected such first priority lien), (b) the customer has obtained the required collision insurance naming the Company as loss payee with a deductible of not more than $1,000 and (c) the Contract has been fully and accurately completed and validly executed. Once the Company has received and approved all required documents, it pays the dealer for the Contract and commences servicing the Contract.
Contract Procurement
The Company currently purchases Contracts in the states listed in the table below. The Contracts purchased by the Company are predominantly for used vehicles; for the periods shown below, less than 1% were for new vehicles. The average model year collateralizing the portfolio as of March 31, 2019 was a 2011 vehicle. The dollar amounts shown in the table below represent the Company’s finance receivables on Contracts purchased within the respective fiscal year:
| State | Maximum allowable interest rate (1) | Number of Branches | Fiscal year ended March 31, (In thousands) 2019 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | (2) | 2 | $1,590 | $3,108 |
| Florida | 18-30%(3) | 17 | 21,524 | 29,206 |
| Georgia | 18-30%(3) | 6 | 8,988 | 11,192 |
| Illinois | (2) | 1 | 700 | 2,667 |
| Indiana | 25% | 3 | 3,995 | 7,001 |
| Kansas | (2) | 1 | 1,087 | 1,788 |
| Kentucky | 18-25%(3) | 3 | 3,792 | 5,558 |
| Maryland | 24% | — | — | 1,040 |
| Michigan | 25% | 2 | 3,389 | 4,709 |
| Missouri | (2) | 3 | 3,207 | 4,663 |
| North Carolina | 18-29%(3) | 4 | 7,283 | 8,836 |
| Ohio | 25% | 6 | 11,768 | 14,599 |
| Pennsylvania | 18-21%(3) | 1 | 1,772 | 2,200 |
| South Carolina | (2) | 2 | 2,366 | 4,055 |
| Tennessee | (2) | 2 | 2,463 | 3,374 |
| Texas | 18-28%(3) | — | 1,787 | 2,835 |
| Virginia | (2) | — | 1,655 | 2,639 |
| Wisconsin | (2) | — | 133 | 105 |
| Total | 53 | $77,499 | $109,575 |
(1) The maximum allowable interest rates are subject to change and vary based on the laws of the individual states.
(2) None of these states currently imposes a maximum allowable interest rate with respect to the types and sizes of Contracts the Company purchases. The maximum rate which the Company will typically charge any customer in each of these states is 30% per annum.
(3) The maximum allowable interest rate in each of these states varies depending upon the model year of the vehicle being financed. In addition, Georgia does not currently impose a maximum allowable interest rate with respect to Contracts over $5,000.
The following table presents selected information on Contracts purchased by the Company:
| Contracts | Fiscal year ended March 31, (Purchases in thousands) 2019 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|
| Purchases | $77,499 | $109,575 |
| Average APR | 23.52% | 22.35% |
| Average dealer discount | 8.22% | 7.41% |
| Average term (months) | 47 | 54 |
| Average loan | $10,086 | $11,219 |
| Number of Contracts purchased | 7,684 | 9,767 |
4
Direct Loans
The Company currently originates Direct Loans in Florida, North Carolina, Georgia, and Ohio. Direct Loans are loans originated directly between the Company and the consumer. These loans are typically for amounts ranging from $1,000 to $15,000 and are generally secured by a lien on an automobile, watercraft or other permissible tangible personal property. The average loan made during fiscal 2019 by the Company had an initial principal balance of approximately $4,000. The Company does not expect the average loan size to increase significantly within the foreseeable future. Most of the Direct Loans are originated with current or former customers under the Company’s automobile financing program. The typical Direct Loan represents a better credit risk than our typical Contract due to the customer’s historical payment history with the Company. The Company does not have a Direct Loan license in Alabama, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia or Wisconsin, and none is presently required in Georgia provided that the original principal balance of the loan is greater than $3,000. The Company obtained a Direct Loan license in Ohio during the fiscal year ended 2019 and expects to pursue licenses in one or more states in the foreseeable future. The size of the loan and maximum interest rate that may be (and is) charged varies from state to state. The Company considers the individual’s income, credit history, job stability, and the value of the collateral offered by the borrower to secure the loan as the primary factors in determining whether an applicant will receive an approval for such loan. Additionally, because most of the Direct Loans made by the Company to date have been made to borrowers under Contracts previously purchased by the Company, the payment history of the borrower under the Contract is a significant factor in making the loan decision. The Company’s Direct Loan program was implemented in April 1995 and accounted for approximately 3% of the Company’s annual consolidated revenues during the year ended March 31, 2019.
In connection with its Direct Loan program, the Company also makes available credit disability insurance, credit life insurance, and involuntary unemployment insurance coverage to customers through unaffiliated third-party insurance carriers. Approximately 65% of the Direct Loans outstanding as of March 31, 2019 elected to purchase third-party insurance coverage made available by the Company. The cost of this insurance to the customer, which includes a commission for the Company, is included in the amount financed by the customer.
The following table presents selected information on Direct Loans originated by the Company:
| Direct Loans | Fiscal year ended March 31, (Originations in thousands) 2019 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|
| Originations | $7,741 | $7,642 |
| Average APR | 26.37% | 25.20% |
| Average term (months) | 25 | 29 |
| Average loan | $4,036 | $3,754 |
| Number of contracts originated | 1,918 | 2,036 |
Underwriting Guidelines
The Company’s typical customer has a credit history that fails to meet the lending standards of most traditional banks and credit unions. Among the credit problems experienced by the Company’s customers that resulted in a poor credit history are: prior automobile account repossessions, unpaid revolving credit card obligations, unpaid medical bill, unpaid student loans, prior bankruptcy, and evictions for nonpayment of rent. The Company believes that its customer profile is similar to that of its direct competitors.
Prior to its approval of the purchase of a Contract, the Company is provided with a standardized credit application completed by the consumer which contains information relating to the consumer’s background, employment, and credit history. The Company also obtains credit reports from Equifax and/or TransUnion, which are independent credit reporting services. The Company verifies the consumer’s employment history, income, and residence. In most cases, consumers are interviewed via telephone by a Company application processor (usually the Branch Manager or Assistant Branch Manager). The Company also considers the customer’s prior payment history with the Company, if any, as well as the collateral value of the vehicle being financed.
The Company has established internal underwriting guidelines to be used by its Branch Managers and internal underwriters when purchasing Contracts. Any Contract that does not meet these guidelines must be approved by the District Managers or senior management of the Company. The Company currently has District Managers charged with managing the specific branches in a defined geographic area. In addition to a variety of administrative duties, the District Managers are responsible for monitoring their assigned branches’ compliance with the Company’s underwriting guidelines as well as approving underwriting exceptions.
The Company uses essentially the same criteria in analyzing a Direct Loan as it does in analyzing the purchase of a Contract. Lending decisions regarding Direct Loans are made based upon a review of the customer’s loan application, income, credit history, job stability, and the value of the collateral offered by the borrower to secure the loan. To date, since the majority of the Company’s Direct Loans have been made to individuals whose automobiles have been financed by the Company, the customer’s payment history under his or her existing or past Contract is a significant factor in the lending decision.
After reviewing the information included in the Contract or Direct Loan application and taking the other factors into account, the Company’s loan origination system categorizes the customer using internally developed credit classifications of “1,” indicating higher creditworthiness, through “4,” indicating lower creditworthiness. Contracts are financed for individuals who fall within all four acceptable rating categories utilized, “1” through “4”. Usually a customer who falls within the two highest categories (i.e., “1” or “2”) is purchasing a two to five-year old, lower mileage used automobile, while a customer in any of the two lowest categories (i.e., “3,” or “4”) usually is purchasing an older, higher mileage automobile from an independent used automobile dealer.
The Company utilizes internal audit (“IA”) to perform audits of its branches’ compliance with Company underwriting guidelines. IA audits Company branches on a schedule that is variable depending on the size of the branch, length of time a branch has been open, current tenure of the Branch Manager, previous branch audit score, and current and historical branch profitability.
Monitoring and Enforcement of Contracts
The Company requires each customer under a Contract to obtain and maintain collision insurance covering damage to the vehicle. Failure to maintain such insurance constitutes a default under the Contract, and the Company may, at its discretion, repossess the vehicle. To reduce potential loss due to insurance lapse, the Company has the contractual right to obtain collateral protection insurance through a third-party, which covers loss due to physical damage to a vehicle not covered by any insurance policy of the customer.
The Company’s Management Information Services personnel maintain a number of reports to monitor compliance by customers with their obligations under Contracts and Direct Loans made by the Company. These reports may be accessed on a real-time basis or at the end of the day throughout the Company by management personnel, including Branch Managers and staff, at computer terminals located in the main office and each branch office. These reports include delinquency reports, customer promise reports, vehicle information reports, purchase reports, dealer analysis reports, static pool reports, and repossession reports.
A delinquency report is an aging report that provides basic information regarding each customer account and indicates accounts that are past due. The report includes information such as the account number, address of the customer, phone numbers of the customer, original term of the Contract, number of remaining payments, outstanding balance, due dates, date of last payment, number of days past due, scheduled payment amount, amount of last payment, total past due, and special payment arrangements or agreements.
When an account becomes delinquent, the Company immediately contacts the customer to determine the reason for the delinquency and to determine if appropriate arrangements for payment can be made. If payment arrangements acceptable to the Company can be made, the information is entered in its database and is used to generate a customer promises report, which is utilized by the Company’s collection staff for account follow up.
The Company prepares a repossession report that provides information regarding repossessed vehicles and aids the Company in disposing of repossessed vehicles. In addition to information regarding the customer, this report provides information regarding the date of repossession, date the vehicle was sold, number of days it was held in inventory prior to sale, year, make and model of the vehicle, mileage, payoff amount on the Contract, NADA book value, Black Book value, suggested sale price, location of the vehicle, original dealer and condition of the vehicle, as well as notes other information that may be helpful to the Company.
If an account is 121 days delinquent and the related vehicle has not yet been repossessed, the account is charged-off and transferred to the Loss Prevention and Recovery Department. Once a vehicle has been repossessed, the related loan balance no longer appears on the delinquency report. Instead, the vehicle appears on the Company’s repossession report and is generally sold at auction. During the fourth quarter of fiscal 2019, the Company changed its charge-off policy from 181 days past due to 121 days past due. Please see Note 3 to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in this Annual Report for further discussion.
The Company also prepares a dealer analysis report that provides information regarding each dealer from which it purchases Contracts. This report allows the Company to analyze the volume of business done with each dealer, the terms on which it has purchased Contracts from such dealer, as well as the overall portfolio performance of Contracts purchased from the dealer.
The Company is subject to seasonal variations within the subprime marketplace. While the APR, discount, and term remain consistent across quarters, write offs and delinquencies tend to be lower while purchases tend to be higher in the fourth and first quarter of the fiscal year. The second and third quarter of the fiscal year tend to have higher write offs and delinquencies, and a lower level of purchases.
Marketing and Advertising
The Company’s Contract marketing efforts currently are directed primarily toward automobile dealers. The Company attempts to meet dealers’ needs by offering highly responsive, cost-competitive, and service-oriented financing programs. The Company relies on its District and Branch Managers to solicit agreements for the purchase of Contracts with automobile dealers located within a 60-mile radius of each branch office. The Branch Manager provides dealers with information regarding the Company and the general terms upon which the Company is willing to purchase Contracts. The Company is evaluating and assessing other forms of advertising, such as radio or newspaper advertisements, for the purchase of Contracts.
The Company solicits customers under its Direct Loan program primarily through direct mailings, followed by telephone calls to individuals who have a good credit history with the Company in connection with Contracts purchased by the Company.
Computerized Information System
Until February 1, 2019, the Company used an internally developed loan servicing system to assist in responding to customer inquiries and to monitor the performance of its Contract and Direct Loan portfolio and the performance of individual customers under Contracts. On February 1, 2019, the Company converted to a third-party loan servicing system to assist in responding to customer inquiries and to monitor the performance of its Contract and Direct Loan portfolio and the performance of individual customers under Contracts.
All Company personnel are provided with real-time access to information. The Company has created specialized programs to automate the tracking of Contracts and Direct Loans from inception. The Company’s computer network encompasses both its corporate headquarters and its branch office locations. See “Monitoring and Enforcement of Contracts” above for a summary of the different reports prepared by the Company.
Competition
The consumer finance industry is highly fragmented and highly competitive. Due to various factors, including the existing low interest rate environment, the competitiveness of the industry continues to increase as new competitors continue to enter the market and certain existing competitors continue to expand their operations. There are numerous financial service companies that provide consumer credit in the markets served by the Company, including banks, credit unions, other consumer finance companies, and captive finance companies owned by automobile manufacturers and retailers. Increased competition for the purchase of Contracts enabled automobile dealers to shop for the best price, resulting in an erosion in the dealer discounts from the initial principal amounts at which the Company was willing to purchase Contracts and higher advance rates. Further, increased competition resulted in the purchase of lower credit quality Contracts. However, with the Company’s change in management during the end of fiscal 2018 and beginning of fiscal 2019, it has placed less emphasis on competition when pricing the dealer discount. The Company instead focuses on purchasing Contracts that are priced to reflect the inherent risk level of the contract, and intends to sacrifice loan volume, if necessary, to maintain that pricing discipline. Primarily as a result of this shift in focus for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, the Company’s average dealer discount on Contracts purchased increased to 8.2%, compared to 7.4% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. The following table shows number and principal amount of Contracts purchased, average amount financed, average term, and average APR and discount for the periods presented:
| Fiscal Year /Quarter | Number of Contracts Purchased | Principal Amount Purchased | Average Financed | Average APR | Average Discount Percentage | Average Term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | 7,684 | $77,498,829 | $10,086 | 23.5% | 8.2% | 47 |
| 4 | 2,151 | 21,233,193 | 9,871 | 23.5% | 8.0% | 46 |
| 3 | 1,625 | 16,475,956 | 10,139 | 23.5% | 8.1% | 47 |
| 2 | 1,761 | 17,844,587 | 10,133 | 23.5% | 8.4% | 47 |
| 1 | 2,147 | 21,945,093 | 10,221 | 23.7% | 8.3% | 48 |
| 2018 | 9,767 | 109,575,099 | 11,219 | 22.4% | 7.4% | 54 |
| 4 | 2,814 | 29,253,725 | 10,396 | 23.3% | 7.9% | 50 |
| 3 | 2,365 | 27,378,449 | 11,577 | 21.7% | 6.9% | 54 |
| 2 | 2,239 | 25,782,056 | 11,515 | 22.0% | 7.3% | 55 |
| 1 | 2,349 | 27,160,869 | 11,563 | 33.0% | 6.9% | 54 |
The Company’s target market consists of persons who are generally unable to obtain traditional used car financing because of their credit history or the vehicle’s mileage or age. Historically, the Company was able to expand its automobile finance business in the non-prime credit market by offering to purchase Contracts on terms that are competitive with those of other companies. Throughout most of fiscal 2018, the Company attempted to expand its product mix to include larger loans with lower APRs and reduced discounts. Beginning in January 2018, the Company rededicated itself to its core product of financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower and refocused on pricing integrity on those Contracts acquired. The Company is committed to the branch-based model and believes that model allows it maintain pricing integrity through solid dealer relationships and a knowledge of the local market.
The Company’s ability to compete effectively with other companies offering similar financing arrangements depends in part upon the Company maintaining close business relationships with dealers of used and new vehicles. No single dealer out of the approximately 4,500 dealers with which the Company currently has active contractual relationships represents a significant amount of the Company’s business volume for any of the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 or 2018.
Regulation
The Company’s financing operations are subject to regulation, supervision and licensing under many federal, state and local statutes, regulations and ordinances. Additionally, the procedures that the Company must follow regarding the repossession of vehicles securing Contracts are regulated by each of the states in which the Company does business. To date, the Company’s operations have been conducted exclusively in the states of Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia and Wisconsin (as of March 31, 2019, the Company has exited Maryland, Texas and Virginia). Accordingly, the laws of such states, as well as applicable federal law, govern the Company’s operations. The following constitute certain of the existing federal, state and local statutes, regulations and ordinances with which the Company must comply:
- State consumer regulatory agency requirements. Pursuant to state regulations, on-site audits can be conducted for each of the Company’s branches located within Alabama, Florida, Indiana, Kansas, Michigan, and Missouri to monitor compliance with applicable regulations. These regulations include but, are not limited to: licensure requirements; requirements for maintenance of proper records; payment of required fees; maximum interest rates that may be charged on loans to finance used vehicles; and, proper disclosure to customers regarding financing terms. Pursuant to Florida and North Carolina law, the Company’s Direct Loan activities in each state are subject to similar periodic on-site audits by the Florida Financial Services Commission and the North Carolina Office of the Commissioner of Banks, respectively. If the Company expands its Direct Loan operations to other states, it expects to become subject to similar on-site audits in such states.
- State licensing requirements. The Company files a notification or obtains a license to acquire Contracts within the following states: Alabama, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Michigan, Missouri, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, and Wisconsin. In regard to its Direct Loan activities in Florida and North Carolina, the Company maintains separate Consumer Finance Licenses with the Florida Department of Banking and Finance and the North Carolina Office of the Commissioner of Banks, respectively. Furthermore, some states require dealers to maintain a Retail Installment Seller’s License, and where applicable, the Company only conducts business with dealers who hold such a license.
- Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“FDCPA”) and applicable state law counterparts prohibit the Company from contacting customers during certain times and at certain places, from using certain threatening practices and from making false implications when attempting to collect a debt.
- Truth in Lending Act. The Truth in Lending Act (“TILA”) requires the Company and the dealers it does business with to make certain disclosures to customers, including the terms of repayment, the total finance charge and the annual percentage rate charged on each Contract or Direct Loan.
- Equal Credit Opportunity Act. The Equal Credit Opportunity Act (“ECOA”) prohibits creditors from discriminating against loan applicants on the basis of race, color, sex, age or marital status. Pursuant to Regulation B promulgated under the ECOA, creditors are required to make certain disclosures regarding consumer rights and advise consumers whose credit applications are not approved of the reasons for the rejection.
- Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act. The Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (“ESIGN”) requires the Company to provide consumers with clear and conspicuous disclosures before the consumer gives consent to authorize the use of electronic signatures, electronic contracts, and electronic records.
- Fair Credit Reporting Act. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”) requires the Company to provide certain information to consumers whose credit applications are not approved on the basis of a report obtained from a consumer reporting agency, as well as, ensure the accuracy and integrity of consumer information reported to credit reporting agencies.
- Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act. The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (“GLBA”) requires the Company to maintain privacy with respect to certain consumer data in its possession and to periodically communicate with consumers on privacy matters.
- Servicemembers Civil Relief Act. The Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (“SCRA”) requires the Company to reduce the interest rate charged on each loan to customers who have subsequently joined, enlisted, been inducted or called to active military duty and places limitations on collection and repossession activity.
- Military Lending Act. The Military Lending Act (“MLA”) requires the Company to limit the military annual percentage rate (“MAPR”) that the Company may charge to a maximum of 36 percent, requires certain disclosures to military consumers, and provides other substantive consumer protections on credit extended to Servicemembers and their families.
- Electronic Funds Transfer Act. The Electronic Funds Transfer Act (“EFTA”) prohibits the Company from requiring its customers to repay a loan or other credit by electronic funds transfer (“EFT”), except in limited situations which do not apply to the Company. The Company is also required to provide certain documentation to its customers when an EFT is initiated and to provide certain notifications to its customers with regard to preauthorized payments.
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”) governs the Company’s practice of contacting customers by certain means i.e. auto dealers, pre-recorded or artificial voice calls on customers’ land lines, fax machines and cell phones, including text messages.
- Bankruptcy. Federal bankruptcy and related state laws may interfere with or affect the Company’s ability to recover collateral or enforce a deficiency judgment.
- Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 (“Dodd-Frank Act”). Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”), which, effective as of July 21, 2011, has the authority to issue and enforce regulations under the federal “enumerated consumer laws,” including (subject to certain statutory limitations) FDCPA, TILA, ECOA, FCRA, GLBA and EFTA. The CFPB has rulemaking and enforcement authority over certain non-depository institutions, including us. The CFPB is specifically authorized, among other things, to take actions to prevent companies providing consumer financial products or services and their service providers from engaging in unfair, deceptive or abusive acts or practices in connection with consumer financial products and services, and to issue rules requiring enhanced disclosures for consumer financial products or services. Under the Dodd-Frank Act, the CFPB also may restrict the use of pre-dispute mandatory arbitration clauses in contracts between covered persons and consumers for a consumer financial product or service. The CFPB also has authority to interpret, enforce, and issue regulations implementing enumerated consumer laws, including certain laws that apply to the Company’s business. The CFPB issued rules regarding the supervision and examination of non-depository “larger participants” in the automobile finance business. At this time, the Company is not deemed a larger participant.
Failure to comply with these laws or regulations could have a material adverse effect on the Company by, among other things, limiting the jurisdictions in which the Company may operate, restricting the Company’s ability to realize the value of the collateral securing the Contracts, and making it more costly or burdensome to do business or resulting in potential liability. The volume of new or modified laws and regulations and the activity of agencies enforcing such law have increased in recent years in response to issues arising with respect to consumer lending. From time to time, legislation and regulations are enacted which increase the cost of doing business, limit or expand permissible activities or affect the competitive balance among financial services providers. Proposals to change the laws and regulations governing the operations and taxation of financial institutions and financial services providers are frequently made in the U.S. Congress, in the state legislatures and by various regulatory agencies. This legislation may change the Company’s operating environment in substantial and unpredictable ways and may have a material adverse effect on the Company’s business.
In particular, the Dodd-Frank Act and regulations promulgated thereunder, including the rules regarding supervision and examination issued by the CFPB, are likely to affect the Company’s cost of doing business, may limit or expand the Company’s permissible activities, may affect the competitive balance within the Company’s industry and market areas and could have a material adverse effect on the Company. The Company’s management continues to assess the Dodd-Frank Act’s probable impact on the Company’s business, financial condition and results of operations, and to monitor developments involving the entities charged with promulgating regulations thereunder. However, the ultimate effect of the Dodd-Frank Act on the financial services industry in general, and on the Company in particular, is uncertain at this time.
In addition to the CFPB, other state and federal agencies have the ability to regulate aspects of the Company’s business. For example, the Dodd-Frank Act provides a mechanism for state Attorneys General to investigate the Company. In addition, the Federal Trade Commission has jurisdiction to investigate aspects of the Company’s business. The Company expects that regulatory investigation by both state and federal agencies will continue and that the results of these investigations could have a material adverse impact on the Company.
Dealers with which the Company does business must also comply with credit and trade practice statutes and regulations. Failure of these dealers to comply with such statutes and regulations could result in customers having rights of rescission and other remedies that could have a material adverse effect on the Company.
The sale of vehicle service contracts and other ancillary products by dealers in connection with Contracts assigned to the Company from dealers is also subject to state laws and regulations. As the Company is the holder of the Contracts that may, in part, finance these products, some of these state laws and regulations may apply to the Company’s servicing and collection of the Contracts. Although these laws and regulations may not significantly affect the Company’s business, there can be no assurance that insurance or other regulatory authorities in the jurisdictions in which these products are offered by dealers will not seek to regulate or restrict the operation of the Company’s business in these jurisdictions. Any regulation or restriction of the Company’s business in these jurisdictions could materially adversely affect the income received from these products.
The Company’s management believes that the Company maintains all requisite licenses and permits and is in material compliance with applicable local, state and federal laws and regulations. The Company periodically reviews its branch office practices in an effort to ensure such compliance. Although compliance with existing laws and regulations has not had a material adverse effect on the Company’s operations to date, given the increasingly complex regulatory environment, the increasing costs of complying with such laws and regulations, and the increasing risk of penalties, fines or other liabilities associated therewith, no assurances can be given that the Company is in material compliance with all of such laws or regulations or that the costs of such compliance, or the failure to be in such compliance, will not have a material adverse effect on the Company’s business, financial condition or results of operations.
Employees
The Company’s management and various support functions are centralized at the Company’s corporate headquarters in Clearwater, Florida. As of March 31, 2019, the Company employed a total of 279 persons, of which 52 persons were employed at the Company’s corporate headquarters. None of the Company’s employees are subject to a collective bargaining agreement, and the Company considers its relations with its employees generally to be good.
Risk factors
As filed, 41,645 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
The following factors, as well as other factors not set forth below, may adversely affect the business, operations, financial condition or results of operations of the Company (sometimes referred to in this section as “we” “us” or “our”).
We have in the past experienced and may in the future experience high delinquency and loss rates in our portfolios. This has reduced and may continue to reduce our profitability. In addition, our inability to accurately forecast and estimate the amount and timing of future collections could have a material adverse effect on our financial position, liquidity and results of operations.
Our consolidated net loss for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018, was $3.6 million and $1.1 million, respectively. Our profitability depends, to a material extent, on the performance of contracts that we purchase. Historically, we have experienced higher delinquency rates than traditional financial institutions because substantially all of our Contracts and Direct Loans are to non-prime borrowers, who are unable to obtain financing from traditional sources due primarily to their credit history. Contracts and Direct Loans made to these individuals generally entail a higher risk of delinquency, default, repossession, and higher losses than loans made to consumers with better credit.
Our underwriting standards and collection procedures may not offer adequate protection against the risk of default, especially in periods of economic uncertainty and wage stagnation such as have existed over much of the past few years. In the event of a default, the collateral value of the financed vehicle usually does not cover the outstanding Contract or Direct Loan balance and costs of recovery.
Our ability to accurately forecast performance and determine an appropriate provision and allowance for credit losses, is critical to our business and financial results. The allowance for credit losses is established through a provision for credit losses based on management’s evaluation of the risk inherent in the portfolio, the composition of the portfolio, specific impaired Contracts and Direct Loans, and current economic conditions. Please see “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations – Critical Accounting Policy” in Item 7 of this Form 10-K and “Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting” in Item 9A of this Form 10-K, both of which are incorporated herein by reference.
There can be no assurance that our performance forecasts will be accurate. In periods with changing economic conditions, such as is the case currently, accurately forecasting the performance of Contract and Direct Loans is more difficult. Our allowance for losses is an estimate, and if actual Contract and Direct Loan losses are materially greater than our allowance for losses, or more generally, if our forecasts are not accurate, our financial position, liquidity and results of operations could be materially adversely affected.
Other than limited representations and warranties made by dealers in favor of the Company, Contracts are purchased from the dealers without recourse, and we are therefore only able to look to the borrowers for repayment.
In June 2016, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (“FASB”) issued the ASU 2016-13 Financial Instruments—Credit Losses (Topic 326): Measurement of Credit Losses on Financial Instruments. Among other things, the amendments in this ASU require the measurement of all expected credit losses for financial instruments held at the reporting date based on historical experience, current conditions and reasonable and supportable forecasts. Financial institutions and other organizations will now use forward-looking information to better inform their credit loss estimates. Many of the loss estimation techniques applied today will still be permitted, although the inputs to those techniques will change to reflect the full amount of expected credit losses. The ASU also requires additional disclosures related to estimates and judgments used to measure all expected credit losses. The new guidance is effective for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2019. Early application will be permitted for all organizations for fiscal years, and interim periods within those fiscal years, beginning after December 15, 2018. The Company is currently evaluating the impact of the adoption of this ASU on the consolidated financial statements and is collecting and analyzing data that will be needed to produce historical inputs into any models created as a result of adopting this ASU. At this time, we believe the adoption of this ASU will have likely have a material adverse effect on our consolidated financial statements.
We operate in an increasingly competitive market.
The non-prime consumer-finance industry is highly competitive, and the competitiveness of the market continues to increase as new competitors continue to enter the market and certain existing competitors continue to expand their operations and become more aggressive in offering competitive terms. There are numerous financial service companies that provide consumer credit in the markets served by us, including banks, credit unions, other consumer finance companies and captive finance companies owned by automobile manufacturers and retailers. Many of these competitors have substantially greater financial resources than us. In addition, our competitors often provide financing on terms more favorable to automobile purchasers or dealers than we offer. Many of these competitors also have long-standing relationships with automobile dealerships and may offer dealerships, or their customers, other forms of financing including dealer floor-plan financing and leasing, which are not provided by us. Providers of non-prime consumer financing have traditionally competed primarily on the basis of:
- interest rates charged;
- the quality of credit accepted;
- dealer discount;
- amount paid to dealers relative to the wholesale book value;
- the flexibility of Contract and Direct Loan terms offered; and
- the quality of service provided.
Our ability to compete effectively with other companies offering similar financing arrangements depends in part on our ability to maintain close relationships with dealers of used and new vehicles. We may not be able to compete successfully in this market or against these competitors. In recent years, it has become increasingly difficult for the Company to match or exceed pricing of its competitors, which has generally resulted in declining Contract acquisition rates during the 2018 and 2019 fiscal years.
We have focused on a segment of the market composed of consumers who typically do not meet the more stringent credit requirements of traditional consumer financing sources and whose needs, as a result, have not been addressed consistently by such financing sources. As new and existing providers of consumer financing have undertaken to penetrate our targeted market segment, we have experienced increasing pressure to reduce our interest rates, fees and dealer discounts in order to maintain our market share. The Company’s average dealer discount on Contracts purchased for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018 was 8.2% and 7.4%, respectively. The Company’s average APR on Contracts purchased for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018, was 23.5% and 22.4%, respectively. These competitive factors continue to exist and may impact our ability to secure quality loans on our preferred terms in significant quantities.
In addition, the number of Contracts and Direct Loans under which customers decided to discontinue contractually required payments to us after they were approved by other lenders for new vehicle financing has recently increased. We are particularly vulnerable to the effects of these practices because of our focus on providing financing with respect to used vehicles.
Our business depends on our continued access to bank financing on acceptable terms.
Prior to March 2019, we financed our operations through traditional bank credit facilities and cash flows generated from operations. On March 29, 2019, we entered into a new senior secured credit facility (the “Credit Facility”). Our ability to access capital through our existing facility, or undertake a future facility, or other debt or equity transactions on economically favorable terms or at all, depends in large part on factors that are beyond our control, including:
- Conditions in the securities and finance markets generally, and for securitized instruments in particular;
- A negative bias toward our industry;
- General economic conditions and the economic health of our earnings, cash flows and balance sheet;
- Security or collateral requirements;
- The credit quality and performance of our customer receivables;
- Regulatory restrictions applicable to us;
- Our overall business and industry prospects;
- Our overall sales performance, profitability, cash flow, balance sheet quality, and regulatory restrictions;
- Our ability to provide or obtain financial support for required credit enhancement;
- Our ability to adequately service our financial instruments;
- Our ability to meet debt covenant requirements; and
- Prevailing interest rates.
Our existing and future levels of indebtedness could adversely affect our financial health, ability to obtain financing in the future, ability to react to changes in our business and ability to fulfill our obligations under such indebtedness.
As of March 31, 2019, we had aggregate outstanding indebtedness, under our Credit Facility, of $145.0 million. This level of indebtedness could:
- Make it more difficult for us to satisfy our obligations with respect to our outstanding notes and other indebtedness, resulting in possible defaults on and acceleration of such indebtedness;
- Require us to dedicate a substantial portion of our cash flow from operations to the payment of principal and interest on our indebtedness, thereby reducing the availability of such cash flows to fund working capital, acquisitions, new store openings, capital expenditures and other general corporate purposes;
- Limit our ability to obtain additional financing for working capital, acquisitions, new store openings, capital expenditures, debt service requirements and other general corporate purposes;
- Limit our ability to refinance indebtedness or cause the associated costs of such refinancing to increase;
- Increase our vulnerability to general adverse economic and industry conditions, including interest rate fluctuations (because a portion of our borrowings are at variable rates of interest); and
- Place us at a competitive disadvantage compared to our competitors with proportionately less debt or comparable debt at more favorable interest rates which, as a result, may be better positioned to withstand economic downturns.
Any of the foregoing impacts of our level of indebtedness could have a material adverse effect on us.
Our Credit Facility is subject to certain defaults and negative covenants.
The Credit Facility loan documents contain customary events of default and negative covenants, including but not limited to those governing indebtedness, liens, fundamental changes, investments, and sales of receivables. Such loan documents also restrict the Company’s ability, without lenders’ consent, to modify its credit policies or make changes to its form of Direct Loan contract or its form of dealer agreement. If an event of default occurs, the lenders could increase borrowing costs, restrict the our ability to obtain additional advances under the Credit Facility, accelerate all amounts outstanding under the Credit Facility, enforce their interest against collateral pledged under the Credit Facility or enforce their rights under the guarantees.
If we fail to maintain an effective system of internal control over financial reporting and disclosure controls and procedures, we may not be able to accurately and timely report our financial results, which could lead to a loss of investor confidence in our financial statements and have an adverse effect on our stock price.
Effective internal control over financial reporting and disclosure controls and procedures are necessary for us to provide reliable and accurate financial statements and to effectively prevent fraud and to operate successfully as a public company. As further described in Item 9A. Controls and Procedures, our management has concluded that, because of a material weakness, our internal control over financial reporting and our disclosure controls and procedures were not effective as of March 31, 2018 or as of March 31, 2019. The Company has and will continue to enhance its controls and expects to remediate the material weakness. However, we cannot be certain that these measures will be successful or that we will be able to prevent future significant deficiencies or material weaknesses. Inadequate internal control over financial reporting or inadequate disclosure controls and procedures could cause investors to lose confidence in our reported financial information, which could hurt our reputation and have a negative effect on the trading price of our stock and our access to capital.
The Dodd-Frank Act authorizes the CFPB to adopt rules that could potentially have a material adverse effect on our operations and financial performance.
Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act established the CFPB, which became operational on July 21, 2011. Under the Dodd-Frank Act, the CFPB has regulatory, supervisory and enforcement powers over providers of consumer financial products, such as the Contracts and Direct Loans that we offer, including explicit supervisory authority to examine and require registration of installment lenders such as ourselves. Included among the powers afforded to the CFPB is the authority to adopt rules describing specified acts and practices as being “unfair,” “deceptive” or “abusive,” and hence unlawful. The CFPB has outlined several proposals under consideration for the purpose of requiring lenders to take steps to ensure consumers have the financial ability to repay their loans. The proposals under consideration would require lenders to determine at the outset of each loan whether a consumer can afford to borrow from the lender and would require that lenders comply with various restrictions designed to ensure that consumers can affordably repay their debt to the lender. To date, the proposals under consideration by the CFPB have not been adopted. If adopted, the proposals outlined by the CFPB may require the Company to make significant changes to its lending practices to develop compliance procedures.
Although the Dodd-Frank Act expressly provides that the CFPB has no authority to establish usury limits, some consumer advocacy groups have suggested that certain forms of alternative consumer finance products, such as installment loans, should be a regulatory priority and it is possible that at some time in the future the CFPB could propose and adopt rules making such lending or other products that we may offer materially less profitable or impractical. Further, the CFPB may target specific features of loans by rulemaking that could cause us to cease offering certain products. Any such rules could have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operation, and financial condition. The CFPB could also adopt rules imposing new and potentially burdensome requirements and limitations with respect to any of our current or future lines of business, which could have a material adverse effect on our operations and financial performance.
In addition to the Dodd-Frank Act’s grant of regulatory powers to the CFPB, the Dodd-Frank Act gives the CFPB authority to pursue administrative proceedings or litigation for violations of federal consumer financial laws. In these proceedings, the CFPB can obtain cease and desist orders (which can include orders for restitution or rescission of contracts, as well as other kinds of affirmative relief) and monetary penalties ranging from $5,000 per day for minor violations of federal consumer financial laws (including the CFPB’s own rules) to $25,000 per day for reckless violations and $1 million per day for knowing violations. If we are subject to such administrative proceedings, litigation, orders or monetary penalties in the future, this could have a material adverse effect on our operations and financial performance. Also, where a company has violated Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act or CFPB regulations under Title X, the Dodd-Frank Act empowers state attorneys general and state regulators to bring civil actions for the kind of cease and desist orders available to the CFPB (but not for civil penalties). If the CFPB or one or more state officials believe we have violated the foregoing laws, they could exercise their enforcement powers in ways that would have a material adverse effect on us. See “Item 1. Business – Regulation” for additional information.
Pursuant to the authority granted to it under the Dodd-Frank Act, the CFPB adopted rules that subject larger nonbank automobile finance companies such as us to supervision and examination by the CFPB. Any such examination by the CFPB likely would have a material adverse effect on our operations and financial performance.
The CFPB issued rules regarding the supervision and examination of non-depository “larger participants” in the automobile finance business, including us. The CFPB’s stated objectives of such examinations are: to assess the quality of a larger participant’s compliance management systems for preventing violations of federal consumer financial laws; to identify acts or practices that materially increase the risk of violations of federal consumer finance laws and associated harm to consumers; and to gather facts that help determine whether the larger participant engages in acts or practices that are likely to violate federal consumer financial laws in connection with its automobile finance business. Thus, as a larger participant, we will be subject to examination by the CFPB for, among other things, ECOA compliance; unfair, deceptive or abusive acts or practices (“UDAAP”) compliance; and the adequacy of our compliance management systems. At the current time, the Company is not deemed a larger participant.
We have evaluated our existing compliance management systems and are in the process of updating, improving and/or replacing such systems. We expect this process to continue as the CFPB promulgates new and evolving rules and interpretations. Given the time and effort needed to establish, implement and maintain adequate compliance management systems and the resources and costs associated with being examined by the CFPB, such an examination would likely have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and profitability. Moreover, any such examination by the CFPB could result in the assessment of penalties, including fines, and other remedies which could, in turn, have a material effect on our business, financial condition, and profitability.
We are subject to many other laws and governmental regulations, and any material violations of or changes in these laws or regulations could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and business operations.
Our financing operations are subject to regulation, supervision, and licensing under various other federal, state and local statutes and ordinances. Additionally, the procedures that we must follow in connection with the repossession of vehicles securing Contracts are regulated by each of the states in which we do business. The various federal, state and local statutes, regulations, and ordinances applicable to our business govern, among other things:
- licensing requirements;
- requirements for maintenance of proper records;
- payment of required fees to certain states;
- maximum interest rates that may be charged on loans to finance used and new vehicles;
- debt collection practices;
- proper disclosure to customers regarding financing terms;
- privacy regarding certain customer data;
- interest rates on loans to customers;
- late fees and insufficient fees charged;
- telephone solicitation of Direct Loan customers; and
- collection of debts from loan customers who have filed bankruptcy.
We believe that we maintain all material licenses and permits required for our current operations and are in substantial compliance with all applicable local, state and federal regulations. Our failure, or the failure by dealers who originate the contracts we purchase, to maintain all requisite licenses and permits, and to comply with other regulatory requirements, could result in consumers having rights of rescission and other remedies that could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition. Furthermore, any changes in applicable laws, rules and regulations, such as the passage of the Dodd-Frank Act and the creation of the CFPB, may make our compliance therewith more difficult or expensive or otherwise materially adversely affect our business and financial condition.
The loss of our key executives could have a material adverse effect on our business.
Our future growth and development are significantly dependent upon the skills and experience of our senior management team and our ability to retain that team.
We do not maintain key-man life insurance policies on any of these executives. The loss of services of one or more of the executives could have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operations, and financial condition. In fact, the turnover of our CEO, CFO, and Controller during the year ended March 31, 2018 contributed to a material weakness in our internal control over financial reporting for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. See Item 9A. Controls and Procedures in this Annual Report, the text of which is incorporated herein by reference.
We are subject to risks associated with litigation.
As a consumer finance company, we are subject to various consumer claims and litigation seeking damages and statutory penalties, based upon, among other things:
- usury laws;
- disclosure inaccuracies;
- wrongful repossession;
- violations of bankruptcy stay provisions;
- certificate of title disputes;
- fraud;
- breach of contract; and
- discriminatory treatment of credit applicants.
Some litigation against us could take the form of class action complaints by consumers. As the assignee of contracts originated by dealers, we may also be named as a co-defendant in lawsuits filed by consumers principally against dealers. The damages and penalties claimed by consumers in these types of actions can be substantial. The relief requested by the plaintiffs varies but may include requests for compensatory, statutory, and punitive damages. We also are periodically subject to other kinds of litigation typically experienced by businesses such as ours, including employment disputes and breach of contract claims. No assurances can be given that we will not experience material financial losses in the future as a result of litigation or other legal proceedings.
We depend upon our relationships with our dealers.
Our business depends in large part upon our ability to establish and maintain relationships with reputable dealers who originate the Contracts we purchase. Although we believe we have been successful in developing and maintaining such relationships, such relationships are not exclusive, and many of them are not longstanding. There can be no assurances that we will be successful in maintaining such relationships or increasing the number of dealers with whom we do business, or that our existing dealer base will continue to generate a volume of Contracts comparable to the volume of such Contracts historically generated by such dealers.
Our success depends upon our ability to implement our business strategy.
Our financial position depends on management’s ability to execute our business strategy. Key factors involved in the execution of our business strategy include achievement of the desired contract purchase volume, the use of effective risk management techniques and collection methods, continued investment in technology to support operating efficiency, and continued access to significant funding and liquidity sources.
With the recent change in senior management, the Company’s business strategy has been redefined. This strategy includes remaining committed to the branch-based model, focusing on financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower, pricing based on risk (rate, yield, advance, etc.), and a commitment to the underwriting discipline required for optimal portfolio performance.
Our failure or inability to execute any element of our business strategy could have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition.
Our business is highly dependent upon general economic conditions.
We are subject to changes in general economic conditions that are beyond our control. During periods of economic uncertainty, such as has existed for much of the past few years, delinquencies, defaults, repossessions, and losses generally increase, absent offsetting factors. These periods also may be accompanied by decreased consumer demand for automobiles and declining values of automobiles securing outstanding loans, which weakens collateral coverage on our loans and increases the amount of a loss we would experience in the event of default. Because we focus on non-prime borrowers, the actual rates of delinquencies, defaults, repossessions, and losses on these loans are higher than those experienced in the general automobile finance industry and could be more dramatically affected by a general economic downturn. In addition, during an economic slowdown or recession, our servicing costs may increase without a corresponding increase in our servicing income. No assurances can be given that our underwriting criteria and collection methods to manage the higher risk inherent in loans made to non-prime borrowers will afford adequate protection against these risks. Any sustained period of increased delinquencies, defaults, repossessions, or losses, or increased servicing costs could have a material adverse effect on our business and financial condition.
Furthermore, in a low interest-rate environment such as has existed in the United States in recent years, the level of competition increases in the non-prime consumer-finance industry as new competitors enter the market and many existing competitors expand their operations. Such increased competition, in turn, has exerted increased pressure on us to reduce our interest rates, fees, and dealer discount rates in order to maintain our market share. Although the Company has recently shifted its focus on not reducing APR and discounts to secure new loan volume, it can provide no assurances that it will be successful in doing so. Any further reductions in our interest rates, fees or dealer discount rates could have a material adverse impact on our profitability or financial condition.
The auction proceeds we receive from the sale of repossessed vehicles and other recoveries are subject to fluctuation due to economic and other factors beyond our control.
If we repossess a vehicle securing a Contract, we typically have it transported to an automobile auction for sale. Auction proceeds from the sale of repossessed vehicles and other recoveries are usually not sufficient to cover the outstanding balance of the Contract, and the resulting deficiency is charged off. In addition, there is, on average, approximately a 30-day lapse between the time we repossess a vehicle and the time it is sold. The proceeds we receive from such sales depend upon various factors, including the supply of, and demand for, used vehicles at the time of sale. Such supply and demand are dependent on many factors. For example, during periods of economic uncertainty, the demand for used cars may soften, resulting in decreased auction proceeds to us from the sale of repossessed automobiles. Furthermore, depressed wholesale prices for used automobiles may result from significant liquidations of rental or fleet inventories, and from increased volume of trade-ins due to promotional financing programs offered by new vehicle manufacturers. Newer, more expensive vehicles securing our larger dollar loans are more susceptible to wholesale pricing fluctuations than are older vehicles and also experience depreciation at a much greater rate. Until the Company’s portfolio has been successfully converted to primarily consisting of our target vehicle (primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower), the Company expects to be affected by softer auction activity and reduced vehicle values.
An increase in market interest rates may reduce our profitability.
Our long-term profitability may be directly affected by the level of and fluctuations in interest rates. Sustained, significant increases in interest rates may adversely affect our liquidity and profitability by reducing the interest rate spread between the rate of interest we receive on our Contracts and interest rates that we pay under our Credit Facility. As interest rates increase, our gross interest rate spread on new originations will generally decline since the rates charged on the contracts originated or purchased from dealers generally are limited by statutory maximums, restricting our opportunity to pass on increased interest costs. We monitor the interest rate environment and, on occasion, enter into interest rate swap agreements relating to a portion of our outstanding debt. Such agreements effectively convert a portion of our floating-rate debt to a fixed-rate, thus reducing the impact of interest rate changes on our interest expense. However, the interest rate swap agreements in effect for most of the past five years matured during the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018, and we have not entered into new arrangements. We will continue to evaluate interest rate swap pricing and we may or may not enter into interest rate swap agreements in the future.
We may experience problems with integrated computer systems or be unable to keep pace with developments in technology or conversion to new integrated computer systems.
We use various technologies in our business, including telecommunication, data processing, and integrated computer systems. Technology changes rapidly. Our ability to compete successfully with other financing companies may depend on our ability to efficiently and cost-effectively implement technological changes. Moreover, to keep pace with our competitors, we may be required to invest in technological changes that do not necessarily improve our profitability.
In February 2019, we converted from our internally developed loan operating system to a third-party loan operating system. This system is used to respond to customer inquiries and to monitor the performance of our Contract and Direct Loan portfolios and the performance of individual customers under our Contracts and Direct Loans. Problems with the system conversion could adversely impact our ability to monitor our portfolios or collect amounts due under our Contracts and Direct Loans, which could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations.
In fact, delays completing the system integration with the accounting system contributed to a material weakness in our internal control over financial reporting for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019. See Item 9A. Controls and Procedures in this Annual Report, the text of which is incorporated herein by reference.
Failure to properly safeguard confidential customer information could subject us to liability, decrease our profitability, and damage our reputation.
In the ordinary course of our business, we collect and store sensitive data, including our proprietary business information and personally identifiable information of our customers, on our computer networks, and share such data with third parties. The secure processing, maintenance and transmission of this information is critical to our operations and business strategy.
Any failure, interruption, or breach in our cyber security, including through employee misconduct or any failure of our back-up systems or failure to maintain adequate security surrounding customer information, could result in reputational harm, disruption in the management of our customer relationships, or the inability to originate, process and service our products. Further, any of these cyber security and operational risks could result in a loss of customer business, subject us to additional regulatory scrutiny, or expose us to lawsuits by customers for identity theft or other damages resulting from the misuse of their personal information and possible financial liability, any of which could have a material adverse effect on our results of operations, financial condition and liquidity. In addition, regulators may impose penalties or require remedial action if they identify weaknesses in our security systems, and we may be required to incur significant costs to increase our cyber security to address any vulnerabilities that may be discovered or to remediate the harm caused by any security breaches. As part of our business, we may share confidential customer information and proprietary information with clients, vendors, service providers, and business partners. The information systems of these third parties may be vulnerable to security breaches and we may not be able to ensure that these third parties have appropriate security controls in place to protect the information we share with them. If our confidential information is intercepted, stolen, misused, or mishandled while in possession of a third party, it could result in reputational harm to us, loss of customer business, and additional regulatory scrutiny, and it could expose us to civil litigation and possible financial liability, any of which could have a material adverse effect on our results of operations, financial condition, and liquidity.
We rely on encryption and authentication technology licensed from third parties to provide the security and authentication necessary to secure online transmission of confidential customer information. Advances in computer capabilities, new discoveries in the field of cryptography or other events or developments may result in a compromise or breach of the algorithms that we use to protect sensitive customer data. A party who is able to circumvent our security measures could misappropriate proprietary information or cause interruptions in our operations. We may be required to expend capital and other resources to protect against, or alleviate problems caused by, security breaches or other cybersecurity incidents. Although we have not experienced any material cybersecurity incidents to dates, there can be no assurance that a cyber-attack, security breach or other cybersecurity incident will not have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition or results of operations in the future. Our security measures are designed to protect against security breaches, but our failure to prevent security breaches could subject us to liability, decrease our profitability and damage our reputation.
We partially rely on third parties to deliver services, and failure by those parties to provide these services or meet contractual requirements could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
We depend on third-party service providers for many aspects of our business operations, including loan origination, title processing, and online payments, which increases our operational complexity and decreases our control. We rely on these service providers to provide a high level of service and support, which subjects us to risks associated with inadequate or untimely service. If a service provider fails to provide the services that we require or expect, or fails to meet contractual requirements, such as service levels or compliance with applicable laws, a failure could negatively impact our business by adversely affecting our ability to process customers’ transactions in a timely and accurate manner, otherwise hampering our ability to service our customers, or subjecting us to litigation or regulatory risk for poor vendor oversight. We may be unable to replace or be delayed in replacing these sources and there is a risk that we would be unable to enter into a similar agreement with an alternate provider on terms that we consider favorable or in a timely manner. Such a failure could have a material and adverse effect on our business, financial condition, and results of operations.
Our growth depends upon our ability to retain and attract a sufficient number of qualified employees.
To a large extent, our growth strategy depends on the opening of new offices that focus primarily on purchasing Contracts and making Direct Loans in markets we have not previously served. Future expansion of our branch office network depends, in part, upon our ability to attract and retain qualified and experienced office managers and the ability of such managers to develop relationships with dealers that serve those markets. We generally do not open a new office until we have located and hired a qualified and experienced individual to manage the office. Typically, this individual will be familiar with local market conditions and have existing relationships with dealers in the area to be served. Although we believe that we can attract and retain qualified and experienced personnel as we proceed with planned expansion into new markets, no assurance can be given that we will be successful in doing so. Competition to hire personnel possessing the skills and experience required by us could contribute to an increase in our employee turnover rate. High turnover or an inability to attract and retain qualified personnel could have an adverse effect on our origination, delinquency, default, and net loss rates and, ultimately, our business and financial condition.
Our stock is thinly traded, which may limit your ability to resell your shares.
The average daily trading volume of our common shares on the NASDAQ Global Select Market for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 was approximately 9,000 shares. Thus, our common shares are thinly traded. Thinly traded stock can be more volatile than stock trading in an active public market. Factors such as our financial results, the introduction of new products and services by us or our competitors, and various factors affecting the consumer-finance industry generally may have a significant impact on the market price of our common shares. In recent years, the stock market has experienced a high level of price and volume volatility, and market prices for the stocks of many companies, including ours, have experienced wide price fluctuations that have not necessarily been related to their operating performance. Therefore, our shareholders may not be able to sell their shares at the volumes, prices, or times that they desire.
Natural disasters, acts of war, terrorist attacks and threats, or the escalation of military activity in response to these attacks or otherwise may negatively affect our business, financial condition, and results of operations.
Natural disasters (such as hurricanes), acts of war, terrorist attacks and the escalation of military activity in response to these attacks or otherwise may have negative and significant effects, such as disruptions in our operations, imposition of increased security measures, changes in applicable laws, market disruptions and job losses. These events may have an adverse effect on the economy in general. Moreover, the potential for future terrorist attacks and the national and international responses to these threats could affect the business in ways that cannot be predicted. The effect of any of these events or threats could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
Changes in U.S. federal, state and local tax law or interpretations of existing tax law could increase our tax burden or otherwise adversely affect our financial condition or results of operations.
We are subject to taxation at the federal, state, and local levels in the United States. On December 22, 2017, the U.S. government enacted comprehensive tax legislation commonly referred to as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (“TCJA”). The changes included in TCJA are broad and complex. The final transition impacts of TCJA may differ from the estimates provided elsewhere in this Annual Report, possibly materially, due to, among other things, changes in interpretations of TCJA, any legislative action to address questions that arise because of TCJA, any changes in accounting standards for income taxes or related interpretations in response to TCJA, or any updates or changes to estimates the Company has utilized to calculate the transition impacts, including impacts from changes to current year earnings estimates. The estimated impact of the new law is based on management’s current knowledge and assumptions and recognized impacts could be materially different from current estimates.
Properties
As filed, 1,078 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
The Company leases its corporate headquarters and branch office facilities. The Company’s headquarters, located at 2454 McMullen Booth Road, Building C, in Clearwater, Florida, consist of approximately 15,000 square feet of office space leased at an annual rate of approximately $18.00 per square foot. The current lease relating to this space was entered into effective April 1, 2015 and expires on March 31, 2020.
As of June 2019, each of the Company’s 50 branch offices located in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, and Tennessee consists of approximately 1,400 square feet of office space. These offices are located in office parks, shopping centers, or strip malls and are occupied pursuant to leases with an initial term of one to five years at annual rates ranging from approximately $11.00 to $25.00 per square foot. The Company believes that these facilities and additional or alternate space available to it are adequate to meet its needs for the foreseeable future.
Legal proceedings
As filed, 319 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
The Company currently is not a party to any pending legal proceedings other than ordinary routine litigation incidental to its business, none of which, if decided adversely to the Company, would, in the opinion of management, have a material adverse effect on the Company’s financial condition or results of operations.
Management's discussion and analysis
As filed, 25,330 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
Overview
Nicholas Financial-Canada is a Canadian holding company incorporated under the laws of British Columbia in 1986. Nicholas Financial-Canada currently conducts its business activities exclusively through a wholly-owned indirect Florida subsidiary, Nicholas Financial. Nicholas Financial is a specialized consumer finance company engaged primarily in acquiring and servicing automobile finance installment contracts (“Contracts”) for purchases of used and new automobiles and light trucks. To a lesser extent, Nicholas Financial also originates direct consumer loans (“Direct Loans”) and sells consumer-finance related products. Nicholas Financial’s financing activities accounted for 100% of the Company’s consolidated revenue for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018. A second Florida subsidiary, Nicholas Data Services, Inc. (“NDS”), serves as an intermediate holding company for Nicholas Financial. In addition, NF Funding I, LLC (“NF Funding I”) is a newly formed, wholly-owned, special purpose financing subsidiary of Nicholas Financial.
Nicholas Financial-Canada, Nicholas Financial, NDS, NF Funding I are collectively referred to herein as the “Company”.
Introduction
The Company’s consolidated revenues decreased from $83.9 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018 to $71.3 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019. The Company’s diluted earnings per share decreased from a net loss of $0.14 per share for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018 to a loss of $0.46 per share for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019. The Company reported a $4.6 million operating loss for the year ended March 31, 2019 compared to operating income of $3.2 million for the year ended March 31, 2018. The decrease was a result of:
- decreased revenues due to a reduction in volume slightly offset by a higher portfolio yield;
- a change in the charge-off policy from 181 days to 121 days, resulting in a one-time charge of $4.9 million; and
- the closing or consolidating of 7 branches during the year, resulting in approximately $0.3 million in charges associated with accelerated rent expense and severance payments.
The Company’s consolidated net loss for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018 was $3.6 million and $1.1 million, respectively.
The Company’s operating results during fiscal 2018 generally deteriorated as a result of several factors, including, but not limited to, loosened underwriting guidelines, more aggressive pricing on originations, the acquisition of Contracts that contained some degree of fraudulent information that at the time of Contract acquisition was not identified, and an increase in the number of Contracts and Direct Loans under which customers decided to discontinue payments to the Company after they were approved by other lenders for new vehicle financing. In addition, aggressive competition had previously influenced the Company to purchase lower credit quality Contracts. Historically, the Company was able to expand its automobile finance business in the non-prime credit market by offering to purchase Contracts on terms that were competitive with those of other companies. However, it became increasingly difficult for the Company to match or exceed pricing of its competitors, which resulted in declining Contract acquisition rates during the 2016, 2017 and 2018 fiscal years.
Starting in January 2018 the Company became recommitted to financing primary transportation to and from work for the sub-prime borrower. The Company began focusing on smaller amounts financed over shorter terms with reasonable payments. As expected, and previously disclosed, the Company’s renewed focus on the Company’s core principles, did result in downward pressure on the volume of Contracts purchased and may continue to cause downward pressure, due to a highly competitive environment. While it is difficult to predict the level of competition long-term, the Company believes that the current highly competitive environment will prevail for the foreseeable future.
The gross portfolio yield of the portfolio for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018, was 26.4% and 25.6%, respectively. The average dealer discount as a percent of finance receivables associated with new volume for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018 was 8.2% and 7.4%, respectively. The increase in APR and discount (and therefore overall yield) on new purchases in fiscal 2019 as compared with fiscal 2018 was primarily driven by the Company’s recommitment to its core principles.
| Portfolio Summary | Fiscal Year ended March 31, (In thousands) 2019 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|
| Average finance receivables (1) | $270,106 | $327,832 |
| Average indebtedness (2) | $136,386 | $189,375 |
| Interest and fee income on finance receivables | 71,300 | 83,917 |
| Interest expense | 9,504 | 10,137 |
| Net interest and fee income on finance receivables | $61,796 | $73,780 |
| Gross portfolio yield (3) | 26.40% | 25.60% |
| Interest expense as a percentage of average finance receivables | 3.52% | 3.09% |
| Provision for credit losses as a percentage of average finance receivables | 12.16% | 11.42% |
| Net portfolio yield (3) | 10.72% | 11.09% |
| Operating expenses as a percentage of average finance receivables | 12.42% | 10.11% |
| Pre-tax yield as a percentage of average finance receivables(4) | (1.70)% | 0.98% |
| Write-off to liquidation (5) | 23.02% | 13.92% |
| Net charge-off percentage (6) | 13.39% | 10.65% |
(1) Average finance receivables represent the average of finance receivables throughout the period.
(2) Average indebtedness represents the average outstanding borrowings under the Credit Facility.
(3) Gross portfolio yield represents interest and fee income on finance receivables as a percentage of average finance receivables. Net portfolio yield represents (a) interest and fee income on finance receivables minus (b) interest expense minus (c) the provision for credit losses, as a percentage of average finance receivables.
(4) Pre-tax yield represents net portfolio yield minus administrative expenses (marketing, salaries, employee benefits, depreciation, and administrative), as a percentage of average finance receivables.
(5) Write-off to liquidation percentage is defined as net charge-offs divided by liquidation. Liquidation is defined as beginning finance receivables balance plus current period purchases and originations minus ending finance receivables balance.
(6) Net charge-off percentage represents net charge-offs divided by average finance receivables outstanding during the period.
(7) Allowance percentage represents the allowance for credit losses divided by average finance receivables outstanding during the period.
Critical Accounting Policy
The Company’s critical accounting policy relates to the allowance for credit losses. It is based on management’s opinion of an amount that is adequate to absorb losses incurred in the existing portfolio. Because of the nature of the customers under the Company’s Contracts and Direct Loan program, the Company considers the establishment of adequate reserves for credit losses to be imperative.
During the first quarter of fiscal 2019, the Company began using the trailing six-month net charge-off percentage, annualized, applied to ending finance receivables, to calculate the allowance for credit losses. This change was made to reflect changes in the Company’s lending policies and underwriting standards, which resulted from the Company changing its business strategies. The change in the Company’s method for calculating the allowance for credit losses was accounted for as a change in estimate. The Company re-focused on financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower. This change resulted in purchasing higher yielding loans, with smaller amounts financed and shorter monthly terms. A trailing six-month net charge-off percentage, annualized, applied to ending finance receivables is also more in line with the industry practice, which typically uses a trailing twelve-month net charge-off methodology. Management believes a trailing six-month will more quickly reflect changes in the portfolio.
In addition, the Company takes into consideration the composition of the portfolio, current economic conditions, the estimated net realizable value of the underlying collateral, historical loan loss experience, delinquency, non-performing assets, and bankrupt accounts when determining management’s estimate of probable credit losses and the adequacy of the allowance for credit losses. If the allowance for credit losses is determined to be inadequate, then an additional charge to the provision would be recorded to maintain adequate reserves based on management’s evaluation of the risk inherent in the loan portfolio.
Prior to the first quarter of fiscal 2019, the Company calculated the allowance for credit losses by reference to static pools, with each pool consisting of Contracts purchased during a three-month period for a given branch location, as management considered the Contracts in those pools to have similar risk characteristics. The Company analyzed each consolidated static pool at specific points in time to estimate losses that were likely to be incurred as of the reporting date. The Company maintained historical write-off information for over 10 years with respect to every consolidated static pool and segregated each static pool by liquidation, thereby creating snapshots or buckets of each pool’s historical write-off-to liquidation ratio at five different points in each pool’s liquidation cycle. These snapshots were then used to assist in determining the allowance for credit losses. The five snapshots were tracked at liquidation levels of 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, and 100%.
Contracts are purchased from many different dealers and are all purchased on an individual Contract-by-Contract basis. Individual Contract pricing is determined by the automobile dealerships and is generally the lesser of the applicable state maximum interest rate, if any, or the maximum interest rate which the customer will accept. In most markets, competitive forces will drive down Contract rates from the maximum rate to a level where an individual competitor is willing to buy an individual Contract. The Company generally purchases Contracts on an individual basis.
The Company utilizes the branch model, which allows for Contract purchasing to be done at the branch level. The Company has detailed underwriting guidelines it utilizes to determine which Contracts to purchase. These guidelines are specific and are designed to provide reasonable assurance that the Contracts that the Company purchases have common risk characteristics. The Company utilizes its District Managers to evaluate their respective branch locations for adherence to these underwriting guidelines, as well as approve underwriting exceptions. The Company also utilizes internal audit (“IA”) to assure adherence to its underwriting guidelines. Any Contract that does not meet the Company’s underwriting guidelines can be submitted by a branch manager for approval from the Company’s District Managers or senior management.
Fiscal 2019 Compared to Fiscal 2018
Interest and Fee Income on Finance Receivables
Interest and fee income on finance receivables, predominantly finance charge income, decreased to $71.3 million in fiscal 2019 as compared to $83.9 million in fiscal 2018. The average finance receivables totaled $270.1 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, a decrease of 17.6% from $327.8 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. Purchasing volume has continued to decrease from fiscal 2018 as a result of tightening the Company’s credit underwriting standards and a reduction in auto sales year over year.
Competition also continued to affect the Company’s ability to acquire Contracts, furthermore, the Company’s renewed strategic focus of financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower has impacted the Company’s ability to acquire Contracts at desired yields. The yield on new Contract purchases increased from 22.4% for fiscal 2018 to 23.5% for fiscal 2019 and the average discount increased from 7.4% for fiscal 2018 to 8.2% for fiscal 2019. Although the Company will continue to try and find ways to grow market share, it will continue to be focused on yield.
The gross portfolio yield increased to 26.4% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 as compared to 25.6% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. The gross portfolio yield increased primarily due to the increase in the average APR and average discount on contracts purchased since January 2018. The net portfolio yield decreased to 10.7% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 from 11.1% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. The net portfolio yield decreased due to an increase in the provision for credit losses as a percentage of finance receivables, as described under “Analysis of Credit Losses” below, offset by a decrease in interest expense.
Operating Expenses
Operating expenses increased slightly to $33.5 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 compared to $33.2 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018 because of increased marketing expense partially offset by a decrease in salaries and employee benefits. Marketing expenses increased approximately $1.0 million due the Company no longer capitalizing bonuses (“Spiffs”) paid to the dealers. The Company accounted for this change as a change in accounting estimate. Beginning in fiscal 2019, spiffs are expensed when incurred. Salaries and employee benefits decreased by approximately $0.9 million, resulting from a reduction in the number of employees.
Interest Expense
Interest expense decreased to $9.5 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, as compared to $10.1 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018, due to a decrease in average outstanding debt and interest rate. The average outstanding debt during the year ended March 31, 2019 decreased to $136.4 million from $189.4 million during the year ended March 31, 2018. The following table summarizes the Company’s average cost of borrowed funds for the fiscal years ended March 31:
| 2019 | 2018 | |
|---|---|---|
| Variable interest under the line of credit and credit facility | 2.97% | 2.76% |
| Settlements under interest rate swap agreements | (—%) | (0.01%) |
| Credit spread under the line of credit and credit facility | 4.00% | 4.35% |
| Average cost of borrowed funds | 6.97% | 7.10% |
LIBOR rates have increased (2.49% as of March 31, 2019 compared to 1.88% as of March 31, 2018) which was offset by a decrease in the credit spread under the line of credit. For further discussions regarding interest rates see “Note 5 – Credit Facility”.
Analysis of Credit Losses
The following table sets forth a reconciliation of the changes in the allowance for credit losses on Contracts and Direct Loans for the fiscal years ended March 31:
(In thousands)
| For the year ended March 31, 2019 Indirect | Direct | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance at beginning of year | $19,433 | $833 | $20,266 |
| Provision for credit losses | 32,715 | 121 | 32,836 |
| Charge-offs | (37,514) | (638) | (38,152) |
| Recoveries | 1,941 | 41 | 1,982 |
| Balance at end of year | $16,575 | $357 | $16,932 |
(In thousands)
| For the year ended March 31, 2018 Indirect | Direct | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance at beginning of year | $16,885 | $773 | $17,658 |
| Provision for credit losses | 36,890 | 560 | 37,450 |
| Charge-offs | (36,183) | (536) | (36,719) |
| Recoveries | 1,841 | 36 | 1,877 |
| Balance at end of year | $19,433 | $833 | $20,266 |
During the first quarter of the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019, the Company began using the trailing six-month charge-offs, annualized, to calculate the allowance for credit losses. This change was made to reflect changes in the Company’s lending policies and underwriting standards, which resulted from the Company changing its business strategies. The Company re-focused on financing primary transportation to and from work for the subprime borrower. This change resulted in purchasing higher yielding loans, with smaller amounts financed and shorter monthly terms. A trailing six-month, annualized, is also more in line with the industry practice, which uses a trailing twelve-month. Management believes a trailing six-month will more quickly reflect changes in the portfolio.
In addition, the Company takes into consideration the composition of the portfolio, current economic conditions, the estimated net realizable value of the underlying collateral, historical loan loss experience, delinquency, non-performing assets, and bankrupt accounts when determining management’s estimate of probable credit losses and adequacy of the allowance for credit losses. If the allowance for credit losses is determined to be inadequate, then an additional charge to the provision would be recorded to maintain adequate reserves based on management’s evaluation of the risk inherent in the loan portfolio.
The provision for credit losses decreased to $32.8 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 from $37.5 million for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018, largely due to the 17.6% decrease in the average finance receivables.
Net charge-offs increased to 13.4% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 from 10.7% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018, primarily resulting from the Company changing its charge-off policy from 181 days past due to 121 days past due, which resulted in the Company charging-off approximately $6.4 million of finance receivables during the fourth quarter of fiscal 2019.
The Company’s losses as a percentage of liquidation (see note 5 in the Portfolio Summary table in the “Introduction” above for the definition of write-off to liquidation) increased to 23.0% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 as compared to 13.9% for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2018. This increase was the result of the Company changing its charge-off policy from 181+ days to 121+ days, which resulted in a one-time charge-off of $6.4 million.
Recoveries as a percentage of charge-offs were approximately 5.2% and 5.1% for the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and 2018, respectively. The Company attributes a large portion of this decrease simply to the increase in charge-offs; historically, there is typically a six to twelve-month lag period prior to receiving any benefits from post charge-off collection activity. Periodically, the Company will aggregate charge-off accounts it deems uncollectible and sell them to a third-party.
The delinquency percentage for Contracts more than thirty days past due, excluding Chapter 13 bankruptcy accounts, as of March 31, 2019 was 10.1%, an increase from 8.8% as of March 31, 2018. The delinquency percentage for Direct Loans more than thirty days past due, excluding Chapter 13 bankruptcy accounts, as of March 31, 2019 was 3.8%, a decrease from 5.2% as of March 31, 2018. The increase in delinquency percentage for Contracts was due to the Company tightening its deferral policy, starting in January 2018.
In accordance with Company policies and procedures, certain borrowers qualify for, and the Company offers, one-month principal payment deferrals on Contracts and Direct Loans. For the fiscal years ended March 31, 2019 and March 31, 2018 the Company granted deferrals to approximately 13.2% and 38.4%, respectively, of total Contracts and Direct Loans. The decrease in the number of deferrals in fiscal 2019 compared to fiscal 2018 resulted from the Company tightening its deferral policy, starting in January 2018.
Income Taxes
The Company recorded a tax benefit of approximately $0.9 million during fiscal 2019 compared to a $4.3 million income tax expense during fiscal 2018. The Company’s effective tax rate in fiscal 2019 was 20.5% compared to 134.7% in fiscal 2018. The decrease was primarily the result of the U.S. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act ( "TCJA"), which was enacted on December 22, 2017. For further discussion regarding income taxes see “Note 7 – Income Taxes”.
Liquidity and Capital Resources
The Company’s cash flows are summarized as follows:
| Cash provided by (used in): | Fiscal Year ended March 31, (In thousands) 2019 | 2018 |
|---|---|---|
| Operating activities | $14,404 | $25,152 |
| Investing activities | 44,159 | 21,826 |
| Financing activities | (23,547) | (47,207) |
| Net increase (decrease) in cash | $35,016 | $(229) |
The Company made certain reclassifications to the fiscal 2018 statement of cash flows to reclass unearned insurance and fee commissions from operating activities to investing activities. In addition, debt origination costs were reclassed from operating activities to financing activities. Net loss and shareholders’ equity were not impacted.
The Company’s primary use of working capital for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2019 was funding the purchase of Contracts, which are financed substantially through cash from principal and interest payments received, and the Company’s line of credit.
On March 29, 2019, NF Funding I, a special purpose financing subsidiary of Nicholas Financial, entered into a senior secured credit facility (the “Credit Facility”) pursuant to a credit agreement with Ares Agent Services, L.P., as administrative agent and collateral agent, and the lenders that are party thereto (the “Credit Agreement”). The Company’s prior line of credit was paid off in connection with this Credit Facility.
Pursuant to the Credit Agreement, the lenders agreed to extend to the Company a line of credit of up to $175,000,000, which will be used to purchase Contracts from Nicholas Financial on a revolving basis pursuant to a related receivables purchase agreement between NF Funding I and Nicholas Financial (the “Receivables Purchase Agreement”). Under the terms of the Receivables Purchase Agreement, Nicholas Financial sells to NF Funding I the receivables under Contracts. Nicholas Financial continues to service the Contracts transferred to NF Funding I pursuant to a related servicing agreement (the “Servicing Agreement”).
The availability of funds under the Credit Facility is generally limited to 82.5% of the value of non-delinquent receivables, and outstanding advances under the Credit Facility will accrue interest at a rate of LIBOR plus 3.75%. The commitment period for advances under the Credit Facility is three years. At the end of the commitment period, the outstanding balance would be paid off over a four-year amortization period.
The Company will continue to depend on the availability the Credit Facility, together with cash from operations, to finance future operations. The availability of funds under the Credit Facility generally depends on availability calculations as defined in the Credit Agreement. In addition, the Credit Agreement and the other loan documents contain customary events of default and negative covenants, including but not limited to those governing indebtedness, liens, fundamental changes, investments, and sales of receivables. See “Risk Factors—Our Credit Facility is subject to certain defaults and negative covenants.” If an event of default occurs under the Credit Facility, the Company’s lenders could increase the Company’s borrowing costs, restrict the Company’s ability to obtain additional borrowings under the facility, accelerate all amounts outstanding under the facility, or enforce their interest against collateral pledged under the facility, or enforce their rights under guarantees.
Impact of Inflation
The Company is affected by inflation primarily through increased operating costs and expenses including increases in interest rates. Inflationary pressures on operating costs and expenses historically have been largely offset by the Company’s continued emphasis on stringent operating and cost controls, although no assurances can be given regarding the Company’s ability to offset the effects of inflation in the future.
Contractual Obligations
The following table summarizes the Company’s material obligations as of March 31, 2019.
| Payments Due by Period (In thousands) Total | Less than 1 year | 1 to 3 years | 3 to 5 years | More than 5 years | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operating leases | $3,444 | $2,032 | $1,379 | $33 | $— |
| Line of credit | 145,000 | — | — | 108,750 | 36,250 |
| Interest on credit facility | 50,550 | 10,107 | 20,213 | 18,958 | 1,272 |
| Total | $198,994 | $12,139 | $21,592 | $127,741 | $37,522 |
32
The Company’s $175.0 million commitment period for advances under the Credit Facility matures March 31, 2022. At the end of the commitment period, the outstanding balance would be paid off over a four-year amortization period. The pricing of the Credit Facility is 375 basis points above 30-day LIBOR. The unused line fee on the Credit Facility is 0.50%. Interest on outstanding borrowings under the Credit Facility as of March 31, 2019, is based on an effective interest rate of 6.97%. The effective interest rate used in the above table does not contemplate the possibility of entering into interest rate swap agreements in the future.
Market risk
As filed, 937 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
Market risks relating to the Company’s operations result primarily from changes in interest rates. The Company does not engage in speculative or leveraged transactions, nor does it hold or issue financial instruments for trading purposes.
Interest Rate Risk
Management’s objective is to minimize the cost of borrowing through an appropriate mix of fixed and floating rate debt. Derivative financial instruments, such as interest rate swap agreements, may be used for the purpose of managing fluctuating interest rate exposures that exist from ongoing business operations. The Company does not use interest rate swap agreements for speculative purposes.
As of March 31, 2019, $145.0 million, or 100% of our total debt, was subject to floating interest rates. A hypothetical increase in the variable interest rates of 1% or 100 basis points would result in an annual pre-tax increase of interest expense of approximately $1.5 million.
Controls and procedures
As filed, 8,442 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
Evaluation of Disclosure Controls and Procedures
The Company maintains disclosure controls and procedures designed to ensure information required to be disclosed in its reports filed pursuant to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the “Exchange Act”), is recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in the SEC’s rules and forms. Such information is accumulated and communicated to management, including the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer as appropriate, to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure. The Company’s management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, does not expect that the Company’s disclosure controls and procedures or internal controls will prevent all possible error and fraud. A control system, no matter how well conceived and operated, can provide only reasonable, not absolute, assurance that the objectives of the control system are met. Further, the design of a control system must reflect the fact there are resource constraints, and the benefits of controls must be considered relative to their costs. Because of the inherent limitations in all control systems, no evaluation of controls can provide absolute assurance that all control issues and instances of fraud, if any, within the Company have been detected.
The Company’s management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, conducted an evaluation of the effectiveness of the Company’s disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in Rule 13a-15(e) under the Exchange Act) as of March 31, 2019. Based upon this evaluation, the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer have concluded that the Company’s disclosure controls and procedures were not effective as of March 31, 2019. Notwithstanding the material weakness described in Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting below, the Company’s management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, has concluded that the consolidated financial statements included in this Annual Report present fairly, in all material respects, our financial position, results of operations and cash flows as of the dates, and for the periods presented, in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States.
Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting
The Company’s management is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting, as such term is defined in Rule 13a-15(f) under the Exchange Act. The Company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation and fair presentation of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. The Company’s management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, conducted an evaluation of the effectiveness of the Company’s internal control over financial reporting as of March 31, 2019, the end of the fiscal year covered by this Report, based on the criteria set forth in Internal Control-Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. Based on this evaluation, management has concluded that the Company’s internal control over financial reporting was not effective as of March 31, 2019 as a result of a material weakness. A material weakness is a deficiency or a combination of deficiencies, in internal control over financial reporting, such that there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the registrant’s annual or interim financial statements will not be prevented or detected on a timely basis. Specifically, management identified the following internal control deficiencies that are considered to be material weaknesses:
1) Management Turnover
The Company experienced significant management turnover in the year ended March 31, 2018, and during fiscal year 2019. The turnover included the Chief Executive Officer, the Chief Financial Officer, and the Controller, which all have significant roles in the structure of the Company’s internal control over financial reporting. In addition to this, the Company hired an Assistant Controller during fiscal 2019, which has a significant impact on the day-to-day operation of the accounting function. With the implementation of new management, there was an acclimation period, in which management had to familiarize themselves with the systems and processes of the Company. The new management team implemented certain policies and procedures that changed the way the Company was previously operating, particularly surrounding the loans receivable portfolio, and the underwriting standards, by tightening the underwriting standards and lessening payment deferrals. These policy and procedure changes changed the design of the internal controls, and some of the previous controls were no longer applicable to the Company.
On February 1, 2019, the new management team implemented a conversion of the Company’s in-house loan operating system to a third-party loan operating system. The new loan system has improved internal controls since it’s serviced by a third-party and not managed in-house.
Due to the turnover and system conversion, the Company was unable to maintain consistent internal control processes, testing and documentation at a level necessary to enable management to assess the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting as of March 31, 2019.
2) Lack of Segregation of Duties
Due to the limited number of employees with accounting experience at the Company, many of the schedules prepared, including schedules surrounding critical accounting areas, were performed without proper review, therefore, segregation of duties did not exist at the Company.
Notwithstanding the material weakness, the Company’s management, including its Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, has concluded that the consolidated financial statements included in this Annual Report present fairly, in all material respects, our financial position, results of operations and cash flows as of the dates, and for the periods presented, in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States.
Remedial Actions
The Company has taken the following remedial actions to address the material weakness:
- The Company is in the process of ensuring the mapping between the loan operating system and the financial reporting system are correct.
- With the arrival of the permanent Chief Financial Officer, the Company will undergo a review of its internal control policies and procedures, and make changes if deemed necessary, to ensure items noted in the above Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting are in place and operating as intended.
- Hired an additional Assistant Controller in the first quarter of fiscal 2020.
Management believes the foregoing efforts will effectively remediate the material weakness. As management continues to evaluate and work to improve internal control over financial reporting, management may determine to take additional measures to address control deficiencies or determine to modify or supplement the remediation plan described above. Management cannot assure you, however, when the Company will remediate such weakness, nor can management be certain of whether additional actions will be required or the costs of any such actions.
Attestation report of the registered public accounting firm
This Annual Report does not include an attestation report of the Company’s independent registered public accounting firm regarding internal control over financial reporting. Management’s report was not subject to attestation by the Company’s independent registered public accounting firm pursuant to the rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Changes in Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
No change in the Company’s internal control over financial reporting occurred during the Company’s fiscal quarter ended March 31, 2019 that has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, the Company’s internal control over financial reporting, except as identified in Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting above.
Figures reported in this filing
Standardized line items from the XBRL in this filing, for the period ended 2019-03-31. Comparative periods it repeats are left out.
| Line item | Period | Value | XBRL concept |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interest expense | 3 months2019-01-01 to 2019-03-31 | $2.3m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Interest expense | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | $9.5m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Income tax | 3 months2019-01-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$1.2m | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Income tax | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$940.0k | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Net income | 3 months2019-01-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$4.7m | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Net income | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$3.6m | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Diluted EPS | 3 months2019-01-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$0.60 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareDiluted |
| Diluted EPS | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$0.46 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareDiluted |
| Basic EPS | 3 months2019-01-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$0.60 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasic |
| Basic EPS | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | −$0.46 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasic |
| Diluted shares (weighted) | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | 7,861,000 shares | us-gaap:WeightedAverageNumberOfDilutedSharesOutstanding |
| Operating cash flow | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | $14.4m | us-gaap:NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities |
| Capital expenditure | 12 months2018-04-01 to 2019-03-31 | $228.0k | us-gaap:PaymentsToAcquirePropertyPlantAndEquipment |
| Cash and equivalents | At period end2019-03-31 | $35.6m | us-gaap:Cash |
| Total assets | At period end2019-03-31 | $252.4m | us-gaap:Assets |
| Total liabilities | At period end2019-03-31 | $147.5m | us-gaap:Liabilities |
| Long-term debt | At period end2019-03-31 | $142.6m | us-gaap:LongTermDebt |
| Shareholders' equity | At period end2019-03-31 | $104.9m | us-gaap:StockholdersEquity |
Source: SEC EDGAR, the filing index for accession 0001564590-19-023956. Last ingested by Listed: Oct 24, 2026, 15:01 ET. Listed shows no prices and gives no investment advice.