CBL & Associates Properties Inc: Form 10-Q for the period ended Sep 30, 2020
Filed with the SEC on Nov 16, 2020 and accepted by EDGAR at Nov 16, 2020, 17:08 ET.
Management's discussion and analysis
As filed, 123,678 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
The following discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations should be read in conjunction with the condensed consolidated financial statements and accompanying notes that are included in this Form 10-Q. Capitalized terms used, but not defined, in this Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations have the same meanings as defined in the notes to the condensed consolidated financial statements. In this discussion, the terms “we,” “us” and “our” refer to the Company or the Company and the Operating Partnership collectively, as the text requires.
Certain statements made in this section or elsewhere in this report may be deemed “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the federal securities laws. All statements other than statements of historical fact should be considered to be forward-looking statements. In many cases, these forward-looking statements may be identified by the use of words such as “will,” “may,” “should,” “could,” “believes,” “expects,” “anticipates,” “estimates,” “intends,” “projects,” “goals,” “objectives,” “targets,” “predicts,” “plans,” “seeks,” and variations of these words and similar expressions. Any forward-looking statement speaks only as of the date on which it is made and is qualified in its entirety by reference to the factors discussed throughout this report.
Although we believe the expectations reflected in any forward-looking statements are based on reasonable assumptions, forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance or results and we can give no assurance that these expectations will be attained. It is possible that actual results may differ materially from those indicated by these forward-looking statements due to a variety of known and unknown risks and uncertainties. Currently, one of the most significant factors that could cause actual outcomes to differ materially from our forward-looking statements is the potential adverse effect of the COVID-19 pandemic, and federal, state, and/or local regulatory guidelines to control it, on our financial condition, operating results and cash flows, our tenants and their customers, the real estate market in which we operate, the global economy and the financial markets. The extent to which the COVID-19 pandemic impacts us and our tenants will depend on future developments, which are highly uncertain and cannot be predicted with confidence, including the scope, severity and duration of the pandemic, the direct and indirect economic effects of the pandemic and containment measures, and potential changes in consumer behavior, among others. In addition to the risk factors described in Part I, Item 1A of our Annual Report on Form 10-K, as amended, for the year ended December 31, 2019, and in Part II, Item 1A of this report, such known risks and uncertainties, many of which may be influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic, include, without limitation:
- general industry, economic and business conditions;
- the impact of the risks and uncertainties associated with the Chapter 11 process on our operations and ability to develop and execute the Company’s business plans, and to satisfy the conditions and milestones applicable under the Restructuring Support Agreement, for the duration of the Chapter 11 Cases;
- interest rate fluctuations;
- costs and availability of capital, including debt, and capital requirements;
- suspension of trading or delisting of our common stock and/or depositary shares representing interests in our Series D Preferred Stock and Series E Preferred Stock, from the NYSE;
- costs and availability of real estate;
- inability to consummate acquisition opportunities and other risks associated with acquisitions;
- competition from other companies and retail formats;
- changes in retail demand and rental rates in our markets;
- shifts in customer demands including the impact of online shopping;
- tenant bankruptcies or store closings;
- changes in vacancy rates at our properties;
- changes in operating expenses;
- changes in applicable laws, rules and regulations;
- sales of real property;
- uncertainty and economic impact of pandemics, epidemics or other public health emergencies or fear of such events, such as the recent COVID-19 pandemic;
- cyber-attacks or acts of cyber-terrorism;
- changes in, or withdrawal of, the credit ratings of the Operating Partnership's senior unsecured long-term indebtedness;
- the ability to obtain suitable equity and/or debt financing and the continued availability of financing, in the amounts and on the terms necessary to support our future refinancing requirements and business; and
- other risks referenced from time to time in filings with the SEC and those factors listed or incorporated by reference into this report.
This list of risks and uncertainties is only a summary and is not intended to be exhaustive. We disclaim any obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements to reflect actual results or changes in the factors affecting the forward-looking information.
EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW
We are a self-managed, self-administered, fully integrated REIT that is engaged in the ownership, development, acquisition, leasing, management and operation of regional shopping malls, open-air and mixed-use centers, outlet centers, associated centers, community centers, office and other properties. See Note 1 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for information on our property interests as of September 30, 2020. We have elected to be taxed as a REIT for federal income tax purposes.
On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization classified COVID-19 as a pandemic. Due to the extraordinary governmental actions taken to contain COVID-19, we are unable to predict the full extent of the pandemic’s impact on our results of operations for the remainder of 2020. As a result, we previously withdrew our full-year 2020 same-center NOI and FFO per share, as adjusted, guidance and underlying assumptions and do not plan to reinstate full-year 2020 guidance.
In response to local and state mandated closures, our entire portfolio, except for a few properties, closed in March. Beginning in late April, government agencies began allowing the re-opening of properties with specified health and safety restrictions. By the close of the third quarter 2020, all of our mall properties were able to reopen. As local mandates were lifted and properties reopened, stores within the properties followed suit with the majority of stores reopening by the close of the third quarter. We have implemented strict procedures and guidelines for our employees, tenants and property visitors based on CDC and other health agency recommendations. Our properties continue to update these policies and procedures, following any new mandates and regulations, as required. The safety and health of our customers, employees and tenants remains a top priority.
Our financial and operating results for the third quarter reflect the ongoing impact of the temporary closure of our portfolio for a significant period due to government mandates and operating restrictions. While all properties were able to reopen by the close of the third quarter, many state and local markets continue to impose occupancy and other restrictions. These additional restrictions may have the effect of restricting traffic and sales for our tenants and may put additional pressure on our tenants’ financial health. We have worked with our tenants to enhance customer reach despite the restrictions, including offering curbside, delivery and opening buy-online-pick-up-instore locations. Revenues for the quarter were impacted by a substantial increase in the estimate for uncollectible revenues related to rents due from tenants that recently filed for bankruptcy or are struggling financially. The pandemic accelerated a number of tenant bankruptcies, resulting in an expectation of additional store closures and lost rent through the remainder of the year. Store closures and rent loss from prior tenant bankruptcies, rent abatements granted and lower percentage rent related to lower retail sales also impacted revenues. We offset a portion of this decline through aggressive actions to reduce costs both at the property and corporate levels, including company-wide salary reductions, furloughs, reductions-in-force and other expense reduction initiatives. However, as properties reopened during the third quarter, certain expenses necessarily resumed.
The mandated closures resulted in nearly all of our tenants closing for a period of time and/or shortening operating hours. As a result, we have experienced an increased level of requests for rent deferrals and abatements, as well as defaults on rent obligations. While, in general, we believe that tenants have a clear contractual obligation to pay rent, we have been working with our tenants to address rent deferral and abatement requests. Based on completed or in process agreements with 25 of our top tenants, representing approximately 40% of total revenues for the second and third quarters of 2020, we anticipate collecting over 65% of related rent for the second quarter and over 81% for the third quarter, with the majority of the remainder expected to be deferred or abated. We remain in negotiations with tenants and are unable to predict the outcome of those discussions. As we finalize negotiations, rent collections as a percentage of billed cash-based rents have increased with certain past-due amounts being paid. As of the end of the third quarter, the April 2020 collection rate had improved from 27% to over 76% and May improved from 33% to 68%. We expect this trend to continue as we move later in the year and into 2021, and certain deferred rents begin coming due. As of early November 2020, we estimate that we will defer $25.3 million, at our share, of rents that were billed for April through September 2020. Substantially all of this amount is related to agreements that were executed as of September 30, 2020 with the remainder in active negotiation. Additionally, we granted rent abatements of approximately $13.1 million and $14.9 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively. We continue to assess rent relief requests from our tenants but are unable to predict the resolution or impact of these discussions.
We implemented a full financial COVID-19 response to improve liquidity and reduce costs. These significant actions included drawing $280 million on our secured line of credit, eliminating all non-essential expenditures, implementing a company-wide furlough and salary reduction program, implementing a permanent reduction in force and delaying and suspending capital expenditures, including redevelopment investments. See the "Liquidity and Capital Resources" section for more information.
As discussed in “Note 1 – Organization and Basis of Presentation” and “Note 8 – Mortgage and Other Indebtedness, Net” to the condensed consolidated financial statements and in “Liquidity and Capital Resources” herein, we received notices of default and reservation of rights letters from the administrative agent under the secured credit facility asserting that certain defaults and events of default have occurred and continue to exist as of the date of this report by reason of the our failure to comply with certain restrictive covenants in the secured credit facility. As a result of these asserted defaults and events of default, the lenders under the secured credit facility declared all outstanding principal, accrued interest and letters of credit to be immediately due and payable. As of the date of this report, the lenders under the secured credit facility have not commenced foreclosure proceedings, but they may seek to exercise one or more remedies in the future. Additionally, we failed to meet the minimum debt yield covenant under the secured credit facility as of September 30, 2020. We could remain in compliance with the debt yield covenant if we (i) added additional unencumbered assets to the collateral pool, subject to lender approval, which is not to be unreasonably withheld, (ii) paid down the amount of debt outstanding with projected available cash or (iii) negotiated a waiver of the covenant with the lenders. We currently do not intend to add additional unencumbered assets to the collateral pool or pay down the amount of debt outstanding. See Note 1 – Organization and Basis of Presentation and Liquidity and Capital Resources for additional information.
We had a net loss for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020 of $44.4 million and $256.5 million respectively, compared to a net loss for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2019 of $92.0 million and $168.5 million, respectively. We recorded a net loss attributable to common shareholders for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020 of $54.1 million and $269.4 million, respectively compared to a net loss for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2019 of $90.1 million and $175.7 million, respectively. In addition to the impact of the government mandated closures and the ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, significant items that affected the comparability between the three-month periods include $13.0 million of costs related to the Company’s restructuring efforts, $14.5 million of incremental interest expense related to the imposition of the base and post-default rates on the Company’s credit facility borrowings, a loss on impairment that is $135.6 million lower in 2020 than in 2019 and a litigation settlement credit that is $20.2 million lower in 2020 than in 2019. For the nine-month periods, in addition to the impact of the government mandated closures and ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, significant items that affected the comparability between the nine-month periods include a loss on impairment that is $55.2 million lower in 2020, litigation settlement expense in 2020 that is $67.9 million lower, gain on extinguishment of debt that is $56.3 million lower and $11.2 million less of gain on investments/deconsolidation than were recognized in the nine months ended September 30, 2019. We also deconsolidated three outlet centers in the third and fourth quarters of 2019.
Same-center NOI and FFO are non-GAAP measures. For a description of same-center NOI, a reconciliation from net income (loss) to same-center NOI, and an explanation of why we believe this is a useful performance measure, see Non-GAAP Measure - Same-center Net Operating Income in “Results of Operations.” For a description of FFO, a reconciliation from net income (loss) attributable to common shareholders to FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders, and an explanation of why we believe this is a useful performance measure, see "Non-GAAP Measure - Funds from Operations."
Voluntary Reorganization under Chapter 11
Beginning on November 1, 2020 (the “Commencement Date”), the Company and certain of its domestic subsidiaries (collectively with the Company, the “Debtors”), commenced voluntary chapter 11 cases (the “Chapter 11 Cases”) by filing voluntary petitions for reorganization under chapter 11 of title 11 (“Chapter 11”) of the United States Code (the “Bankruptcy Code”) with the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas (the “Bankruptcy Court”). The Debtors are authorized to continue to operate their businesses and manage their properties as debtors in possession pursuant to sections 1107(a) and 1108 of the Bankruptcy Code. Pursuant to Rule 1015(b) of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure, the Debtors’ Chapter 11 Cases are being jointly administered for procedural purposes only under the caption In re CBL & Associates Properties, Inc., et al., Case No. 20-35226. Documents filed on the docket of and other information related to the Chapter 11 Cases are available free of charge online at https://dm.epiq11.com/case/cbj/dockets.
We are currently operating our business as debtors-in-possession in accordance with the applicable provisions of the Bankruptcy Code and orders of the Bankruptcy Court. After we filed our Chapter 11 petitions, the Bankruptcy Court granted certain relief requested by the Debtors enabling us to conduct our business activities in the ordinary course, including, among other things and subject to the terms and conditions of such orders, authorizing us to pay employee wages and benefits, to pay taxes and certain governmental fees and charges, to continue to operate our cash management system in the ordinary course, and to pay the prepetition claims of certain of our service providers. For goods and services provided following the Commencement Date, we intend to pay service providers in the ordinary course.
Subject to certain exceptions, under the Bankruptcy Code, the filing of the Chapter 11 Cases automatically enjoined, or stayed, the continuation of most judicial or administrative proceedings or filing of other actions against the Debtors or their property to recover, collect or secure a claim arising prior to the Commencement Date. Accordingly, although the filing of the Chapter 11 Cases triggered defaults under the Debtors’ funded debt obligations, creditors are stayed from taking any actions against the Debtors as a result of such defaults, subject to certain limited exceptions permitted by the Bankruptcy Code. Absent an order of the Bankruptcy Court, substantially all of the Debtors’ prepetition liabilities are subject to settlement under the Bankruptcy Code.
For the duration of the Company’s Chapter 11 proceedings, the Company’s operations and ability to develop and execute its business plan are subject to the risks and uncertainties associated with the Chapter 11 process. As a result of these risks and uncertainties, the amount and composition of the Company’s assets, liabilities, officers and/or directors could be significantly different following the outcome of the Chapter 11 proceedings, and the description of the Company’s operations, properties and liquidity and capital resources included in this quarterly report may not accurately reflect its operations, properties and liquidity and capital resources following the Chapter 11 process.
In particular, subject to certain exceptions, under the Bankruptcy Code, the Debtors may assume, assume and assign or reject executory contracts and unexpired leases subject to the approval of the Bankruptcy Court and certain other conditions. Generally, the rejection of an executory contract or unexpired lease is treated as a prepetition breach of such executory contract or unexpired lease and, subject to certain exceptions, relieves the Debtors of performing their future obligations under such executory contract or unexpired lease but entitles the contract counterparty or lessor to a prepetition general unsecured claim for damages caused by such deemed breach subject, in the case of the rejection of unexpired leases of real property, to certain caps on damages. Counterparties to such rejected contracts or leases may assert unsecured claims in the Bankruptcy Court against the applicable Debtor’s estate for such damages. Generally, the assumption or assumption and assignment of an executory contract or unexpired lease requires the Debtors to cure existing monetary defaults under such executory contract or unexpired lease and provide adequate assurance of future performance thereunder. Accordingly, any description of an executory contract or unexpired lease with the Debtors in this quarterly report, including where applicable a quantification of the Company’s obligations under any such executory contract or unexpired lease with the Debtors is qualified by any overriding rights the Company has under the Bankruptcy Code. Further, nothing herein is or shall be deemed an admission with respect to any claim amounts or calculations arising from the assumption, assumption and assignment or rejection of any executory contract or unexpired lease and the Debtors expressly preserve all of their rights with respect thereto.
Given the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the retail and broader markets, the ongoing weakness of the credit markets, the Operating Partnership’s default of certain restrictive covenants, the acceleration of the senior secured credit facility and the filing of the Chapter 11 Cases, we believe that there is substantial doubt that we will continue to operate as a going concern within one year after the date our condensed consolidated financial statements for the quarter ended September 30, 2020 are issued. See “Note 1 – Organization and Basis of Presentation” to the condensed consolidated financial statements for additional information.
RESULTS OF OPERATIONS
Properties that were in operation for the entire year during 2019 and the nine months ended September 30, 2020 are referred to as the “Comparable Properties.” Since January 1, 2019, we have opened one self-storage facility, deconsolidated three outlet centers and disposed of eleven properties:
Properties Opened
| Property | Location | Date Opened |
|---|---|---|
| Mid Rivers Mall – CubeSmart Self-storage (1) | St. Peters, MO | January 2019 |
(1) This property is owned by a 50/50 joint venture that is accounted for using the equity method of accounting and is included in equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates in the accompanying condensed consolidated statements of operations.
Deconsolidations
| Property | Location | Date of Deconsolidation |
|---|---|---|
| The Outlet Shoppes at Atlanta (1) | Woodstock, GA | December 2019 |
| The Outlet Shoppes at El Paso (1) | El Paso, TX | August 2019 |
| The Outlet Shoppes of the Bluegrass (1) | Simpsonville, KY | November 2019 |
(1) This property is owned by a joint venture that is accounted for using the equity method of accounting and is included in equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates in the accompanying condensed consolidated statements of operations from the date of deconsolidation.
Dispositions
| Property | Location | Sales Date |
|---|---|---|
| 850 Greenbrier Circle | Chesapeake, VA | July 2019 |
| Acadiana Mall | Lafayette, LA | January 2019 |
| Barnes & Noble parcel | High Point, NC | July 2019 |
| Cary Towne Center | Cary, NC | January 2019 |
| Courtyard by Marriott at Pearland Town Center | Pearland, TX | June 2019 |
| Dick’s Sporting Goods at Hanes Mall | Winston-Salem, NC | September 2019 |
| The Forum at Grandview | Madison, MS | July 2019 |
| Honey Creek Mall | Terre Haute, IN | April 2019 |
| Kroger at Foothills Plaza | Maryville, TN | July 2019 |
| The Shoppes at Hickory Point | Forsyth, IL | April 2019 |
| Hickory Point Mall | Forsyth, IL | August 2020 |
Non-core properties are defined as Excluded Malls - see definition that follows under "Operational Review."
Comparison of the Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 to the Three Months Ended September 30, 2019
Revenues
| Total for the Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Change | Comparable Properties Core | Non-core | Deconsolidation | Dispositions | Total Change | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rental revenues | $124,081 | $180,616 | $(56,535) | $(42,009) | $(3,946) | $(9,387) | $(1,193) | $(56,535) |
| Management, development and leasing fees | 2,104 | 2,216 | (112) | (112) | — | — | — | (112) |
| Other | 3,712 | 4,419 | (707) | (547) | (25) | (46) | (89) | (707) |
| Total revenues | $129,897 | $187,251 | $(57,354) | $(42,668) | $(3,971) | $(9,433) | $(1,282) | $(57,354) |
Rental revenues from the Comparable Properties declined due to (i) store closures and rent concessions that were in effect prior to the COVID-19 pandemic for tenants with high occupancy cost levels and tenants that closed in 2019 due to bankruptcy and (ii) rent concessions to tenants that are in bankruptcy or are struggling financially due to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, including $12.5 million of rent abatements on past due rents and $12.3 million in uncollectible revenues for past due rents. Percentage rent declined $1.1 million as a result of store closures and lower retail sales due to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on traffic and sales.
Operating Expenses
| Total for the Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Change | Comparable Properties Core | Non-core | Deconsolidation | Dispositions | Total Change | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Property operating | $(20,396) | $(27,344) | $(6,948) | $(4,009) | $(225) | $(2,437) | $(277) | $(6,948) |
| Real estate taxes | (17,215) | (18,699) | (1,484) | (859) | (92) | (377) | (156) | (1,484) |
| Maintenance and repairs | (8,425) | (10,253) | (1,828) | (1,182) | (167) | (386) | (93) | (1,828) |
| Property operating expenses | (46,036) | (56,296) | (10,260) | (6,050) | (484) | (3,200) | (526) | (10,260) |
| Depreciation and amortization | (53,477) | (64,168) | (10,691) | (6,026) | (1,534) | (2,918) | (213) | (10,691) |
| General and administrative | (25,497) | (12,467) | 13,030 | 13,134 | (104) | — | — | 13,030 |
| Loss on impairment | (46) | (135,688) | (135,642) | (135,642) | — | — | — | (135,642) |
| Litigation settlement | 2,480 | 22,688 | 20,208 | 20,208 | — | — | — | 20,208 |
| Other | — | (7) | (7) | (7) | — | — | — | (7) |
| Total operating expenses | $(122,576) | $(245,938) | $(123,362) | $(114,383) | $(2,122) | $(6,118) | $(739) | $(123,362) |
Property operating expenses at the Comparable Properties decreased primarily due to the implementation of comprehensive programs to reduce operating expenses to mitigate the impact of mandated property closures and the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, including salary reductions, furloughs, a reduction-in-force and other operating expense initiatives.
The decrease in depreciation and amortization expense related to the Comparable Properties primarily relates to a lower basis in depreciable assets resulting from impairments recorded since the prior year period and a greater amount of tenant improvement write-offs in the prior year period related to tenants that closed as a result of bankruptcy.
General and administrative expenses increased primarily due to $13.0 million of costs related to the Company’s negotiations to restructure its corporate-level debt, which was partially offset by the implementation of comprehensive programs to reduce expenses, including salary reductions, furloughs, a reduction-in-force and other general and administrative expenses.
In the third quarter of 2019, we recognized $135.6 million of loss on impairment of real estate to write down the book value of two malls. See Note 5 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for more information.
Other Income and Expenses
Interest and other income increased $0.6 million compared to the prior-year period primarily due to interest income related to the U.S. Treasury securities that we invested in using a portion of the $280 million we drew on our secured line of credit in March 2020 to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility in light of the uncertainty surrounding the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. This was partially offset by a decrease in interest income due to several mortgage and other notes receivable being retired since the prior year period.
Interest expense increased $10.6 million due to an increase of $12.1 million primarily related to (i) a higher outstanding balance on the secured line of credit as a result of the $280 million we drew in March 2020 to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility and (ii) the accrual of additional interest on the secured credit facility at a higher interest rate imposed as a result of notices of default received from the administrative agent. Additionally, we accrued $2.5 million of default interest expense related to property-level nonrecourse loans that are in default. These increases were mostly offset by a $4.8 million decrease in property-level interest expense related to the deconsolidation of three encumbered properties since the prior-year period and the impact of the continued amortization of the secured term loan and non-recourse property-level loans.
During the nine months ended September 30, 2020, we recorded a $15.4 million gain on extinguishment of debt related to one mall. We transferred Hickory Point Mall to the lender in satisfaction of the non-recourse debt secured by that property.
During the three months ended September 30, 2019, we recognized $8.1 million of gain on sales of real estate assets primarily related to the sale of a community center, an office building and five outparcels.
Equity in losses of unconsolidated affiliates increased by $5.6 million during the three months ended September 30, 2020 compared to the prior-year period. The increase is primarily due to the additional amortization of our inside/outside basis difference related to the three properties that were deconsolidated since the end of the prior year period as well as lower earnings of our unconsolidated affiliates due to the mandated property closures and an increase in estimates of uncollectible rental revenues and abatements of rent.
Comparison of the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 to the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2019
Revenues
| Total for the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Change | Comparable Properties Core | Non-core | Deconsolidation | Dispositions | Total Change | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rental revenues | $405,476 | $556,989 | $(151,513) | $(98,761) | $(11,585) | $(30,619) | $(10,548) | $(151,513) |
| Management, development and leasing fees | 5,251 | 7,325 | (2,074) | (2,074) | — | — | — | (2,074) |
| Other | 10,955 | 14,344 | (3,389) | (2,504) | (176) | (348) | (361) | (3,389) |
| Total revenues | $421,682 | $578,658 | $(156,976) | $(103,339) | $(11,761) | $(30,967) | $(10,909) | $(156,976) |
Rental revenues from the Comparable Properties declined due to (i) store closures and rent concessions that were in effect prior to the COVID-19 pandemic for tenants with high occupancy cost levels and tenants that closed in 2019 due to bankruptcy and (ii) rent concessions to tenants that are in bankruptcy or are struggling financially due to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, including $14.1 million of rent abatements and $47.7 million in uncollectible revenues for past due rents. Percentage rent declined $2.9 million as a result of store closures and lower retail sales due to mandated property closures.
Operating Expenses
| Total for the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Change | Comparable Properties Core | Non-core | Deconsolidation | Dispositions | Total Change | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Property operating | $(63,011) | $(82,856) | $(19,845) | $(8,368) | $(1,378) | $(7,473) | $(2,626) | $(19,845) |
| Real estate taxes | (53,500) | (57,766) | (4,266) | (941) | (93) | (2,265) | (967) | (4,266) |
| Maintenance and repairs | (25,675) | (34,327) | (8,652) | (5,644) | (987) | (892) | (1,129) | (8,652) |
| Property operating expenses | (142,186) | (174,949) | (32,763) | (14,953) | (2,458) | (10,630) | (4,722) | (32,763) |
| Depreciation and amortization | (162,042) | (198,438) | (36,396) | (19,006) | (4,958) | (10,113) | (2,319) | (36,396) |
| General and administrative | (62,060) | (48,901) | 13,159 | 13,264 | (105) | — | — | 13,159 |
| Loss on impairment | (146,964) | (202,121) | (55,157) | (29,023) | (16,200) | — | (9,934) | (55,157) |
| Litigation settlement | 2,480 | (65,462) | (67,942) | (67,942) | — | — | — | (67,942) |
| Other | (400) | (41) | 359 | 359 | — | — | — | 359 |
| Total operating expenses | $(511,172) | $(689,912) | $(178,740) | $(117,301) | $(23,721) | $(20,743) | $(16,975) | $(178,740) |
Property operating expenses at the Comparable Properties decreased primarily due to the implementation of comprehensive programs to reduce operating expenses to mitigate the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, including salary reductions, furloughs, reductions-in-force and other operating expense initiatives.
The decrease in depreciation and amortization expense related to the Comparable Properties primarily relates to a lower basis in depreciable assets resulting from impairments recorded since the prior year period, as well as a higher amount of write-offs of tenant improvements and intangible lease assets related to store closings in the prior year period.
General and administrative expenses increased due to $13.0 million of costs related to the Company’s negotiations to restructure its corporate-level debt, partially offset by the implementation of comprehensive programs to reduce expenses, including salary reductions, furloughs and a reduction-in-force, as well higher legal expenses in the prior year period related to the litigation settlement and the new secured credit facility.
For the nine months ended September 30, 2020, we recognized $147.0 million of loss on impairment of real estate to write down the book value of three malls. For the nine months ended September 30, 2019, we recognized $202.1 million of loss on impairment of real estate to write down the book value of five malls and one community center. See Note 5 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for more information.
During the nine months ended September 30, 2019, we recognized $65.5 million of litigation settlement expense related to the settlement of a class action lawsuit. During the nine months ended September 30, 2020, we recognized a reduction of the litigation settlement expense of $2.5 million related to amounts we were released from pursuant to the terms of the settlement agreement. See Note 12 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for more information.
Other Income and Expenses
Interest and other income increased $3.0 million during the nine months ended September 30, 2020 compared to the prior-year period primarily due to additional interest income received related to the U.S. Treasury securities that we invested in using a portion of the $280 million we drew on our secured line of credit in March 2020 to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility in light of the uncertainty surrounding the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Interest expense increased $3.8 million compared to the prior-year period. The increase was primarily from an increase of $12.4 million due to (i) a higher outstanding balance on the secured line of credit as a result of the $280 million we drew in March 2020 to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility and (ii) the accrual of additional interest on the secured credit facility at a higher interest rate imposed as a result of notices of default received from the administrative agent. Additionally, we accrued $5.4 million of default interest expense related to property-level nonrecourse loans that are in default. This increase was partially offset by a $15.7 million decrease in property-level interest expense from the deconsolidation of three encumbered properties since the prior-year period, the continued amortization of the corporate term loan and non-recourse property-level loans and the retirement of three property-level loans.
During the nine months ended September 30, 2020, we recorded a $15.4 million gain on extinguishment of debt related to one mall. We transferred Hickory Point Mall to the lender in satisfaction of the non-recourse debt secured by that property. During the nine months ended September 30, 2019, we recorded $71.7 million of gain on extinguishment of debt related to two malls. We transferred Acadiana Mall to the lender in satisfaction of the non-recourse debt secured by the property. We sold Cary Towne Center and used the net proceeds from the sale to satisfy a portion of the non-recourse loan that secured the property. The remaining principal balance was forgiven.
Equity in earnings of unconsolidated affiliates decreased by $15.9 million during the nine months ended September 30, 2020 compared to the prior-year period. The decrease was primarily due to an increase in the amortization of our inside/outside basis difference related to the three properties that were deconsolidated since the end of the prior year period as well as lower earnings of our unconsolidated affiliates due to the mandated property closures and an increase in estimates of uncollectible rental revenues and abatements of rent.
Non-GAAP Measure
Same-center Net Operating Income
NOI is a supplemental non-GAAP measure of the operating performance of our shopping centers and other properties. We define NOI as property operating revenues (rental revenues and other income) less property operating expenses (property operating, real estate taxes and maintenance and repairs).
We compute NOI based on the Operating Partnership's pro rata share of both consolidated and unconsolidated properties. We believe that presenting NOI and same-center NOI (described below) based on our Operating Partnership’s pro rata share of both consolidated and unconsolidated properties is useful since we conduct substantially all of our business through our Operating Partnership and, therefore, it reflects the performance of the properties in absolute terms regardless of the ratio of ownership interests of our common shareholders and the noncontrolling interest in the Operating Partnership. Our definition of NOI may be different than that used by other companies, and accordingly, our calculation of NOI may not be comparable to that of other companies.
Since NOI includes only those revenues and expenses related to the operations of our shopping center properties, we believe that same-center NOI provides a measure that reflects trends in occupancy rates, rental rates, sales at the malls and operating costs and the impact of those trends on our results of operations. Our calculation of same-center NOI excludes lease termination income, straight-line rent adjustments, amortization of above and below market lease intangibles and write-offs of landlord inducement assets in order to enhance the comparability of results from one period to another.
We include a property in our same-center pool when we have owned all or a portion of the property since January 1 of the preceding calendar year and it has been in operation for both the entire preceding calendar year and current year-to-date period. New properties are excluded from same-center NOI until they meet these criteria. Properties excluded from the same-center pool that would otherwise meet these criteria are properties which are being repositioned or properties where we are considering alternatives for repositioning and where we intend to renegotiate the terms of the debt secured by the related property or return the property to the lender. Asheville Mall, Burnsville Center, EastGate Mall, Greenbrier Mall and Park Plaza were classified as Lender Malls at September 30, 2020.
Due to the exclusions noted above, same-center NOI should only be used as a supplemental measure of our performance and not as an alternative to GAAP operating income (loss) or net income (loss). A reconciliation of our same-center NOI to net loss for the three- and nine-month periods ended September 30, 2020 and 2019 is as follows (in thousands):
| Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net loss | $(44,424) | $(92,034) | $(256,511) | $(168,531) |
| Adjustments: (1) | ||||
| Depreciation and amortization | 66,796 | 76,608 | 201,180 | 228,201 |
| Interest expense | 69,213 | 55,640 | 183,035 | 171,793 |
| Abandoned projects expense | — | 7 | 400 | 41 |
| (Gain) loss on sales of real estate assets | 55 | (8,056) | (2,708) | (14,438) |
| Gain on investment/deconsolidation | — | (11,174) | — | (11,174) |
| Gain on extinguishment of debt | (15,407) | — | (15,407) | (71,722) |
| Loss on impairment | 46 | 135,688 | 146,964 | 202,121 |
| Litigation settlement | (2,480) | (22,688) | (2,480) | 65,462 |
| Income tax provision | 546 | 1,670 | 17,189 | 2,622 |
| Lease termination fees | (1,722) | (848) | (3,375) | (2,938) |
| Straight-line rent and above- and below-market rent | 2,662 | (1,881) | 631 | (4,334) |
| Net (income) loss attributable to noncontrolling interests in other consolidated subsidiaries | 937 | (763) | 1,631 | (631) |
| General and administrative expenses | 25,497 | 12,467 | 62,060 | 48,901 |
| Management fees and non-property level revenues | (4,415) | (2,293) | (9,746) | (9,077) |
| Operating Partnership's share of property NOI | 97,304 | 142,343 | 322,863 | 436,296 |
| Non-comparable NOI | (5,909) | (10,845) | (19,120) | (38,137) |
| Total same-center NOI | $91,395 | $131,498 | $303,743 | $398,159 |
(1) Adjustments are based on our Operating Partnership's pro rata ownership share, including our share of unconsolidated affiliates and excluding noncontrolling interests' share of consolidated properties.
Same-center NOI decreased 30.5% for the three months ended September 30, 2020 as compared to the prior-year period. The $40.1 million decrease for the three months ended September 30, 2020 compared to the same period in 2019 primarily consisted of a $46.8 million decrease in revenues offset by a $6.9 million decline in operating expenses. Rental revenues declined $46.1 million during the quarter primarily related to (i) store closures and rent concessions that were in effect prior to the COVID-19 pandemic for tenants with high occupancy cost levels and tenants that closed in 2019 due to bankruptcy and (ii) rent concessions to tenants that are in bankruptcy or are struggling financially due to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, including $14.6 million of rent abatements on past due rents and $12.4 million in uncollectible revenues for past due rents.
Same-center NOI decreased 23.7% for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 as compared to the prior-year period. The $94.4 million decrease for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 compared to the same period in 2019 primarily consisted of a $112.4 million decrease in revenues offset by a $17.9 million decline in operating expenses. Rental revenues declined $110.1 million during the quarter primarily related to (i) store closures and rent concessions that were in effect prior to the COVID-19 pandemic for tenants with high occupancy cost levels and tenants that closed in 2019 due to bankruptcy and (ii) rent concessions to tenants that are in bankruptcy or are struggling financially due to the impacts of the
COVID-19 pandemic, including $16.9 million of rent abatements on past due rents and $52.4 million in uncollectible revenues for past due rents.
Operational Review
The shopping center business is, to some extent, seasonal in nature with tenants typically achieving the highest levels of sales during the fourth quarter due to the holiday season, which generally results in higher percentage rents in the fourth quarter. Additionally, the malls earn most of their rents from short-term tenants during the holiday period. Thus, occupancy levels and revenue production are generally the highest in the fourth quarter of each year. Results of operations realized in any one quarter may not be indicative of the results likely to be experienced over the course of the fiscal year.
In response to local and state mandated closures due to the COVID-19 pandemic, our entire portfolio, except for a few properties, closed. All of our mall properties have re-opened and we have implemented strict procedures and guidelines for our employees, tenants and property visitors based on CDC and other health agency recommendations.
The mandated closures resulted in nearly all of our tenants closing for a period of time and/or shortening operating hours. As a result, we have experienced an increased level of requests for rent deferrals, and abatements, as well as defaults on rent obligations. While, in general, we believe that the tenants have a clear contractual obligation to pay rent, we have been working with our tenants to address rent deferral and abatement requests. Based on completed or in process agreements with 25 of our top tenants, representing approximately 40% of total revenues for the second and third quarters of 2020, we anticipate collecting over 65% of related rent for the second quarter and over 81% for the third quarter, with the majority of the remainder expected to be deferred or abated. We remain in negotiations with tenants and are unable to predict the outcome of those discussions. As we finalize negotiations, rent collections as a percentage of billed cash-based rents have increased with certain past-due amounts being paid. As of the end of the third quarter, the April 2020 collection rate had improved from 27% to over 76% and May improved from 33% to 68%. We expect this trend to continue as we move later in the year and into 2021, and certain deferred rents begin coming due. As of early November 2020, we estimate that we will defer $25.3 million, at our share, of rents that were billed for April through September 2020. Substantially all of this amount is related to agreements that were executed as of September 30, 2020 with the remainder in active negotiation. Additionally, we granted rent abatements of approximately $13.1 million and $14.9 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively. We continue to assess rent relief requests from our tenants but are unable to predict the resolution or impact of these discussions.
Year-to-date, more than twelve national tenants have declared bankruptcy, including major tenants such as J.C. Penney, Ascena Retail Group, Stage Stores and GNC. As of September 30, 2020, J.C. Penney and Ascena Retail Group, Inc. represented $18.5 million in gross annual revenue and comprised 6.1 million square feet. The remaining ten tenants in bankruptcy represented approximately $22.3 million in gross annual revenue and comprised 1.1 million square feet. The majority of these have announced some store closures and some have liquidated, but several are expected to reorganize and continue to operate.
We classify our regional malls into three categories:
(1) Stabilized Malls – Malls that have completed their initial lease-up and have been open for more than three complete calendar years.
(2) Non-stabilized Malls - Malls that are in their initial lease-up phase. After three complete calendar years of operation, they are reclassified on January 1 of the fourth calendar year to the stabilized mall category. The Outlet Shoppes at Laredo was classified as a non-stabilized mall as of September 30, 2020 and 2019. The Outlet Shoppes at Laredo will be classified as a stabilized mall starting January 1, 2021.
(3) Excluded Malls - We exclude malls from our core portfolio if they fall in one of the following categories, for which operational metrics are excluded:
a. Lender Malls - Malls for which we are working or intend to work with the lender on a restructure of the terms of the loan secured by the property or convey the secured property to the lender. Asheville Mall, Burnsville Center, EastGate Mall, Greenbrier Mall and Park Plaza were classified as Lender Malls as of September 30, 2020, and Greenbrier Mall, and Hickory Point Mall were classified as Lender Malls as of September 30, 2019. Lender Malls are excluded from our same-center pool as decisions made while in discussions with the lender may lead to metrics that do not provide relevant information related to the condition of these properties.
b. Repositioning Malls - Malls that are currently being repositioned or where we have determined that the current format of the mall no longer represents the best use of the mall and we are in the process of evaluating alternative strategies for the mall. This may include major redevelopment or an alternative retail or non-retail format, or after evaluating alternative strategies for the mall, we may determine that the mall no longer meets our criteria for long-term investment. The steps taken to reposition these malls, such as signing tenants to short-term leases, which are not included in occupancy percentages, or leasing to regional or local tenants, which typically do not report sales, may lead to metrics which do not provide relevant information related to the condition of these malls. Therefore, traditional performance measures, such as occupancy percentages and leasing metrics, exclude Repositioning Malls. There were no malls classified as Repositioning Malls as of September 30, 2020 and September 30, 2019.
We derive the majority of our total revenues from the mall properties. The sources of our total revenues by property type were as follows:
| Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|
| Malls | 90.4% | 91.6% |
| Other Properties | 9.6% | 8.4% |
Mall Store Sales
Mall store sales include reporting mall tenants of 10,000 square feet or less for stabilized malls and exclude license agreements, which are retail contracts that are temporary or short-term in nature and generally last more than three months but less than twelve months. Due to temporary mall and store closures that occurred, the majority of CBL’s tenants did not report sales for the full reporting period. As a result, CBL is not able to provide a complete measure of sales per square foot for the trailing twelve months ended September 30, 2020. Stabilized mall same-center sales per square foot for the twelve months ended September 30, 2019 were $386.
Occupancy
Our portfolio occupancy is summarized in the following table (1):
| As of September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|
| Total portfolio | 86.8% | 90.5% |
| Malls: | ||
| Total Mall portfolio | 85.2% | 88.7% |
| Same-center Malls | 85.2% | 89.0% |
| Stabilized Malls | 85.4% | 88.8% |
| Non-stabilized Malls (2) | 74.4% | 83.8% |
| Other Properties: | ||
| Associated centers | 89.1% | 96.3% |
| Community centers | 94.4% | 96.3% |
(1) As noted above, excluded properties are not included in occupancy metrics. Occupancy for malls represents percentage of mall store gross leasable area occupied under 20,000 square feet. Occupancy for other properties represents percentage of gross leasable area occupied.
(2) Represents occupancy for The Outlet Shoppes at Laredo.
Leasing
Leasing activity for the quarter was muted as we continued our focus on negotiating with existing tenants. To-date we have completed or are finalizing negotiations with retailers representing the majority of our top tenants. These agreements generally include flexible terms primarily on second quarter and, in certain cases, third quarter rent to certain retailers that require assistance, while at the same time preserving current and future income.
The following is a summary of the total square feet of leases signed in the three- and nine-month periods ended September, 2020 and 2019:
| Operating portfolio: | Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New leases | 43,654 | 239,645 | 463,771 | 768,106 |
| Renewal leases | 553,848 | 472,636 | 1,276,343 | 1,626,014 |
| Development portfolio: | ||||
| New leases | — | 1,175 | 7,929 | 205,614 |
| Total leased | 597,502 | 713,456 | 1,748,043 | 2,599,734 |
Average annual base rents per square foot are based on contractual rents in effect as of September 30, 2020 and 2019, including the impact of any rent concessions. Average annual base rents per square foot for comparable small shop space of less than 10,000 square feet were as follows for each property type:
| Malls (1): | September 30, 2020 | 2019 |
|---|---|---|
| Same-center Stabilized Malls | $30.42 | $31.94 |
| Stabilized Malls | 30.49 | 32.05 |
| Non-stabilized Malls (2) | 24.89 | 24.12 |
| Other Properties (3): | 15.54 | 15.40 |
| Associated centers | 14.02 | 13.75 |
| Community centers | 16.78 | 16.99 |
| Office buildings | 19.14 | 18.87 |
(1) Excluded properties are not included.
(2) Represents average annual base rents for The Outlet Shoppes at Laredo.
(3) Average base rents for associated centers, community centers and office buildings include all leased space, regardless of size.
Results from new and renewal leasing of comparable small shop space of less than 10,000 square feet during the nine-month period ended September 30, 2020 for spaces that were previously occupied, based on the contractual terms of the related leases inclusive of the impact of any rent concessions, are as follows:
| Property Type Quarter: | Square Feet | Prior Gross Rent PSF | New Initial Gross Rent PSF | % Change Initial | New Average Gross Rent PSF (1) | % Change Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All Property Types (2) | 348,790 | $33.60 | $27.88 | (17.0)% | $28.29 | (15.8)% |
| Stabilized Malls | 297,079 | 34.81 | 29.06 | (16.5)% | 29.47 | (15.3)% |
| New leases | 16,919 | 44.07 | 39.86 | (9.6)% | 41.53 | (5.8)% |
| Renewal leases | 280,160 | 34.25 | 28.41 | (17.1)% | 28.74 | (16.1)% |
| Year-to-Date: | ||||||
| All Property Types (2) | 886,441 | $30.24 | $26.59 | (12.1)% | $27.03 | (10.6)% |
| Stabilized Malls | 793,168 | 30.68 | 27.10 | (11.7)% | 27.55 | (10.2)% |
| New leases | 68,613 | 28.70 | 32.00 | 11.5% | 33.51 | 16.8% |
| Renewal leases | 724,555 | 30.87 | 26.64 | (13.7)% | 26.99 | (12.6)% |
(1) Average gross rent does not incorporate allowable future increases for recoverable common area expenses.
(2) Includes stabilized malls, associated centers, community centers and office buildings.
New and renewal leasing activity of comparable small shop space of less than 10,000 square feet based on the lease commencement date is as follows:
| Commencement 2020: | Number of Leases | Square Feet | Term (in years) | Initial Rent PSF | Average Rent PSF | Expiring Rent PSF | Initial Rent Spread | Average Rent Spread | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New | 73 | 235,156 | 7.14 | $28.48 | $30.07 | $25.63 | $2.85 | 11.1% | $4.44 | 17.3% |
| Renewal | 355 | 1,156,701 | 2.58 | 25.33 | 26.24 | 30.37 | (5.04) | (16.6)% | (4.13) | (13.6)% |
| Commencement 2020 Total | 428 | 1,391,857 | 3.36 | 25.86 | 26.88 | 29.57 | (3.71) | (12.5)% | (2.69) | (9.1)% |
| Commencement 2021: | ||||||||||
| New | 8 | 23,594 | 9.22 | 36.82 | 38.89 | 32.09 | 4.73 | 14.7% | 6.80 | 21.2% |
| Renewal | 76 | 210,540 | 2.44 | 33.96 | 34.27 | 36.50 | (2.54) | (7.0)% | (2.23) | (6.1)% |
| Commencement 2021 Total | 84 | 234,134 | 3.09 | 34.25 | 34.73 | 36.06 | (1.81) | (5.0)% | (1.33) | (3.7)% |
| Total 2020/2021 | 512 | 1,625,991 | 3.31 | $27.07 | $28.01 | $30.50 | $(3.43) | (11.2)% | $(2.49) | (8.2)% |
LIQUIDITY AND CAPITAL RESOURCES
As of September 30, 2020, we had $258.6 million available in unrestricted cash and U.S. Treasury securities and we had $675.9 million outstanding on our secured credit facility. Our total pro rata share of debt at September 30, 2020 was $4.4 billion.
In February 2020, we utilized our secured credit facility to pay off two loans secured by Parkway Place and Valley View Mall totaling $84.5 million. Also, we closed on a new loan secured by The Outlet Shoppes at Atlanta – Phase II in the amount of $4.7 million, with an interest rate of LIBOR plus 2.5% and a maturity date of November 2023. Proceeds were used to retire the $4.4 million existing loan. In March 2020, we drew $280.0 million on our secured line of credit to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility in light of the uncertainty surrounding the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. We purchased $154.2 million, including accrued interest, of U.S. Treasury securities with a portion of the borrowings on our secured line of credit.
In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, we implemented comprehensive programs to halt all non-essential expenditures, to reduce operating and overhead expenses and to reduce, defer or suspend capital expenditures, including redevelopment investments. These programs include a temporary reduction of up to 50% to the compensation of our Chairman of the Board, our CEO and our President as well as independent director fees, a temporary reduction of up to 20% to the compensation of our other named executive officers, salary reductions to all staff, a broad-based furlough program, a permanent reduction in workforce and 2020 capital expenditure reductions or deferrals estimated in the range of $60.0 million to $80.0 million. While we have paused several major projects, we are pursuing capital lite solutions for backfilling our remaining available anchors, including joint venture partnerships, favorable lease structures and third-party arrangements – all of which benefit our portfolio while preserving capital. Additionally, we were able to achieve debt service payment deferrals for a portion of our secured loans. Securitized lenders in general have shown minimal flexibility in amending loan payments.
As discussed in “Note 15 – Subsequent Events” to the condensed consolidated financial statements, the Company elected to not make the $6.9 million interest payment due and payable on October 15, 2020, with respect to the Operating Partnership’s 4.60% senior unsecured notes due 2024 (the “2024 Notes”) (the “2024 Notes Interest Payment”). Under the indenture governing the 2024 Notes, the Operating Partnership has a 30-day grace period to make the 2024 Notes Interest Payment before the nonpayment is considered an “event of default” with respect to the 2024 Notes. Any event of default under the 2024 Notes for nonpayment of the 2024 Notes Interest Payment would also be considered an event of default under the Operating Partnership’s senior secured credit facility which could lead to an acceleration of amounts due under the facility; however, as discussed in Note 8 – Mortgage and Other Indebtedness, Net, obligations under the secured credit facility have been accelerated based on the events of default previously asserted by the administrative agent under the secured credit facility, which the Company continues to dispute. Further, if the trustee for the 2024 Notes should exercise its right to accelerate the maturity of the full balance owed on the 2024 Notes as a result of such an “event of default,” that would also constitute an “event of default” under the 2023 Notes and the 2026 Notes, which could lead to the acceleration of all amounts due under those notes.
See Liquidity and Going Concern Considerations in Note 1 – Organization and Basis of Presentation and Significant Bankruptcy Court Actions in Note 15 – Subsequent Events to the condensed consolidated financial statements and the section below titled Financial Covenants and Restrictions for information on the ongoing alleged defaults and events of defaults asserted by the administrative agent with respect to the secured credit facility and the Company’s adversarial proceeding in response to the notices from the administrative agent asserting rights and remedies and for information on the Company’s commencement of the Chapter 11 Cases.
We have addressed nearly all our major debt maturities for 2020 and are in discussions with existing lenders for certain 2021 secured loan maturities. We anticipate restructuring our unsecured debt maturities through the recent Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. The filing of the Chapter 11 Cases also constituted an event of default with respect to certain property-level debt of the Operating Partnership’s subsidiaries, which may result in automatic acceleration of the outstanding principal and accrued interest or may give the applicable lender the right to accelerate such amounts. See Note 7 – Unconsolidated Affiliates and Noncontrolling Interests and Note 8 – Mortgage and Other Indebtedness, Net for more information.
We derive the majority of our revenues from leases with retail tenants, which have historically been the primary source for funding short-term liquidity and capital needs such as operating expenses, debt service, tenant construction allowances, recurring capital expenditures, dividends and distributions. We believe that the combination of cash flows generated from our operations, combined with cash on hand and our investment in U.S. Treasury securities will, for the foreseeable future, provide adequate liquidity to meet our cash needs assuming we continue to operate as a going concern within twelve months of the date our condensed consolidated financial statements are issued. In addition to these factors, we have options available to us to generate additional liquidity, including but not limited to, joint venture investments and decreasing expenditures related to tenant construction allowances and other capital expenditures. We also generate revenues from sales of peripheral land at our properties and from sales of real estate assets when it is determined that we can realize an optimal value for the assets.
Cash Flows - Operating, Investing and Financing Activities
There was $141.2 million of cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash as of September 30, 2020, an increase of $82.1 million from December 31, 2019. Of this amount, $116.6 million was unrestricted cash and cash equivalents as of September 30, 2020. Also, at September 30, 2020, we had $151.8 million in U.S. Treasuries that are scheduled to mature between April 2021 and June 2021.
Our net cash flows are summarized as follows (in thousands):
| Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net cash provided by operating activities | $59,192 | $225,243 | $(166,051) |
| Net cash provided by (used in) investing activities | (201,504) | 55,870 | (257,374) |
| Net cash provided by (used in) financing activities | 224,486 | (275,369) | 499,855 |
| Net cash flows | $82,174 | $5,744 | $76,430 |
Cash Provided by Operating Activities
Cash provided by operating activities decreased $166.0 million primarily due to a decline in cash payments of rental revenues from tenants due to the closure of most of our malls for a period of time in response to government mandates that began in March. Operating cash flows have also been impacted by rent deferrals and abatements that have been granted to tenants experiencing financial difficulties due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Rental revenues also decreased due to store closures and rent concessions for tenants with high occupancy cost levels, including tenants that closed in 2019 and 2020 due to bankruptcy prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as a decline in rental revenues related to dispositions.
Cash Provided by (Used in) Investing Activities
Net cash used in investing activities for 2020 was primarily related to the purchase of U.S. Treasury securities for $153.2 million using a portion of the $280.0 million that we drew on our secured line of credit. We also expended $47.8 million on additions to real estate assets, primarily related to redevelopment projects. Net cash provided by investing activities in the prior year period related to $128.4 million of proceeds from dispositions of properties, which was partially offset by $90.4 million of additions to real estate assets.
Cash Provided by (Used in) Financing Activities
The net cash inflow for 2020 is primarily due to the $280.0 million draw on our secured credit facility in order to increase liquidity and preserve financial flexibility in light of the uncertainty surrounding the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Additionally, there were no common or preferred stock dividends paid for the nine months ended September 30, 2020, as compared to $26.0 million in dividends paid to holders of common stock and $33.7 million in dividends paid to holders of preferred stock during the nine months ended September 30, 2019.
Debt
Debt of the Company
CBL has no indebtedness. Either the Operating Partnership or one of its consolidated subsidiaries, that it has a direct or indirect ownership interest in, is the borrower on all of our debt. CBL is a limited guarantor of the Notes, as described in Note 8 to the condensed consolidated financial statements, for losses suffered solely by reason of fraud or willful misrepresentation by the Operating Partnership or its affiliates. We also provide a similar limited guarantee of the Operating Partnership's obligations with respect to our secured credit facility as of September 30, 2020.
Debt of the Operating Partnership
The following tables summarize debt based on our pro rata ownership share, including our pro rata share of unconsolidated affiliates and excluding noncontrolling investors’ share of consolidated properties, because we believe this provides investors and lenders a clearer understanding of our total debt obligations and liquidity (in thousands):
| September 30, 2020: Fixed-rate debt: | Consolidated | Noncontrolling Interests | Unconsolidated Affiliates | Total | Weighted- Average Interest Rate (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-recourse loans on operating Properties (2) | $1,193,997 | $(30,275) | $616,446 | $1,780,168 | 4.79% |
| Recourse loans on operating Properties (3) | — | — | 9,360 | 9,360 | 3.74% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2023 (4) | 448,265 | — | — | 448,265 | 5.25% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2024 (5) | 299,966 | — | — | 299,966 | 4.60% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2026 (6) | 618,136 | — | — | 618,136 | 5.95% |
| Total fixed-rate debt | 2,560,364 | (30,275) | 625,806 | 3,155,895 | 5.06% |
| Variable-rate debt: | |||||
| Recourse loans on operating Properties | 68,511 | — | 104,622 | 173,133 | 2.82% |
| Construction loans | — | — | 17,864 | 17,864 | 2.52% |
| Secured line of credit (7) | 675,925 | — | — | 675,925 | 9.50% |
| Secured term loan (7) | 438,750 | — | — | 438,750 | 9.50% |
| Total variable-rate debt | 1,183,186 | — | 122,486 | 1,305,672 | 8.52% |
| Total fixed-rate and variable-rate debt | 3,743,550 | (30,275) | 748,292 | 4,461,567 | 6.07% |
| Unamortized deferred financing costs | (13,864) | 288 | (2,594) | (16,170) | |
| Total mortgage and other indebtedness, net | $3,729,686 | $(29,987) | $745,698 | $4,445,397 |
58
| December 31, 2019: Fixed-rate debt: | Consolidated | Noncontrolling Interests | Unconsolidated Affiliates | Total | Weighted- Average Interest Rate (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-recourse loans on operating Properties (2) | $1,330,561 | $(30,658) | $623,193 | $1,923,096 | 4.88% |
| Recourse loans on operating Properties (3) | — | — | 10,050 | 10,050 | 3.74% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2023 (4) | 447,894 | — | — | 447,894 | 5.25% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2024 (5) | 299,960 | — | — | 299,960 | 4.60% |
| Senior unsecured notes due 2026 (6) | 617,473 | — | — | 617,473 | 5.95% |
| Total fixed-rate debt | 2,695,888 | (30,658) | 633,243 | 3,298,473 | 5.10% |
| Variable-rate debt: | |||||
| Recourse loans on operating Properties | 41,950 | — | 69,046 | 110,996 | 4.13% |
| Construction loans | 29,400 | — | 35,362 | 64,762 | 4.45% |
| Secured line of credit | 310,925 | — | — | 310,925 | 3.94% |
| Secured term loan | 465,000 | — | — | 465,000 | 3.94% |
| Total variable-rate debt | 847,275 | — | 104,408 | 951,683 | 4.00% |
| Total fixed-rate and variable-rate debt | 3,543,163 | (30,658) | 737,651 | 4,250,156 | 4.86% |
| Unamortized deferred financing costs | (16,148) | 318 | (2,851) | (18,681) | |
| Total mortgage and other indebtedness, net | $3,527,015 | $(30,340) | $734,800 | $4,231,475 |
(1) Weighted-average interest rate includes the effect of debt premiums and discounts but excludes amortization of deferred financing costs.
(2) An unconsolidated affiliate has an interest rate swap on a notional amount outstanding of $42,982 as of September 30, 2020 and $43,623 as of December 31, 2019 related to a variable-rate loan on Ambassador Town Center to effectively fix the interest rate on this loan to a fixed-rate of 3.22%.
(3) The unconsolidated affiliate has an interest rate swap on a notional amount outstanding of $9,360 as of September 30, 2020 and $10,050 as of December 31, 2019 related to a variable-rate loan on Ambassador Town Center - Infrastructure Improvements to effectively fix the interest rate on this loan to a fixed-rate of 3.74%.
(4) The balance is net of an unamortized discount of $1,736 and $2,106 as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively.
(5) The balance is net of an unamortized discount of $34 and $40 as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively.
(6) The balance is net of an unamortized discount of $6,864 and $7,527 as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively.
(7) The administrative agent informed the Company that interest will accrue on all outstanding obligations at the post-default rate, which is equal to the rate that otherwise would be in effect plus 5.0%. The post-default interest rate at September 30, 2020 was 9.50%. The variable interest rate at LIBOR based on original terms of senior secured facility is 2.41% as of September 30, 2020.
The weighted-average remaining term of our total share of consolidated and unconsolidated debt was 3.3 years and 3.9 years at September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively. The weighted-average remaining term of our pro rata share of fixed-rate debt was 3.5 and 4.1 years at September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively.
As of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, our pro rata share of consolidated and unconsolidated variable-rate debt represented 29.4% and 22.5%, respectively, of our total pro rata share of debt.
See Note 7 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for information concerning activity related to unconsolidated affiliates.
Credit Ratings
During the quarter ended June 30, 2020, Fitch Ratings, Moody’s Investors Service and S&P Global Ratings terminated their coverage of the Operating Partnership's unsecured long-term indebtedness.
Senior Unsecured Notes
The following presents the Company's compliance with key covenant ratios, as defined, of the Notes and the senior secured credit facility as of September 30, 2020:
| Debt Covenant Compliance Ratios (1) | Required | Actual |
|---|---|---|
| Total debt to total assets | < 60% | 56% |
| Secured debt to total assets | < 40% | 36% |
| Total unencumbered assets to unsecured debt | > 150% | 190% |
| Consolidated income available for debt service to annual debt service charge | > 1.5x | 1.8 x |
| Minimum debt yield on outstanding balance (2) | > 10% | 9.7% |
59
(1) The debt covenant compliance ratios for the secured line of credit, the secured term loan and the senior unsecured notes are defined and computed on the same basis.
(2) The minimum debt yield on outstanding balance debt covenant compliance ratio only applies to the secured credit facility. As of September 30, 2020, the lenders under the secured credit facility had declared all outstanding obligations to be immediately due and payable due to asserted defaults and events of default under the secured credit facility. Additionally, on November 1, 2020, we commenced the Chapter 11 Cases by filing voluntary petitions for reorganization under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, which is an event of default under the secured credit facility.
Issuer and Guarantor Subsidiaries of Guaranteed Securities
In March 2020, the SEC issued Rule Release No. 33-10762, Financial Disclosures About Guarantors and Issuers of Guaranteed Securities and Affiliates Whose Securities Collateralize a Registrant’s Securities ("Release 33-10762”). Release 33-10762 simplifies the disclosure requirements related to certain registered securities under Rules 3-10 and 3-16 of SEC Regulation S-X, permitting registrants to provide certain alternative financial disclosures and non-financial disclosures in lieu of separate consolidating financial statements for subsidiary issuers and guarantors of registered debt securities if certain conditions are met. The amendments in Release 33-10762 are generally effective for filings on or after January 4, 2021, with early application permitted. We adopted the new disclosure requirements permitted under Release 33-10762 effective for the period as of and for the nine months ended September 30, 2020.
The Operating Partnership’s senior secured credit facility is secured by 17 malls and 3 associated centers that are directly or indirectly owned by 36 wholly owned subsidiaries of the Operating Partnership (the “Guarantor Subsidiaries”). The Guarantor Subsidiaries own an additional four malls, two associated centers and four mortgage notes receivable that are not collateral for the secured credit facility. The Guarantor Subsidiaries also entered into agreements to guarantee the Operating Partnership’s obligations under the senior secured credit facility.
Based on the terms of the Notes, to the extent that any subsidiary of the Operating Partnership executes and delivers a guarantee to another debt facility, the Operating Partnership shall also cause the subsidiary to guarantee the Operating Partnership’s obligations under the Notes on a senior basis. In connection with entering the guarantee agreements related to the senior secured credit facility, the Guarantor Subsidiaries entered a guarantee agreement with the issuer of the Notes to satisfy the guaranty requirement.
The guarantees of the Guarantor Subsidiaries are joint and several and full and unconditional. The guarantees are unsecured and effectively subordinated to any existing and future secured debt that a Guarantor Subsidiary may have to the extent of the value of the assets securing such debt. Each Guarantor Property’s obligation will remain until the earlier of such time as (i) all guaranteed obligations have been paid in full in cash and each guaranteed obligation has been terminated or cancelled in accordance with its terms or (ii) any such Guarantor Subsidiary ceases to be a guarantor under the senior secured credit facility. The Guarantor Subsidiaries’ maximum guarantee related to the secured credit facility is $1,114.7 million as of September 30, 2020, and the maximum guarantee related to the Notes is $1,375.0 million as of September 30, 2020.
The following tables present summarized financial information for the Operating Partnership and the Guarantor Subsidiaries on a combined basis. The summarized financial information does not include the Operating Partnership’s investments in non-guarantor subsidiaries nor the earnings from non-guarantor subsidiaries. Intercompany transactions between the Operating Partnership and the Guarantor Subsidiaries have been eliminated. The summarized balance sheet information is as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019 and the summarized statement of operations information is for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 and the year ended December 31, 2019. Amounts are presented in thousands.
| September 30, 2020 | December 31, 2019 | |
|---|---|---|
| Net investment in real estate assets | $1,456,142 | $1,505,668 |
| Total assets (1) | 1,651,465 | 1,696,190 |
| Total liabilities (2) | 2,846,991 | 2,503,005 |
| Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | Year Ended December 31, 2019 | |
| Total revenues (3) | $167,917 | $292,540 |
| Total expenses (4) | 288,842 | 476,202 |
| Net loss | (119,132) | (117,325) |
60
(1) Total assets include an intercompany note receivable with a non-guarantor subsidiary of $4,002 and $4,194 as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively
(2) Total liabilities include intercompany liabilities of $2,781 as of September 30, 2020
(3) Total revenues include revenues derived from non-guarantor subsidiaries of $160 and $1,255 for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 and the year ended December 31, 2019, respectively.
(4) Total expenses include expenses incurred with non-guarantor subsidiaries of $24,468 and $16,749 for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 and the year ended December 31, 2019, respectively.
Financial Covenants and Restrictions
As discussed in “Note 8 – Mortgage and Other Indebtedness, Net” to the condensed consolidated financial statements, we elected not to make the 2023 Notes Interest Payment and the 2026 Notes Interest Payment. The Operating Partnership did not make either the 2023 Notes Interest Payment or the 2026 Notes Interest Payment by the last day of the respective 30-day grace periods provided for in the indenture governing the 2023 Notes and the 2026 Notes. The Operating Partnership’s failure to make the 2023 Notes Interest Payment and the 2026 Notes Interest Payment during the applicable grace periods constituted an “event of default” with respect to each of the 2023 Notes and the 2026 Notes.
On August 5, 2020, we made the 2023 Notes Interest Payment to the holders of the 2023 Notes and the 2026 Notes Interest Payment to the holders of the 2026 Notes. Accordingly, from and after such payment, the nonpayment of each of the 2023 Notes Interest Payment and the 2026 Notes Interest Payment no longer constitutes (i) an “event of default” under the indenture governing the 2023 Notes and the 2026 Notes that occurred and is continuing or (ii) to the extent provided in the Bank Forbearance Agreement, an “event of default” under the secured credit facility.
On each of May 26, 2020, June 2, 2020, June 16, 2020, August 6, 2020 and August 19, 2020, the Operating Partnership received notices of default and reservation of rights letters from the administrative agent under the secured credit facility, which asserted that certain defaults and events of default occurred and continue to exist by reason of the Operating Partnership’s failure to comply with certain restrictive covenants under the secured credit facility and resulting from the failure to make the 2023 Notes Interest Payment and the 2026 Notes Interest Payment prior to the expiration of the applicable grace periods. On August 6, 2020, the Operating Partnership received a notice of imposition of base rate and post-default rate letter from the Agent, which (i) informed the Operating Partnership that following an asserted event of default on March 19, 2020, all outstanding loans were converted to base loans at the expiration of the applicable interest periods and (ii) sought payment of approximately $4.8 million related thereto for April through June 2020 (the “Demand Interest”). The base rate is defined as the highest of (i) the prime rate, (ii) the federal funds rate plus 0.50% and (iii) the LIBOR Market Index Rate plus 1.0%, plus 1.25%. The base rate on September 30, 2020 was 4.50% based on the prime rate plus 1.25%. The administrative agent also informed the Operating Partnership that from and after August 6, 2020, interest will accrue on all outstanding obligations at the post-default rate, which is equal to the rate that otherwise would be in effect plus 5.0%. The post-default interest rate at the time of notification and at September 30, 2020 was 9.50%. On August 19, 2020, the Operating Partnership received from the administrative agent (i) a notice of default and reservation of rights letter, which asserted that each of the failure to pay the Demand Interest and the entry into the RSA constituted events of default under the terms of the secured credit facility and (ii) a notice of acceleration of obligations under the secured credit facility based on the events of default previously asserted by the administrative agent, pursuant to which, the administrative agent declared all outstanding principal, interest accruing at the base rate and the post-default rate, which as previously disclosed are rates being disputed by the Company, and letters of credit to be immediately due and payable. The administrative agent also terminated the revolving and swingline commitments and the obligation to issue letters of credit under the secured credit facility and instructed the Operating Partnership to deliver approximately $1.3 million in cash to collateralize outstanding letters of credit.
On August 25, 2020, The Operating Partnership received a notice of imposition of base rate letter from the administrative agent under the secured credit facility, which informed the Operating Partnership that following an asserted event of default, that all outstanding loans converted to base rate loans beginning July 1, 2019 and (ii) sought payment of approximately $12.0 million related thereto for July 1, 2019 through March 30, 2020. Additionally, the Operating Partnership failed to meet the minimum debt yield covenant under the secured credit facility as of September 30, 2020.
As of the date of this report, the lenders under the secured credit facility have not commenced foreclosure proceedings, but they may seek to exercise such remedies in the future. In addition, as a result of the events of default asserted by the administrative agent in such letters, the administrative agent may deny the Operating Partnership’s request for future LIBOR interest periods, which would result in an increase in annual interest expense of approximately $19.3 million based on the base rate and $74.4 million based on the post-default rate.
On October 16, 2020, the Company received an additional notice of default and reservation of rights letter from the Agent which asserted that certain defaults exist and continue to exist by reason of the Operating Partnership’s failure to comply with certain restrictive covenants in the Credit Agreement and resulting from the failure to make the $6.9 million interest payment that was due and payable on October 15, 2020, to holders of the 2024 Notes and that such default will constitute an event of default under the Credit Agreement if such interest is not paid within the 30-day grace period. On
October 28, 2020, the Operating Partnership was notified by the administrative agent and lenders that they elected to exercise their rights pursuant to the terms of the secured credit facility to (i) require that rents payable by tenants at the properties that are collateral to the secured credit facility be paid directly to the administrative agent and (ii) exercise all voting rights and other ownership rights in respect of all the equity interests in the subsidiaries of the Operating Partnership that are guarantors of the secured credit facility.
Notwithstanding these actions by the administrative agent, the Company intends to continue to operate its business, retain legal ownership of the entities pledged under the collateral agreement and the pledge agreement and manage its properties. The Company contends that the actions taken by the administrative agent are unauthorized and unlawful and the Company continues to disagree with the assertions made by the administrative agent as to the basis for the notice of acceleration and the notice of exercise and, accordingly, the validity of the notice of acceleration and the notice of exercise. The Company is vigorously defending against the claims made by the administrative agent and the lenders. Among other things, the Company, in good faith, disputes that any breaches of the agreement to the secured credit facility or any events of default thereunder that were the subject of the prior notices have occurred and are continuing. On November 2, 2020, the Company filed an adversary proceeding in the Bankruptcy Court seeking among other things, a Temporary Restraining Order (the “Order”) and for a Preliminary Injunction to enjoin, pending a determination of the parties’ rights, the administrative agent or any of its officers, agents, servants, attorneys and successors from taking any action to exercise any and all remedies under the agreement to the secured credit facility or other agreements as a result of the events of default asserted by the administrative agent, or any other right or remedy that would otherwise accompany the occurrence of an event of default, including without limitation, any rights of acceleration under the agreement to the secured credit facility, rights flowing from the notice of acceleration, rights exercised pursuant to the notice of exercise or any other rights or remedies properly exercisable solely upon an actual or determined event of default. On the November 2, 2020, the Bankruptcy Court granted the Order and the Company and the administrative agent are negotiating the terms of a standstill pending further determination by the Bankruptcy Court. See Note 1 – Organization and Basis of Presentation to the condensed consolidated financial statements for additional information.
Unencumbered Consolidated Portfolio Statistics
(Dollars in thousands, except sales per square foot data)
| Sales Per Square Foot for the Twelve Months Ended (1) (2) | Occupancy (2) | % of Consolidated Unencumbered NOI for the Nine Months Ended | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9/30/20 | (3) | 9/30/19 | 9/30/20 | 9/30/19 | 9/30/20 | (4) | |
| Unencumbered consolidated Properties: | |||||||
| Tier 1 Malls | $382 | 86.9% | 85.9% | 19.8% | (5) | ||
| Tier 2 Malls | 338 | 82.0% | 85.7% | 33.7% | |||
| Tier 3 Malls | 279 | 80.0% | 87.0% | 23.3% | |||
| Total Malls | N/A | 309 | 81.9% | 86.3% | 76.8% | ||
| Total Associated Centers | N/A | N/A | 85.8% | 95.7% | 16.8% | ||
| Total Community Centers | N/A | N/A | 98.4% | 97.3% | 5.7% | ||
| Total Office Buildings & Other | N/A | N/A | 100.0% | 86.7% | 0.7% | ||
| Total Unencumbered Consolidated Portfolio | N/A | $309 | 83.5% | 88.9% | 100.0% |
(1) Represents same-center sales per square foot for mall tenants 10,000 square feet or less for stabilized malls.
(2) Operating metrics are included for unencumbered operating properties and do not include sales or occupancy of unencumbered parcels.
(3) Due to temporary mall and store closures that occurred, the majority of CBL’s tenants did not report sales for the full reporting period. As a result, CBL is not able to provide a complete measure of sales per square foot for the quarter or trailing twelve months.
(4) Our consolidated unencumbered properties generated approximately 40.1% of total consolidated NOI of $253,039,476 (which excludes NOI related to dispositions) for the nine months ended September 30, 2020.
(5) NOI is derived from unencumbered portions of Tier One properties that are otherwise secured by a loan. The unencumbered portions include outparcels, anchors and former anchors that have been redeveloped.
Equity
In 2019, we suspended all future dividends on our common stock and preferred stock, as well as distributions to all noncontrolling interest investors in our Operating Partnership. The dividend arrearage created by our board of directors’ decision to suspend the dividends that continue to accrue on our outstanding preferred stock currently makes us ineligible to use the abbreviated, and less costly, SEC Form S-3 registration statement to register our securities for sale. This means we will be required to use a registration statement on Form S-1 to register additional securities for sale with the SEC, which we expect to hinder our ability to act quickly in relation to, and raise our costs incurred in, future capital raising activities. This preferred dividend arrearage (and the Operating Partnership’s related arrearage in distributions to its preferred units of limited partnership underlying our outstanding preferred shares) also will require that we not resume any payment of dividends on our common stock unless full cumulative dividends accrued with respect to our preferred stock (and such underlying preferred units) for all past quarters and the then-current quarter are first declared and paid in cash, or declared with a sum sufficient for the payment thereof having been set apart for such payment in cash. In addition, for so long as this distribution suspension results in the existence of a distribution shortfall (as described in the Partnership Agreement of the Operating Partnership) with respect to any of the S-SCUs, the L-SCUs or the K-SCUs (an “SCU Distribution Shortfall”), we (i) may not cause the Operating Partnership to resume distributions to holders of its outstanding common units of limited partnership until all holders of SCUs have received distributions sufficient to satisfy the SCU Distribution Shortfall for all prior quarters and the then-current quarter (which effectively also prevents the resumption of common stock dividends, since our common stock dividends are funded by distributions the Company receives on the underlying common units it holds in the Operating Partnership) and (ii) may not elect to settle any exchange requested by a holder of common units of the Operating Partnership in cash, and may only settle any such exchange through the issuance of shares of common stock or other units of the Operating Partnership ranking junior to any such units as to which a distribution shortfall exists. Our board of directors has prospectively approved that, to the extent any partners exercise any or all of their exchange rights while the existence of the SCU Distribution Shortfall requires an exchange to be settled through the issuance of shares of common stock or other units of the Operating Partnership, the consideration paid shall be in the form of shares of common stock. We will review taxable income on a regular basis and take measures, if necessary, to ensure that we meet the minimum distribution requirements to maintain our status as a REIT.
See Listing Criteria in Note 1 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for additional information regarding a notice we received from the NYSE regarding our non-compliance with the NYSE Listing Standards and our plans to address this non-compliance.
As a publicly traded company, and as a subsidiary of a publicly traded company, we previously have accessed capital through both the public equity and debt markets. We have a shelf registration statement on Form S-3 on file with the SEC that previously authorized us to publicly issue unspecified amounts of senior and/or subordinated debt securities, shares of preferred stock (or depositary shares representing fractional interests therein), shares of common stock, warrants or rights to purchase any of the foregoing securities, and units consisting of two or more of these classes or series of securities and limited guarantees of debt securities issued by the Operating Partnership. This shelf registration statement also authorized the Operating Partnership to publicly issue unsubordinated debt securities. This shelf registration statement was due to expire in July 2021. However, as a result of both (i) the fact that the Company no longer qualifies as a well-known seasoned issuer under SEC rules and (ii) our loss of eligibility to use Form S-3 to register offers and sales of securities as described above, we are unable to use this shelf registration statement.
Additionally, while we had previously suspended quarterly dividend payments on our common stock during 2019, a very small amount of monthly “cash option” investments in shares continued into May 2020, pursuant to the terms of the Company’s dividend reinvestment plan (“DRIP”). Due in part to impacts on the Company’s operations and staffing resulting from ongoing efforts to address the COVID-19 pandemic, we inadvertently failed to suspend the operation of these “cash option” investments during the months of March, April and May 2020, after we lost the ability to use the Form S-3 registration statement for the DRIP, effective with the filing of our Annual Report on Form 10-K in March, due to the dividend arrearage with respect to our preferred stock. We have now fully suspended the operation of our DRIP, including the cash option feature but, as a result of this oversight, we issued a total of 6,134 shares of common stock that were not registered under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the “Securities Act”) for aggregate consideration of $1,346.94 prior to such suspension. The purchasers of these shares, issued pursuant to our DRIP when we were not eligible to issue shares on Form S-3, could bring claims against us for rescission and other damages under federal or state securities laws.
Market Capitalization
Our total-market capitalization as of September 30, 2020 was as follows (in thousands, except stock prices):
| Shares Outstanding | Stock Price (1) | |
|---|---|---|
| Common stock and operating partnership units | 201,690 | $0.16 |
| 7.375% Series D Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Stock | 1,815 | 250.00 |
| 6.625% Series E Cumulative Redeemable Preferred Stock | 690 | 250.00 |
(1) Stock price for common stock and Operating Partnership units equals the closing price of CBL's common stock on September 30, 2020. The stock prices for the preferred stock represent the liquidation preference of each respective series of preferred stock.
Capital Expenditures
Deferred maintenance expenditures are generally included in the determination of CAM expense that is billed to tenants in accordance with their lease agreements. These expenditures are generally recovered over a 5 to 15-year period. Renovation expenditures are primarily for remodeling and upgrades of malls, of which a portion is recovered from tenants over a 5 to 15-year period. We recover these costs through fixed amounts with annual increases or pro rata cost reimbursements based on the tenant’s occupied space.
The following table, which excludes expenditures for developments, redevelopments and expansions, summarizes these capital expenditures, including our share of unconsolidated affiliates' capital expenditures, for the three and nine month periods ended September 30, 2020 compared to the same periods in 2019 (in thousands):
| Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tenant allowances (1) | $1,426 | $10,781 | $10,181 | $21,831 |
| Deferred maintenance: | ||||
| Parking area and parking area lighting | — | 315 | 270 | 529 |
| Roof repairs and replacements | 230 | 2,083 | 2,234 | 4,757 |
| Other capital expenditures | 1,113 | 5,610 | 4,954 | 15,094 |
| Total deferred maintenance | 1,343 | 8,008 | 7,458 | 20,380 |
| Capitalized overhead | 245 | 423 | 980 | 1,795 |
| Capitalized interest | 438 | 787 | 1,530 | 1,969 |
| Total capital expenditures | $3,452 | $19,999 | $20,149 | $45,975 |
(1) Tenant allowances primarily relate to new leases. Tenant allowances related to renewal leases were not material for the periods presented.
Annual capital expenditures budgets are prepared for each of our properties that are intended to provide for all necessary recurring and non-recurring capital expenditures. As noted above, in response to the impact from COVID-19 we have deferred or suspended capital expenditures, including redevelopment expenditures, in the range of $60.0 million to $80.0 million. We believe that property operating cash flows, which include reimbursements from tenants for certain expenses, and readily available cash on hand will provide the necessary funding for these expenditures.
Developments, Expansions and Redevelopments
The following tables summarize our development, expansion and redevelopment projects as of September 30, 2020.
Properties Opened During the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020
(Dollars in thousands)
| Property Outparcel Development: | Location | CBL Ownership Interest | Total Project Square Feet | CBL's Share of Total Cost (1) | Cost to Date (2) | 2020 Cost | Opening Date | Initial Unleveraged Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fremaux Town Center - Old Navy | Slidell, LA | 90% | 12,467 | $1,918 | $1,553 | $100 | May 2020 | 9.2% |
| Hamilton Place - Self Storage (3) (4) | Chattanooga, TN | 60% | 68,875 | 5,824 | 4,419 | 3,300 | July 2020 | 8.7% |
| Parkdale Mall - Self Storage (3) (4) | Beaumont, TX | 50% | 69,341 | 4,435 | 3,543 | 1,039 | April 2020 | 10.2% |
| Total Properties Opened | 150,683 | $12,177 | $9,515 | $4,439 |
(1) Total Cost is presented net of reimbursements to be received.
(2) Cost to Date does not reflect reimbursements until they are received.
(3) Yield is based on expected yield upon stabilization.
(4) Total cost includes an allocated value for the Company’s land contribution and amounts funded by construction loans.
Redevelopments Completed During the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020
(Dollars in thousands)
| Property Mall Redevelopments: | Location | CBL Ownership Interest | Total Project Square Feet | CBL's Share of Total Cost (1) | Cost to Date (2) | 2020 Cost | Opening Date | Initial Unleveraged Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cherryvale Sears Redevelopment - Tilt | Rockford, IL | 100% | 114,118 | $3,508 | $3,281 | $378 | June 2020 | 8.3% |
| Coastal Grand Dick's Redevelopment - DSG/Golf Galaxy (3) | Myrtle Beach, SC | 50% | 132,727 | $7,050 | $4,486 | $3,360 | Sept 2020 | 11.6% |
| Dakota Square Herbergers Redevelopment - Ross, T-Mobile, Retail Shops | Minot, ND | 100% | 30,096 | 6,410 | 4,537 | 188 | Jan 2020 | 7.2% |
| Hamilton Place Sears Redevelopment - Dicks Sporting Goods, Dave & Busters, Hotel, Cheesecake Factory (4) | Chattanooga, TN | 100% | 195,166 | 38,715 | 29,923 | 4,067 | March 2020 | 7.8% |
| Mall del Norte Forever 21 Redevelopment - Main Event | Laredo, TX | 100% | 81,242 | 10,514 | 6,819 | 1,160 | Sept 2019/Feb 2020 | 9.3% |
| The Promenade @ D'Iberville Redevelopment - Five Below, Carter's | D'Iberville, MS | 100% | 14,007 | 2,832 | 2,457 | 446 | Feb 2020/Apr 2020 | 11.4% |
| Total Redevelopments Completed | 567,356 | $69,029 | $51,503 | $9,599 |
(1) Total Cost is presented net of reimbursements to be received.
(2) Cost to Date does not reflect reimbursements until they are received.
(3) Total cost includes amounts funded by a construction loan.
(4) The return reflected represents a pro forma incremental return as Total Cost excludes the cost related to the acquisition of the Sears building in 2017.
Properties Under Development at September 30, 2020
(Dollars in thousands)
| Property Outparcel Developments: | Location | CBL Ownership Interest | Total Project Square Feet | CBL's Share of Total Cost (1) | Cost to Date (2) | 2020 Cost | Expected Opening Date (3) | Initial Unleveraged Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hamilton Place Development - Aloft Hotel (4)(5) | Chattanooga, TN | 50% | 89,674 | $12,000 | $6,767 | $6,125 | Q1 '21 | 9.2% |
| Mayfaire Town Center - First Watch | Wilmington, NC | 100% | 6,300 | 2,267 | 1,491 | 1,125 | Q4 '20 | 10.1% |
| Pearland Town Center - HCA Offices | Pearland, TX | 100% | 48,416 | 14,186 | 4,700 | 3,843 | Q1 '21 | 11.8% |
| 144,390 | $28,453 | $12,958 | $11,093 | |||||
| Mall Redevelopments: | ||||||||
| Westmoreland Mall JCP pad Redevelopment - Chipotle | Greensburg, PA | 100% | 2,300 | $1,017 | $1,125 | $881 | Q4 '20 | 9.4% |
| 2,300 | $1,017 | $1,125 | $881 | |||||
| Total Properties Under Development | 146,690 | $29,470 | $14,083 | $11,974 |
(1) Total Cost is presented net of reimbursements to be received.
(2) Cost to Date does not reflect reimbursements until they are received.
(3) As a result of government mandated construction halts due to the COVID-19 pandemic, opening dates may change from what is currently reflected.
(4) Yield is based on expected yield once project stabilizes.
(5) Total cost includes an allocated value for the Company’s land contribution and amounts funded by a construction loan.
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements
Unconsolidated Affiliates
We have ownership interests in 29 unconsolidated affiliates as of September 30, 2020 that are described in Note 7 to the condensed consolidated financial statements. The unconsolidated affiliates are accounted for using the equity method of accounting and are reflected in the condensed consolidated balance sheets as investments in unconsolidated affiliates.
The following are circumstances when we may consider entering into a joint venture with a third party:
- Third parties may approach us with opportunities in which they have obtained land and performed some pre-development activities, but they may not have sufficient access to the capital resources or the development and leasing expertise to bring the project to fruition. We enter into such arrangements when we determine such a project is viable and we can achieve a satisfactory return on our investment. We typically earn development fees from the joint venture and provide management and leasing services to the property for a fee once the property is placed in operation.
- We determine that we may have the opportunity to capitalize on the value we have created in a property by selling an interest in the property to a third party. This provides us with an additional source of capital that can be used to develop or acquire additional real estate assets that we believe will provide greater potential for growth. When we retain an interest in an asset rather than selling a 100% interest, it is typically because this allows us to continue to manage the property, which provides us the ability to earn fees for management, leasing, development and financing services provided to the joint venture.
Guarantees
We may guarantee the debt of a joint venture primarily because it allows the joint venture to obtain funding at a lower cost than could be obtained otherwise. This results in a higher return for the joint venture on its investment, and a higher return on our investment in the joint venture. We may receive a fee from the joint venture for providing the guaranty. Additionally, when we issue a guaranty, the terms of the joint venture agreement typically provide that we may receive indemnification from the joint venture or have the ability to increase our ownership interest.
See Note 12 to the condensed consolidated statements for information related to our guarantees of unconsolidated affiliates' debt as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019.
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING POLICIES
Our discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations is based on our condensed consolidated financial statements, which have been prepared in accordance with GAAP. The preparation of financial statements in conformity with GAAP requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the financial statements and disclosures. Some of these estimates and assumptions require application of difficult, subjective, and/or complex judgment about the effect of matters that are inherently uncertain and that may change in subsequent periods. We evaluate our estimates and assumptions on an ongoing basis. We base our estimates on historical experience and on various other assumptions that we believe to be reasonable under the circumstances, the results of which form the basis for making judgments about the carrying values of assets and liabilities that are not readily apparent from other sources. Actual results may differ from these estimates under different assumptions or conditions.
Our Annual Report on Form 10-K, as amended, for the year ended December 31, 2019 contains a discussion of our critical accounting policies and estimates in the Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations section. Uncertainty in the current economic environment due to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic has and may continue to significantly impact management’s judgments regarding estimates and assumptions. In addition to the critical accounting policies and estimates discussed in Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations in our Annual Report on Form 10-K, as amended, we are adding the following due to significant changes in judgements related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Revenue Recognition and Accounts Receivable
Receivables include amounts billed and currently due from tenants pursuant to lease agreements and receivables attributable to straight-line rents associated with those lease agreements. Individual leases where the collection of rents is in dispute are assessed for collectability based on management’s best estimate of collection considering the anticipated outcome of the dispute. Individual leases that are not in dispute are assessed for collectability and upon the determination that the collection of rents over the remaining lease term is not probable, accounts receivable are reduced as an adjustment to rental revenues. Revenue from leases where collection is deemed to be less than probable is recorded on a cash basis until collectability is determined to be probable. Further, management assesses whether operating lease receivables, at a portfolio level, are appropriately valued based upon an analysis of balances outstanding, historical collection levels and current economic trends. An allowance for the uncollectible portion of the portfolio is recorded as an adjustment to rental revenues. Management’s estimate of the collectability of accounts receivable from tenants is based on the best information available to management at the time of evaluation.
We review current economic considerations each reporting period, including the effects of tenant bankruptcies. Additionally, with the uncertainties regarding COVID-19, our assessment also took into consideration the type of tenant and current discussions with the tenants regarding matters such as billing disputes, lease negotiations and executed deferrals or abatements, as well as recent rent payment and credit history. Evaluating and estimating uncollectible lease payments and related receivables requires a significant amount of judgment by management and is based on the best information available to management at the time of evaluation. For the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020, we reduced rental revenue by $13.7 million and $54.5 million, respectively, due to lease-related reserves and write-offs, which includes $2.6 million and $5.1 million, respectively, for straight-line rent receivables. Actual results could differ from these estimates and such differences could be material to our consolidated financial statements.
Lease Modifications
In April 2020, the FASB issued a question-and-answer document (the “Lease Modification Q&A”) focused on the application of lease accounting guidance related to lease concessions provided as a result of COVID-19. Under existing lease guidance, we would have to determine, on a lease by lease basis, if a lease concession was the result of a new arrangement reached with the tenant (treated within the lease modification accounting framework) or if a lease concession was under the enforceable rights and obligations within the existing lease agreement (precluded from applying the lease modification accounting framework). The Lease Modification Q&A clarifies that entities may elect to not evaluate whether lease-related relief that lessors provide to mitigate the economic effects of COVID-19 on lessees is a lease modification under Topic 842, Leases. Instead, an entity that elects not to evaluate whether a concession directly related to COVID-19 is a modification can then elect whether to apply the modification guidance (i.e. assume the relief was always contemplated by the contract or assume the relief was not contemplated by the contract). Both lessees and lessors may make this election.
We have elected to apply the relief provided under the Lease Modification Q&A and will avail ourselves of the election to avoid performing a lease by lease analysis for the lease concessions that were (1) granted as relief due to the COVID-19 pandemic and (2) result in the cash flows remaining substantially the same or less than the original contract. The Lease Modification Q&A had a material impact on our consolidated financial statements as of and for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020. However, its future impact to us is dependent upon the extent of lease concessions granted to tenants as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic in future periods and the elections made by us at the time of entering such concessions.
The Lease Modification Q&A allows us to determine accounting policy elections at a disaggregated level, and the elections should be applied consistently by either the type of concession, underlying asset class or on another reasonable basis. As a result, we have made the following policy elections based on the type of concession agreed to with the respective tenant.
Rent Deferrals
The Company will account for rental deferrals using the receivables model as described within the Lease Modification Q&A. Under the receivables model, the Company will continue to recognize lease revenue in a manner that is unchanged from the original lease agreement and continue to recognize lease receivables and rental revenue during deferral period.
Rent Abatements
The Company will account for rental abatements using the negative variable income model as described within the Lease Modification Q&A. Under the negative variable income model, the Company will recognize negative variable rent for the current period reduction of rental revenue associated with any lease concessions we provide.
At September 30, 2020, our receivables include $22.1 million related to receivables that have been deferred and are to be repaid over periods generally starting in late 2020 and extending for some portion of 2021. We granted abatements of $13.1 million and 14.9 million, respectively, for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020. Additionally, we granted rent abatements of approximately $13.1 million and $14.9 million for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2020, respectively. We continue to assess rent relief requests from our tenants but are unable to predict the resolution or impact of these discussions. For agreements that are in currently under negotiation, we do not expect the impact to be material.
Recent Accounting Pronouncements
See Note 2 to the condensed consolidated financial statements for information on recently issued accounting pronouncements.
Impact of Inflation and Deflation
Deflation can result in a decline in general price levels, often caused by a decrease in the supply of money or credit. The predominant effects of deflation are high unemployment, credit contraction and weakened consumer demand. Restricted lending practices could impact our ability to obtain financings or refinancings for our properties and our tenants’ ability to obtain credit. Decreases in consumer demand can have a direct impact on our tenants and the rents we receive.
During inflationary periods, substantially all of our tenant leases contain provisions designed to mitigate the impact of inflation. These provisions include clauses enabling us to receive percentage rent based on tenants' gross sales, which generally increase as prices rise, and/or escalation clauses, which generally increase rental rates during the terms of the leases. In addition, many of the leases are for terms of less than 10 years, which may provide us the opportunity to replace existing leases with new leases at higher base and/or percentage rent if rents of the existing leases are below the then existing market rate. Most of the leases require the tenants to pay a fixed amount, subject to annual increases, for their share of operating expenses, including CAM, real estate taxes, insurance and certain capital expenditures, which reduces our exposure to increases in costs and operating expenses resulting from inflation.
Non-GAAP Measure
Funds from Operations
FFO is a widely used non-GAAP measure of the operating performance of real estate companies that supplements net income (loss) determined in accordance with GAAP. NAREIT defines FFO as net income (loss) (computed in accordance with GAAP) excluding gains or losses on sales of depreciable operating properties and impairment losses of depreciable properties, plus depreciation and amortization, and after adjustments for unconsolidated partnerships and joint ventures and noncontrolling interests. Adjustments for unconsolidated partnerships, joint ventures and noncontrolling interests are calculated on the same basis. We define FFO as defined above by NAREIT less dividends on preferred stock of the Company or distributions on preferred units of the Operating Partnership, as applicable. Our method of calculating FFO may be different from methods used by other REITs and, accordingly, may not be comparable to such other REITs.
We believe that FFO provides an additional indicator of the operating performance of our properties without giving effect to real estate depreciation and amortization, which assumes the value of real estate assets declines predictably over time. Since values of real estate assets have historically risen or fallen with market conditions, we believe that FFO, which excludes historical cost depreciation and amortization, enhances investors’ understanding of our operating performance. The use of FFO as an indicator of financial performance is influenced not only by the operations of our properties and interest rates, but also by our capital structure.
We present both FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders and FFO allocable to common shareholders, as we believe that both are useful performance measures. We believe FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders is a useful performance measure since we conduct substantially all of our business through our Operating Partnership and, therefore, it reflects the performance of the properties in absolute terms regardless of the ratio of ownership interests of our common shareholders and the noncontrolling interest in our Operating Partnership. We believe FFO allocable to common shareholders is a useful performance measure because it is the performance measure that is most directly comparable to net income (loss) attributable to common shareholders.
In our reconciliation of net income (loss) attributable to common shareholders to FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders that is presented below, we make an adjustment to add back noncontrolling interest in income (loss) of our Operating Partnership in order to arrive at FFO of the Operating Partnership common unitholders. We then apply a percentage to FFO of the Operating Partnership common unitholders to arrive at FFO allocable to common shareholders. The percentage is computed by taking the weighted-average number of common shares outstanding for the period and dividing it by the sum of the weighted-average number of common shares and the weighted-average number of Operating Partnership units held by noncontrolling interests during the period.
FFO does not represent cash flows from operations as defined by GAAP, is not necessarily indicative of cash available to fund all cash flow needs and should not be considered as an alternative to net income (loss) for purposes of evaluating our operating performance or to cash flow as a measure of liquidity.
The Company believes that it is important to identify the impact of certain significant items on its FFO measures for a reader to have a complete understanding of the Company’s results of operations. Therefore, the Company has also presented adjusted FFO measures excluding these significant items from the applicable periods. Please refer to the reconciliation of net income (loss) attributable to common shareholders to FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders below for a description of these adjustments.
FFO of the Operating Partnership declined to $11.4 million for the three months ended September 30, 2020 from $90.4 million for the prior-year period and declined to $57.2 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 from $203.0 million for the prior-year period. Excluding the adjustments noted below, FFO of the Operating Partnership, as adjusted, declined to $9.0 million for the three months ended September 30, 2020 from $67.8 million for the same period in 2019, and declined to $65.5 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2020 from $196.8 million for the same period in 2019. The decreases in FFO, as adjusted, for the three- and nine- month periods were primarily driven by lower property-level NOI, which includes the estimate for uncollectable rental revenues and rent abatements due to the mandated property closures a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The reduction in rental revenues was partially offset by lower operating expenses from the program we put in place to eliminate all non-essential expenditures and the company-wide furlough and salary reduction program.
The reconciliation of net loss attributable to common shareholders to FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders is as follows (in thousands, except per share data):
| Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net loss attributable to common shareholders | $(54,101) | $(90,116) | $(269,449) | $(175,715) |
| Noncontrolling interest in income (loss) of Operating Partnership | (609) | (13,904) | (19,100) | (27,116) |
| Depreciation and amortization expense of: | ||||
| Consolidated Properties | 53,477 | 64,168 | 162,042 | 198,438 |
| Unconsolidated affiliates | 14,437 | 14,471 | 41,967 | 36,599 |
| Non-real estate assets | (702) | (920) | (2,431) | (2,719) |
| Noncontrolling interests' share of depreciation and amortization | (1,118) | (2,031) | (2,829) | (6,836) |
| Loss on impairment | 46 | 135,688 | 146,964 | 202,121 |
| (Gain) loss on depreciable property | — | (16,914) | 25 | (21,755) |
| FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders | 11,430 | 90,442 | 57,189 | 203,017 |
| Debt restructuring expenses (1) | 12,913 | — | 20,770 | — |
| Litigation settlement, net of taxes (2) | (2,480) | (22,688) | (2,480) | 64,979 |
| Non-cash default interest expense (3) | 2,519 | — | 5,412 | 542 |
| Gain on extinguishment of debt (4) | (15,407) | — | (15,407) | (71,722) |
| FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders, as adjusted | $8,975 | $67,754 | $65,484 | $196,816 |
| FFO per diluted share | $0.06 | $0.45 | $0.28 | $1.01 |
| FFO, as adjusted, per diluted share | $0.04 | $0.34 | $0.32 | $0.98 |
(1) Represents professional fees related to the Company's negotiations with the administrative agent and lenders under the secured credit facility and certain holders of the Company's senior unsecured notes regarding a restructure of such indebtedness.
(2) Represents the accrued expense related to settlement of a class action lawsuit.
(3) The three and nine months ended September 30, 2020 includes default interest expense related to Greenbrier Mall, Hickory Point Mall, Eastgate Mall, Asheville Mall, Burnsville Center and Park Plaza Mall. The nine months ended September 30, 2019 includes default interest expense related to Acadiana Mall and Cary Towne Center.
(4) The three and nine months ended September 30, 2020 includes a gain on extinguishment on debt related to the non-recourse loan secured by Hickory Point Mall, which was conveyed to the lender. The nine months ended September 30, 2019 includes a gain on extinguishment of debt related to the non-recourse loan secured by Acadiana Mall, which was conveyed to the lender in the first quarter of 2019, and a gain on extinguishment of debt related to the non-recourse loan secured by Cary Towne Center, which was sold in the first quarter of 2019.
The reconciliation of diluted EPS to FFO per diluted share is as follows:
| Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diluted EPS attributable to common shareholders | $(0.28) | $(0.52) | $(1.43) | $(1.01) |
| Eliminate amounts per share excluded from FFO: | ||||
| Depreciation and amortization expense, including amounts from consolidated Properties, unconsolidated affiliates, non-real estate assets and excluding amounts allocated to noncontrolling interests | 0.34 | 0.38 | 0.99 | 1.13 |
| Loss on impairment | — | 0.68 | 0.72 | 1.00 |
| Gain on depreciable property | — | (0.09) | — | (0.11) |
| FFO per diluted share | $0.06 | $0.45 | $0.28 | $1.01 |
70
The reconciliations of FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders to FFO allocable to common shareholders, including and excluding the adjustments noted above, are as follows (in thousands):
| Three Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | Nine Months Ended September 30, 2020 | 2019 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FFO of the Operating Partnership | $11,430 | $90,442 | $57,189 | $203,017 |
| Percentage allocable to common shareholders (1) | 95.93% | 86.64% | 93.38% | 86.63% |
| FFO allocable to common shareholders | $10,965 | $78,359 | $53,403 | $175,874 |
| FFO allocable to Operating Partnership common unitholders, as adjusted | $8,975 | $67,754 | $65,484 | $196,816 |
| Percentage allocable to common shareholders (1) | 95.93% | 86.64% | 93.38% | 86.63% |
| FFO allocable to common shareholders, as adjusted | $8,610 | $58,702 | $61,149 | $170,502 |
(1) Represents the weighted-average number of common shares outstanding for the period divided by the sum of the weighted-average number of common shares and the weighted-average number of Operating Partnership units outstanding during the period.
Market risk
As filed, 1,694 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
Defaults on Indebtedness
See information presented in Note 8 – Mortgage and Other Indebtedness, Net in the financial statements included in PART I of this report under the heading “Senior Unsecured Notes” for a discussion of certain defaults with respect to the Company’s senior unsecured notes and senior secured credit facility related to certain interest payments on the senior unsecured notes, and additional information presented under the heading “Financial Covenants and Restrictions” for a discussion of additional asserted defaults with respect to the Company’s senior secured credit facility.
Preferred Dividend and Special Common Unit Distribution Arrearages
Dividends on the Series D and the Series E preferred stock are cumulative and therefore will continue to accrue at an annual rate of $18.4375 per share and $16.5625 per share, respectively. As of September 30, 2020, the cumulative amount of unpaid dividends on the preferred stock totaled $44.9 million.
Distributions on the Series K and S special common units are cumulative and therefore will continue to accrue at an annual rate of $2.96875 per unit, $3.0288 per unit and $2.92875 per unit, respectively. Distributions on the Series L special common units were cumulative through and accrued at an annual rate of $3.0288 per unit. Pursuant to the terms of the Series L special common units, on June 1, 2020 the Series L special common units began receiving distributions at the same rate and on the same terms as the common units of limited partnership interest in the Operating Partnership. As of September 30, 2020, the cumulative amount of unpaid distributions on the special common units totaled $8.8 million.
Controls and procedures
As filed, 4,313 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
Disclosure Controls and Procedures
As of the end of the period covered by this quarterly report, an evaluation was performed under the supervision of our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer and with the participation of our management, of the effectiveness of the design and operation of the Company's and the Operating Partnership's disclosure controls and procedures pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 13a-15. The Company's and the Operating Partnership's disclosure controls and procedures are designed to provide reasonable assurance that information required to be disclosed in the reports we file or submit under the Exchange Act is recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in the SEC rules and forms and to ensure that information we are required to disclose is accumulated and communicated to our management, including our Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, as appropriate to allow timely decisions regarding required disclosure. Based on that evaluation, the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer have concluded that the Company’s and the Operating Partnership’s disclosure controls and procedures were not effective as a result of the material weakness described below.
Material Weakness in Internal Control over Financial Reporting
A material weakness is a deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, in internal control over financial reporting, such that there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the Company’s and the Operating Partnership’s annual or interim financial statements will not be prevented or detected on a timely basis. In its assessment of the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting at both June 30, 2020 and September 30, 2020, management of the Company and the Operating Partnership determined that there was a control deficiency that constituted a material weakness, as described below.
As a result of turnover, the Company and the Operating Partnership did not maintain a sufficient complement of personnel commensurate with their accounting and financial reporting requirements in accordance with U.S. GAAP and SEC regulations.
The control deficiency described above created a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the annual or interim financial statements would not be prevented or detected on a timely basis and therefore we concluded that the deficiency represents a material weakness in the Company’s and the Operating Partnership’s internal control over financial reporting and that the Company and the Operating Partnership did not maintain effective internal control over financial reporting as of June 30, 2020 and September 30, 2020 based on criteria established in Internal Control-Integrated Framework issued by COSO.
Notwithstanding the identified material weakness, management believes that the Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements and related financial information included in this Form 10-Q fairly present, in all material respects, our balance sheets, statements of operations, comprehensive loss and cash flows as of and for the periods presented.
Remediation Plan
The Company and the Operating Partnership plan to remediate this material weakness by hiring additional personnel to enable them to meet their financial reporting requirements. The Company and the Operating Partnership may also utilize outside advisors to assist on a short-term basis.
Changes in Internal Control over Financial Reporting
We have continued to address the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on our control structure, including modifications to business modeling, forecasting and estimations, lease modifications, and accounts receivable collectability, as well as for the consequences of reductions in headcount and remote working arrangements. We are continually monitoring and assessing the COVID-19 pandemic’s effect on our internal control processes in order to minimize the impact to their design and operating effectiveness. There were no other changes in the Company’s or the Operating Partnership’s internal control over financial reporting during our most recent fiscal quarter that have materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, our internal control over financial reporting.
Risk factors
As filed, 33,013 characters, with its headings, lists and tables. Extracted from the main document; charts and exhibits are in the original on sec.gov.
In addition to the other information set forth in this report, you should carefully consider the risks that could materially affect our business, financial condition or results of operations that are discussed under the caption “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of our Annual Report on Form 10-K, as amended, for the year ended December 31, 2019. The risk factor set forth below updates, and should be read together with, such risk factors. Moreover, risk factors set forth in the Annual Report on Form 10-K, as amended, for the year ended December 31, 2019 could be heightened as a result of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The RSA is subject to significant conditions and milestones that may be beyond our control and may be difficult for us to satisfy. If the RSA is terminated, our ability to confirm and consummate the Plan could be materially and adversely affected.
The RSA sets forth certain conditions we must satisfy, including the timely satisfaction of milestones in the Chapter 11 Cases, such as confirmation of the Plan and effectiveness of the Plan. Our ability to timely complete such milestones is subject to risks and uncertainties that may be beyond our control. The RSA gives the Consenting Noteholders the ability to terminate the RSA under certain circumstances, including the failure of certain conditions to be satisfied. Should a termination event occur, all obligations of the parties to the RSA will terminate. A termination of the RSA may result in the loss of support for the Plan, which could adversely affect our ability to confirm and consummate the Plan. If the Plan is not consummated, there can be no assurance that any new Plan would be as favorable to holders of claims as the current Plan and our chapter 11 proceedings could become protracted, which could significantly and detrimentally impact our relationships with vendors, suppliers, employees, and tenants.
We will be subject to the risks and uncertainties associated with chapter 11 proceedings.
As a consequence of our filing for relief under chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, our operations and our ability to develop and execute our business plan, and our continuation as a going concern, will be subject to the risks and uncertainties associated with bankruptcy. These risks include the following:
- our ability to prosecute, confirm and consummate the Plan or another plan of reorganization with respect to the chapter 11 proceedings;
- the high costs of bankruptcy proceedings and related fees;
- if required, our ability to obtain sufficient financing to allow us to emerge from bankruptcy and execute our business plan post-emergence;
- our ability to maintain our relationships with our suppliers, service providers, tenants, employees and other third parties;
- our ability to maintain contracts that are critical to our operations;
- our ability to execute our business plan in the current depressed commodity price environment;
- the ability to attract, motivate and retain key employees;
- the ability of third parties to seek and obtain court approval to terminate contracts and other agreements with us;
- the ability of third parties to seek and obtain court approval to convert the chapter 11 proceedings to chapter 7 proceedings; and
- the actions and decisions of our creditors and other third parties who have interests in our chapter 11 proceedings that may be inconsistent with our plans.
These risks and uncertainties could affect our business and operations in various ways. For example, negative events associated with our chapter 11 proceedings could adversely affect our relationships with our suppliers, service providers, tenants, employees, and other third parties, which in turn could adversely affect our operations and financial condition. Also, we need the prior approval of the Bankruptcy Court for transactions outside the ordinary course of business, which may limit our ability to respond timely to certain events or take advantage of certain opportunities. Because of the risks and uncertainties associated with our chapter 11 proceedings, we cannot accurately predict or quantify the ultimate impact of events that occur during our chapter 11 proceedings that may be inconsistent with our plans.
We may not be able to obtain confirmation of the Plan as outlined in the RSA.
There can be no assurance that the Plan as outlined in the RSA (or any other plan of reorganization) will be approved by the Bankruptcy Court, so we urge caution with respect to existing and future investments in our securities.
The success of any reorganization will depend on approval by the Bankruptcy Court and the willingness of existing debt and security holders to agree to the exchange or modification of their interests as outlined in the Plan, and there can be no guarantee of success with respect to the Plan or any other plan of reorganization. We might receive official objections to confirmation of the Plan from the various stakeholders in the chapter 11 proceedings. We cannot predict the impact that any objection might have on the Plan or on a Bankruptcy Court's decision to confirm the Plan. Any objection may cause us to devote significant resources in response which could materially and adversely affect our business, financial condition and results of operations.
If the Plan is not confirmed by the Bankruptcy Court, it is unclear whether we would be able to reorganize our business and what, if any, distributions holders of claims against us, including holders of our secured and unsecured debt and equity, would ultimately receive with respect to their claims. There can be no assurance as to whether we will successfully reorganize and emerge from chapter 11 or, if we do successfully reorganize, as to when we would emerge from chapter 11. If no plan of reorganization can be confirmed, or if the Bankruptcy Court otherwise finds that it would be in the best interest of holders of claims and interests, the chapter 11 cases may be converted to cases under chapter 7 of the Bankruptcy Code, pursuant to which a trustee would be appointed or elected to liquidate our assets for distribution in accordance with the priorities established by the Bankruptcy Code.
Upon emergence from bankruptcy, our historical financial information may not be indicative of our future financial performance.
Our capital structure will be significantly altered under the Plan. Under fresh-start reporting rules that may apply to us upon the effective date of the Plan (or any alternative plan of reorganization), our assets and liabilities would be adjusted to fair values and our accumulated deficit would be restated to zero. Accordingly, if fresh-start reporting rules apply, our financial condition and results of operations following our emergence from chapter 11 would not be comparable to the financial condition and results of operations reflected in our historical financial statements. Further, a plan of reorganization could materially change the amounts and classifications reported in our consolidated historical financial statements, which do not give effect to any adjustments to the carrying value of assets or amounts of liabilities that might be necessary as a consequence of confirmation of a plan of reorganization.
The pursuit of the RSA has consumed, and the chapter 11 proceedings will continue to consume, a substantial portion of the time and attention of our management, which may have an adverse effect on our business and results of operations, and we may face increased levels of employee attrition.
Although the Plan is designed to minimize the length of our chapter 11 proceedings, it is impossible to predict with certainty the amount of time that we may spend in bankruptcy or to assure parties in interest that the Plan will be confirmed. The chapter 11 proceedings will involve additional expense and our management will be required to spend a significant amount of time and effort focusing on the proceedings. This diversion of attention may materially adversely affect the conduct of our business, and, as a result, on our financial condition and results of operations, particularly if the chapter 11 proceedings are protracted.
During the pendency of the chapter 11 proceedings, our employees will face considerable distraction and uncertainty and we may experience increased levels of employee attrition. A loss of key personnel or material erosion of employee morale could have a material adverse effect on our ability to effectively, efficiently and safely conduct our business, and could impair our ability to execute our strategy and implement operational initiatives, thereby having a material adverse effect on our financial condition and results of operations.
We depend on the continued presence of key personnel for critical management decisions.
Retaining and understanding historical knowledge from our key personnel is critical to allowing the management team to more effectively progress our business plan. As part of the restructuring we anticipate our existing senior management team to remain in place, however there is a risk of loss of key personnel. Anytime personnel are replaced, there is a risk that there may be a loss of service, albeit temporary, that could result in an adverse effect on the business.
Upon our emergence from bankruptcy, the composition of our Board of Directors may change significantly.
Under the Plan, the composition of our Board of Directors may change significantly. Any new directors are likely to have different backgrounds, experiences and perspectives from those individuals who previously served on the Board and, thus, may have different views on the issues that will determine our future. As a result, our future strategy and plans may differ materially from those of the past.
Transfers of our equity, or issuances of equity before or in connection with our chapter 11 proceedings, may impair our ability to utilize the existing tax basis in our assets, our federal income tax net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes during the current year and in future years.
Under federal income tax law, a corporation is generally permitted to offset net taxable income in a given year with net operating losses carried forward from prior years, and its existing adjusted tax basis in its assets may be used to offset future gains or to generate annual cost recovery deductions. We had significant “net unrealized built-in loss” (NUBIL) (i.e., adjusted tax basis in excess of the fair market value of our assets) and net operating loss carryforwards that are not subject to any section 382 limitations.
Our ability to utilize our NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes to offset future taxable income is subject to certain requirements and restrictions. In order to qualify for taxation as a “real estate investment trust,” we must meet various requirements including a requirement to distribute 90% of our taxable income; and, to avoid paying corporate income tax, we must distribute 100% of our taxable income. If we do experience an "ownership change" during or in connection with the restructuring process, as defined in section 382 of the Internal Revenue Code, then our ability to use our NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes to offset future taxable income may be substantially limited, which could have a negative impact on our financial position and results of operations. Generally, there is an "ownership change" if one or more stockholders owning 5% or more of a corporation's common stock have aggregate increases in their ownership of such stock of more than 50 percentage points over a prescribed testing period. Under section 382 and section 383 of the Internal Revenue Code, absent an applicable exception, if a corporation undergoes an "ownership change", the amount of its NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes that may be utilized to offset future taxable income generally is subject to an annual limitation (though “recognized built-in losses” arising from our NUBIL will only be subject to limitation if they are recognized within 5 years of the “ownership change”).
Whether or not the NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes are subject to limitation under section 382, our NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes are expected to be further reduced by the amount of discharge of indebtedness arising in our Chapter 11 Cases under section 108 of the Internal Revenue Code.
We have received an order from the Bankruptcy Court approving potential restrictions on certain transfers of our stock to limit the risk of an "ownership change" prior to our emergence from restructuring in our chapter 11 proceedings. We anticipate that the implementation of our plan of reorganization will result in an "ownership change." If so, our NUBIL, net operating loss carryforwards and other tax attributes will become impaired, with the extent of such impairment dependent on the impact of special tax law rules under section 382(l)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code, applicable to an "ownership change" that occurs as part of a chapter 11 plan.
The current pandemic of the novel coronavirus, or COVID-19 has, and could continue to, materially and adversely impact or disrupt our financial condition, results of operations, cash flows and performance, as could any future outbreak of another highly infectious or contagious disease.
Since being reported in December 2019, COVID-19 has spread globally, including to every state in the United States. On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a pandemic, and on March 13, 2020, the United States declared a national emergency with respect to COVID-19.
The COVID-19 pandemic has had, and may continue to have, repercussions across regional and global economies and financial markets. The outbreak of COVID-19 in many countries, including the United States, has significantly adversely impacted global economic activity and has contributed to significant volatility and negative pressure in financial markets. The global impact of the outbreak has been rapidly evolving and, as cases of COVID-19 have continued to be identified in additional countries, many - including the United States - have reacted by instituting quarantines, mandating business and school closures and restricting travel.
Certain states and cities, including where we own properties and where our corporate headquarters is located, have also reacted by instituting quarantines, restrictions on travel, “shelter-in-place” rules, restrictions on types of business that may continue to operate, and/or restrictions on the types of construction projects that may continue. The Company cannot predict if additional states and cities will implement similar restrictions or when any such new restrictions might be lifted. As a result, the COVID-19 pandemic is negatively impacting almost every industry directly or indirectly, including the retail industry in which the Company and our tenants operate.
A majority of our tenants implemented temporary closures and/or shortened the operating hours of their stores for a period of time and requested rent deferral or rent abatement during this pandemic or have failed to pay rent. In addition, state, local or industry-initiated efforts, such as tenant rent freezes, or governmental or court-imposed delays in the processing of landlord initiated commercial eviction and collection actions in various jurisdictions in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, may also affect our ability to collect rent or enforce remedies for the failure to pay rent. We believe our tenants do not have a contractual right to cease paying rent due to government-mandated closures and, subject to negotiated resolutions of rent deferral requests that we have entered into, and may continue to enter into with certain tenants, we intend to enforce our rights under our lease agreements. However, COVID-19 and the related governmental orders present fairly novel situations for which the ultimate legal outcome cannot be assured, and it is possible future governmental action could impact our rights under the lease agreements. The extent of tenant requests and actions, and the resulting impact to the Company’s results of operations and cash flows, is uncertain and cannot be predicted.
The COVID-19 pandemic, or a future pandemic, could also have further material and adverse effects on our ability to successfully operate and on our financial condition, results of operations and cash flows due to, among other factors:
- complete or partial closures of, or other operational issues at, one or more of our properties beyond those that have already occurred resulting from government or tenant action;
- the reduced economic activity severely impacts our tenants' businesses, financial condition and liquidity and may cause one or more of our tenants to be unable to meet their obligations to us in full, or at all, or to otherwise seek modifications of such obligations;
- the reduced economic activity, as well as any lasting reduction in consumer activity at brick-and-mortar commercial establishments due to changed habits in response to the prolonged existence and threat of the
COVID-19 pandemic, could result in a prolonged recession and could negatively impact consumer discretionary spending;
- difficulty accessing debt and equity capital on attractive terms, or at all, and a severe disruption and instability in the global financial markets or deteriorations in credit and financing conditions may affect our access to capital necessary to fund business operations or address maturing liabilities on a timely basis and our tenants' ability to fund their business operations and meet their obligations to us;
- permitting, inspections and reviews by jurisdictional planning commissions and authorities is also likely to be delayed or postponed which could materially impact the timeline and budgets for completing redevelopments;
- projects in our redevelopment pipeline may not be pursued or may be completed later or with higher costs than anticipated, potentially causing a loss that exceeds our investment in the project;
- the financial impact of the COVID-19 pandemic could negatively impact our future compliance with financial covenants of our credit facility, indentures and other recourse and non-recourse debt agreements and result in a default and potentially an acceleration of indebtedness, which non-compliance could negatively impact our ability to make additional borrowings under our revolving credit facility and pay dividends;
- any additional impairments in value of our tangible assets and intangible lease assets that could be recorded as a result of weaker economic conditions;
- a deterioration in our or our tenants' ability to operate in affected areas or delays in the supply of products or services to us or our tenants from vendors that are needed for our or our tenants' efficient operations could adversely affect our operations and those of our tenants;
- the ability to renew leases or re-lease vacant spaces on favorable terms, or at all; and
- the potential negative impact on the health of our personnel, particularly if a significant number of them are impacted, could result in a deterioration in our ability to ensure business continuity during this disruption.
The extent to which the COVID-19 pandemic impacts our operations and those of our tenants will depend on future developments, which are highly uncertain and cannot be predicted with confidence, including the scope, severity and duration of the pandemic, the actions taken to contain the pandemic or mitigate its impact, and the direct and indirect economic effects of the pandemic and containment measures, among others. Additional closures by our tenants of their stores and early terminations by our tenants of their leases could further reduce our cash flows, which could impact our ability to resume paying dividends to our stockholders at any point in the future.
The rapid development and fluidity of this situation precludes any prediction as to the full adverse impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. The COVID-19 pandemic presents material uncertainty and risk with respect to our financial condition, results of operations, cash flows and performance.
We have determined that there is substantial doubt about our ability to continue as a going concern.
In accordance with the accounting guidance related to the presentation of financial statements, when preparing financial statements for each annual and interim reporting period, management evaluates whether there are conditions or events that, when considered in the aggregate, raise substantial doubt about the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern within one year after the date that the financial statements are issued. In making its assessment, management considered the Company’s current financial condition and liquidity sources, as well as the status of the Chapter 11 Cases.
The Operating Partnership received notices of default and reservation of rights letters from the administrative agent under the secured credit facility asserting that certain defaults and events of default, as applicable, have occurred and continue to exist as of the date of this report by reason of the Operating Partnership’s failure to comply with certain restrictive covenants under the secured credit facility. As a result of these asserted defaults and events of default, the lenders under the secured credit facility declared all outstanding principal, accrued interest and letters of credit to be immediately due and payable. Subsequent to the lenders accelerating the outstanding balances under the secured credit facility, other events occurred that each constitute an event of default under the secured credit facility, including (i) the Operating Partnership failed to meet the minimum debt yield covenant under the secured credit facility as of September 30, 2020, (ii) the NYSE suspension of trading in the Company’s common stock and commencement of proceedings to delist the Company’s common stock and depositary shares representing fractional interests in each of its series of preferred stock and (iii) the Debtors filed the Chapter 11 Cases. Additionally, the filing of the Chapter 11 Cases constituted an event of default that results in the automatic acceleration of all outstanding principal, accrued and unpaid interest, and letters of credit to be immediately due and payable with respect to the secured credit facility and the senior unsecured notes. The filing of the Chapter 11 Cases also constituted an event of default with respect to certain property-level debt of the Operating Partnership’s subsidiaries, which may result in automatic acceleration of the outstanding principal and accrued interest or may give the applicable lender the right to accelerate such amounts.
Given the acceleration of the senior secured credit facility, the senior unsecured notes and certain property-level debt, as well as the inherent risks, unknown results and inherent uncertainties associated with the bankruptcy process and the direct correlation between these matters and our ability to satisfy our financial obligations that may arise, the Company believes that there is substantial doubt that it will continue to operate as a going concern within one year after the date these condensed consolidated financial statements are issued. The accompanying condensed consolidated financial statements have been prepared in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America applicable to a going concern, which contemplates the realization of assets and the satisfaction of liabilities in the normal course of business. Accordingly, the condensed consolidated financial statements do not reflect any adjustments related to the recoverability of assets and satisfaction of liabilities that might be necessary should the Company be unable to continue as a going concern.
We identified a material weakness in internal control over financial reporting. We may not remediate this material weakness on a timely basis or may identify additional material weaknesses in the future or otherwise fail to maintain an effective system of internal control over financial reporting, which may result in material misstatements of our financial statements or cause us to fail to meet our reporting obligations. As a result, stockholders could lose confidence in our financial and other public reporting, which would then be likely to negatively affect our business and the market price of our securities.
A material weakness in internal control over financial reporting was identified as of June 30, 2020 and September 30, 2020. A material weakness is defined as a deficiency, or a combination of deficiencies, in internal control over financial reporting, such that there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the annual or interim financial statements will not be prevented or detected on a timely basis. See Part I, Item 4 above for further details. We are planning to remediate the material weakness by hiring additional personnel to enable the Company and the Operating Partnership to meet their financial reporting requirements, and we may utilize outside advisors to assist on a short-term basis. These remediation measures may be time consuming and costly, and might place significant demands on our financial, accounting and operational resources. In addition, there is no assurance that we will be successful in hiring the necessary personnel in a timely manner, or at all.
Effective internal control over financial reporting is necessary for us to provide reliable financial reports and is important in helping to prevent mistakes in our financial statements and financial fraud. Any failure to implement required new or improved controls, or difficulties encountered in our implementation to successfully remediate our existing or any future material weaknesses in our internal control over financial reporting, or identification of any additional material weaknesses that may exist, may adversely affect the accuracy and timing of our financial reporting, we may be unable to maintain compliance with securities law requirements regarding timely filing of periodic reports in addition to applicable stock exchange listing requirements, we may be unable to prevent fraud, investors may lose confidence in our financial reporting, and the price of our securities may decline as a result.
Any testing conducted by us, or any testing conducted by our independent registered public accounting firm, may reveal additional deficiencies in our internal control over financial reporting that are deemed to be new material weaknesses or that may require prospective or retroactive changes to our financial statements or identify other areas for further attention or improvement. In addition, our reporting obligations as a public company could place a significant strain on our management, operational and financial resources and systems for the foreseeable future and may cause us to fail to timely achieve and maintain the adequacy of its internal control over financial reporting.
Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies and procedures may deteriorate. Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting cannot provide absolute assurance of achieving financial reporting objectives because of its inherent limitations. Internal control over financial reporting is a process that involves human diligence and compliance and is subject to lapses in judgment and breakdowns resulting from human failures. Because of such limitations, there is a risk that material misstatements may not be prevented or detected on a timely basis by internal control over financial reporting. There is no assurance that the measures we are currently undertaking or may take in the future will be sufficient to maintain effective internal controls or to avoid potential future deficiencies in internal control, including material weaknesses.
Our stock currently is subject to delisting from the NYSE due to “abnormally low” trading price levels under the NYSE’s continued listed standards. Trading in our stock was suspended on November 2, 2020 and the NYSE has determined to commence related delisting proceedings. The delisting of our stock from the NYSE could have materially adverse effects on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
On November 2, 2020, the NYSE announced that (i) it had suspended trading in the Company’s stock and (ii) it had determined to commence proceedings to delist the Company’s common stock, as well as the depositary shares each representing a 1/10th fractional share of the Company’s Series D Preferred Stock and the depositary shares each representing a 1/10th fractional share of the Company’s Series E Preferred Stock, due to such securities no longer being suitable for listing based on “abnormally low” trading price levels, pursuant to Section 802.01D of the NYSE Listed Company Manual. While the Company intends to appeal this decision in accordance with NYSE rules, there can be no assurance that an appeal will be successful. In the meantime, effective November 3, 2020, the Company’s common stock and the depositary shares representing fractional interests in its Series D Preferred Stock and Series E Preferred Stock began trading on the OTC Markets, operated by the OTC Markets Group, Inc., under the symbols “CBLAQ”, “CBLDQ” and
“CBLEQ”, respectively. The over-the-counter markets are a more limited market than the NYSE and it is likely that there will be significantly less liquidity in the trading of our common and preferred stock.
The suspension of trading and potential delisting of our common stock could have material adverse effects on our business, financial condition and results of operations due to, among other things:
- the reduced trading liquidity for our common and preferred stock as a result of trading on the over-the-counter markets rather than the NYSE as described above could further reduce the market price of such stock;
- decreases in the number of institutional and other investors willing to hold or acquire our stock, coverage by securities analysts, market making activity and information available concerning trading prices and volume, as well as fewer broker-dealers willing to execute trades in our stock, thereby further restricting our ability to obtain equity financing;
- causing an event of default or noncompliance under certain of our debt facilities and other agreements; and
- reducing our ability to retain, attract and motivate our directors, officers and employees by means of equity compensation.
As a result of the cumulative, unpaid dividends on our preferred stock we are no longer eligible to register the offer and sale of securities on SEC Form S-3, which will impair our capital raising activities and could result in the Company being required to repurchase a limited number of shares sold under our DRIP.
We are no longer eligible to use SEC Form S-3 to register offers and sales of our securities under the Securities Act, as a result of the existing dividend arrearage on our preferred stock, which will continue to accumulate following our board of directors’ decision in December 2019 to suspend such dividends. Historically, we have relied on shelf registration statements on Form S-3 for our public capital raising transactions, and also to register the offer and sale of shares of common stock under our DRIP. Our inability to use Form S-3 may harm our ability to raise capital in the future, as we will be required to use a registration statement on Form S-1 to register securities with the SEC, which may be expected to hinder our ability to act quickly in raising capital to take advantage of market conditions and to increase our cost of raising capital. Further, we inadvertently failed to suspend small monthly “cash option” investments in common stock under our DRIP during the months of March, April and May 2020, and as a result of this oversight, we issued a total of 6,134 shares of common stock that were not registered under the Securities Act for aggregate consideration of $1,346.94. The purchasers of these shares, issued pursuant to our DRIP when we were not eligible to issue shares on Form S-3, could bring claims against us for rescission and other damages under federal or state securities laws
Figures reported in this filing
Standardized line items from the XBRL in this filing, for the period ended 2020-09-30. Comparative periods it repeats are left out.
| Line item | Period | Value | XBRL concept |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 3 months2020-07-01 to 2020-09-30 | $5.0m | us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax |
| Revenue | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | $13.7m | us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax |
| Interest expense | 3 months2020-07-01 to 2020-09-30 | $61.1m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Interest expense | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | $160.8m | us-gaap:InterestExpense |
| Income tax | 3 months2020-07-01 to 2020-09-30 | $546.0k | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Income tax | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | $17.2m | us-gaap:IncomeTaxExpenseBenefit |
| Net income | 3 months2020-07-01 to 2020-09-30 | −$42.9m | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Net income | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | −$235.8m | us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss |
| Diluted EPS | 3 months2020-07-01 to 2020-09-30 | −$0.28 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasicAndDiluted |
| Diluted EPS | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | −$1.43 | us-gaap:EarningsPerShareBasicAndDiluted |
| Operating cash flow | 9 months2020-01-01 to 2020-09-30 | $59.2m | us-gaap:NetCashProvidedByUsedInOperatingActivities |
| Cash and equivalents | At period end2020-09-30 | $106.8m | us-gaap:CashAndCashEquivalentsAtCarryingValue |
| Total assets | At period end2020-09-30 | $4.56bn | us-gaap:Assets |
| Total liabilities | At period end2020-09-30 | $3.95bn | us-gaap:Liabilities |
| Long-term debt | At period end2020-09-30 | $3.73bn | us-gaap:LongTermDebt |
| Shareholders' equity | At period end2020-09-30 | $589.5m | us-gaap:StockholdersEquity |
Source: SEC EDGAR, the filing index for accession 0001564590-20-054211. Last ingested by Listed: Nov 10, 2026, 01:03 ET. Listed shows no prices and gives no investment advice.